Marvel’s latest X-Men story has changed what defines Rogue, and the change is not small. In Uncanny X-Men, Rogue’s unborn child has begun communicating with her, which Collider’s Hannah describes as a loaded creative decision. It is also one that lands with particular force on a character whose whole history is about unwanted voices inside her head.
The story focuses on Rogue’s pregnancy and the new complication it brings.
Rogue’s History With Motherhood
Rogue has previously expressed that motherhood is not something she wanted. That position is not the problem. Characters change, and a character stating one desire at one point in her life does not obligate every writer who follows to preserve it forever.
The problem, according to Collider, is whether Uncanny X-Men is letting Rogue make that change herself. A fetus communicating with its mother is a loaded creative decision for any character, but for Rogue, whose past is defined by bodily autonomy and unwanted voices inside her head, it becomes impossible to separate from everything that came before.
The Quiz’s Ten Questions
Collider’s quiz asks readers to answer ten questions about their personality, values, and fighting spirit. The questions range from what drives them to do what is right to how they handle a villain who keeps escaping justice. The quiz promises to reveal which Marvel Cinematic Universe hero shares their spirit, values, and instincts.
The questions include:
- What drives you to do what is right?
- Where are you at 2 AM?
- How do you handle a villain who keeps escaping justice?
- How do you feel about keeping a secret identity?
- How do you carry the loss of someone important?
- What is your role when working with a team?
- Where do you draw the line between justice and revenge?
- What does life look like when you’re not saving the world?
- What keeps you up at night?
- What do you do when the battle is lost?
Queens, New York
The quiz reveals that the Marvel hero who matches a reader’s spirit, values, and instincts is Spider-Man. The description ties his personality to Queens, New York, where he carries the weight of the world on shoulders that are younger than they should have to be. He is described as funny, loyal, and endlessly self-sacrificing.
The quiz suggests that readers who answered the questions honestly will find a hero whose code mirrors their own. Spider-Man’s lesson — that great power demands great responsibility — is not a slogan to him, but the code he lives by, even when it costs him everything.
Hell’s Kitchen, New York
For readers who lean toward a darker path, the quiz offers Daredevil as their match. He fights in the shadows between law and chaos, guided by a fierce moral compass that refuses to let the guilty walk free. Matt Murdock’s duality — champion in the courtroom, devil in the alley — mirrors the reader’s own conflict.
The description of Daredevil is relentless, conflicted, and unwilling to stop. It notes that the line between law and chaos has never been easy for him, and it suggests that readers who operate in the grey will find themselves reflected in his story.
Stark Industries, Malibu
Iron Man is the option for readers who lead with their minds and back it up with resources. Tony Stark’s arc — from ego to sacrifice — is described as the reader’s arc too. The quiz suggests that readers who started out looking out for themselves but somewhere along the way made the world their responsibility will find themselves mirrored in Tony’s story.
The description of Iron Man is brilliant, driven, and occasionally insufferable, but always willing to solve the unsolvable problem. It notes that he leads with his mind and backs it up with resources, innovation, and a stubbornness that borders on heroic.
New York City
The Punisher is the option for readers who have been through fire that would break most people. Frank Castle’s war is born from love twisted by loss, and the reader’s own war is described as being born from the same grief. The Punisher’s code is forged in grief, and the reader’s code is described as being unyielding, relentless, and operating by a code that refuses to compromise.
The description of the Punisher is uncompromising and unflinching, and it notes that the world may not agree with his methods, but his conviction is absolute. It suggests that readers who see a corrupt, broken world and have decided to do something about it, consequences be damned, will find themselves reflected in his story.
Asgard and the Nine Realms
Thor is the option for readers who lead with strength but have learned — sometimes painfully — that true greatness comes from humility and growth. His story is one of transformation, from arrogant prince to worthy king. The reader is described as powerful, proud, and on a lifelong journey to become worthy of the legend they carry.
The description of Thor is larger than life, yet more vulnerable than he lets on. It notes that he leads with strength but has learned — sometimes painfully — that true greatness comes from humility and growth. It suggests that readers who are powerful and proud but vulnerable will find themselves reflected in his story.
A Comparison of the Four Heroes
| Hero | Home | Characterization |
|---|---|---|
| Daredevil | Hell’s Kitchen, New York | Relentless, conflicted, unwilling to stop |
| Iron Man | Stark Industries, Malibu | Brilliant, driven, occasionally insufferable |
| Punisher | New York City | Unyielding, relentless, forged in grief |
| Thor | Asgard, Protector of the Nine Realms | Powerful, proud, on a lifelong journey |
The Problem With Rogue’s Pregnancy
The issue is that Rogue’s unborn child can communicate with her. That is a loaded creative decision for any character, but for Rogue, whose history is tied to bodily autonomy, unwanted voices inside her head, and the fight to determine where other people end and she begins, it becomes impossible to separate from everything that came before.
The question of whether Uncanny X-Men is letting Rogue make that change herself has become considerably more complicated now that the fetus can speak. A character expressing one desire at one point in her life does not mean every writer who follows is obligated to preserve it forever. The problem is whether Rogue gets to make that change herself.
The Verdict on Rogue’s Change
Collider’s coverage of Rogue’s pregnancy is careful. It acknowledges that the change itself is not the problem — a character expressing one desire at one point in her life does not obligate every writer who follows to preserve it forever. The problem is whether Rogue gets to make that change herself.
The quiz is available at collider.com, asking readers to answer ten questions about their personality, values, and fighting spirit to find out which MCU hero shares their spirit, values, and instincts. The story of Rogue’s pregnancy continues in Uncanny X-Men, and the question of whether she gets to make that change herself remains open.
Source material: “Marvel’s Latest X-Men Story Officially Changes Everything That Defines Rogue,” Collider.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.