Henry Cavill plays Theseus, a mortal man chosen by Zeus to lead the fight against the ruthless King Hyperion, who is on a rampage across Greece to obtain a weapon that can destroy humanity. That is the setup for Immortals, the 2011 epic fantasy directed by Tarsem Singh and written by Charley Parlapanides and Vlas Parlapanides. The film runs 110 minutes, mixes action, drama and spectacle, and leans heavily on Greek mythology. Its tagline promises a hero the gods need. The execution does not always live up to that promise.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures UK.
Theseus and Hyperion
Cavill carries the film as Theseus, a hoplite trained by the Old Man, who tells him Theseus has been chosen by the gods. Theseus and his mother Aethra are outcasts because Theseus is a bastard child. The setup gives the story a personal stake. When Hyperion attacks the village, Theseus kills many of his men before being captured. He is forced to watch as Hyperion murders Aethra. The loss drives him forward, but the film spends more time on the spectacle of battle than on the grief behind it.
Hyperion, played by Mickey Rourke, is the villain the gods cannot stop. He searches for the Epirus Bow, a weapon that can release the Titans from Mount Tartarus. He captures the virgin oracle Phaedra to use her dreams and visions to find it. The setup is simple: one man hunts a weapon, the gods look on helplessly, and the mortal caught in the middle is Theseus.
The Oracle and the Dream Sequence
Phaedra, played by Freida Pinto, is the film’s anchor. She sees visions that guide both sides. When Hyperion’s guards attack, she and her sisters provoke a riot. She escapes with Theseus and the other slaves. The sequence is visually striking, but it also shows the film’s habit of leaning on spectacle over substance.
“The Gods need a hero.”
That tagline sums up the film’s attitude toward its own mythology. The gods are watching, the humans are fighting, and the story expects the audience to care about the outcome. Sometimes it succeeds. Sometimes it does not.
The Olympians and Their Rules
The Olympians are sympathetic to the humans suffering at Hyperion’s hands, but they are forbidden by Zeus from interfering in mortal affairs. That rule is the engine of the story. Unless the Titans are released, the gods must have faith in mankind’s free will to defeat Hyperion. The other gods are skeptical, noting that mankind’s strength of will is starting to fail. Zeus himself has trained Theseus in the guise of the Old Man, but reasons he has helped him as a human rather than a god.
The problem is that the rules are never explained clearly. The film assumes the audience knows why the gods cannot intervene, and it never bothers to spell it out. This leaves the audience wondering why the gods cannot simply strike Hyperion down, which undercuts the tension of the whole enterprise.
The Battle Against Hyperion
The film’s biggest set piece comes when Theseus pursues Hyperion. His forces are overwhelmed when trying to seize a boat. Poseidon, unseen by Zeus, dives from Olympus into the ocean, causing a tidal wave that wipes out Hyperion’s men. It is a spectacular moment, but it also raises the question of why the gods waited until the final act to help. The film answers that question with a shrug rather than an explanation.
Comparing the Two Sides
| Character | Role | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Theseus | Mortal hero | Determination | Underpowered early |
| Hyperion | Ruthless king | Ruthlessness | Overconfident |
| Zeus | God of gods | Power | Forbidden from intervening |
| Phaedra | Oracle | Visionary | Captive |
The table shows the film’s core conflict. The mortals are determined but outmatched, while the gods are powerful but bound by rules they do not explain. That contrast should make for a tense story. Instead, the film often feels like two separate stories running parallel without ever truly meeting.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The film’s strengths are its visuals and its ambition. Tarsem Singh directs with a bold eye, and the action sequences are staged with flair. The mythology is dense, with references to the Titans, the Olympians and the sacred labyrinth that holds Theseus’s village. The film is not afraid to commit to its fantasy world.
Its weaknesses are structural. The story loses focus in the middle, and the pacing suffers as a result. The emotional beats land unevenly, with some moments feeling hollow next to the spectacle around them. The film wants to be a legend, but it settles for a costume drama.
The film was a commercial success, grossing $227 million, and it received mixed reviews from critics. That mixed reception is reflected in our own judgment. We score it 4.6 out of 10.
That score reflects a film that understands spectacle better than story. It is bigger than it is smart. It is worth seeing for the visual style and the ambition of its staging. It is not worth revisiting for the story it failed to tell.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
