Supergirl premiered in 2015 as a spinoff of The CW’s Arrow universe, and it arrived with a clear mission: to make a superhero show about a young woman who wants to save the world while still figuring out how to live in it. The series follows Kara Danvers, played by Melissa Benoist, as she learns to balance her secret identity as Supergirl with her life as a mild-mannered government analyst.
Trailer, via Movie Trailer Locker.
The Lead Carries the Show
Benoist anchors the series with warmth and physicality. She plays Kara as a character who is genuinely excited to be alive, even when her powers put everyone around her in danger. The show leans into her optimism without losing sight of the emotional weight of being a hero.
The supporting cast also holds up. Calista Flockhart plays Kara’s adoptive mother, a role that requires a grounded presence alongside the show’s more fantastical elements. David Harewood’s Martian Manhunter provides a steady, paternal force, while Mehcad Brooks plays James Olsen as a loyal friend and potential love interest.
Strengths That Set It Apart
- Character-driven drama: The show spends as much time on Kara’s relationships as it does on the villains, which gives the action scenes more stakes.
- Light-hearted tone: Unlike some darker superhero shows, Supergirl keeps its spirit bright, making it easy to watch without feeling weighed down.
- Diverse cast: The show’s lineup includes characters from different backgrounds, which adds texture to its stories.
- Strong musical score: The show’s original score matches the show’s energy without overpowering the dialogue.
Weaknesses That Hold It Back
Not every episode lands with the same strength. Some villains feel interchangeable, and the pacing can drag in midseason episodes. The show also struggles with the challenge of balancing the fun of superheroics with the real-world consequences of its characters’ actions.
Despite these moments, the show’s strengths outweigh its weaknesses. Supergirl succeeds because it commits fully to its premise, delivering a show that is both light and emotionally resonant.
Final Word
Supergirl is a confident, enjoyable entry in the superhero genre. It knows exactly what kind of story it wants to tell and tells it well, with a lead performance that carries the series from start to finish. The show isn’t perfect, but it doesn’t need to be. It simply asks viewers to believe in the idea of a hero who just wants to help people, and it delivers on that promise again and again.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
