Drop Dead Diva ran on Lifetime from 2009 to 2014, and it remains one of the stranger comedies ever to make it onto cable television. Created by Josh Berman, the show follows a vapid model whose soul returns to Earth in the body of a dead lawyer, a setup that sounds like a pitch meeting gone wrong. The show is a fantasy sitcom, a legal drama, and a body-swap comedy, all mixed together in a way that never quite decides what it wants to be. It is also surprisingly sweet, even when it is at its most absurd.
The premise is simple. Deborah “Deb” Dobkins, a vapid model played by Brooke D’Orsay, is killed in a car crash while driving to an audition for The Price Is Right. Her soul arrives at Heaven’s gates and is judged by a gatekeeper named Fred, played by Ben Feldman. Fred declares her a “zero-zero,” since she has performed zero good deeds and zero bad deeds during her time on Earth. Before Fred can send her away, Deb presses the “return” key and is brought back to life in the body of Jane Bingum, a recently deceased lawyer who died protecting her boss Jay Parker from a shooter.
Jane is the complete opposite of Deb. She is brilliant, hard-working, charitable, and plus-sized. Deb finds that Jane works at the same law firm, Harrison-Parker, as Deb’s fiancĂ© Grayson Kent, played by Jackson Hurst. After telling her best friend Stacy Barrett, played by April Bowlby, of her predicament, Deb prepares to tell Grayson the truth about her new body. Fred, meanwhile, is assigned as Deb’s guardian angel, a punishment for letting her escape Heaven. His job is to prevent Deb from telling Grayson the truth and insisting that no one else can know that she is really Deb in Jane’s body.
Trailer, via Sony Pics at Home.
Brooke Elliott’s Double Performance
The show’s entire engine rests on Brooke Elliott playing both sides of the split. She is the vain, shallow Deb who cannot understand why everyone treats her like a genius, and she is the brilliant, selfless Jane who cannot understand why everyone treats her like a fraud. Elliott carries both performances with ease, and the show’s success depends entirely on her ability to switch between them.
The contrast between the two personalities is the show’s main joke. Deb is so vain that she cannot see the world beyond her own reflection, while Jane is so selfless that she cannot understand why anyone cares about her at all. The show leans heavily on this dynamic, and it works best when the two sides are allowed to collide in the same scene. When Deb tries to use Jane’s legal skills to win a case, she often fails because she cannot stop thinking about her outfit or her hair. When Jane tries to be social, she often fails because she cannot stop thinking about the case file in her hands.
The Supporting Cast
The supporting cast helps ground the show’s silliness. Jackson Hurst plays Grayson Kent, Deb’s fiancĂ© and Jane’s colleague, who spends most of the series trying to decide whether he loves the woman he knew or the woman who now wears her body. April Bowlby plays Stacy Barrett, Deb’s best friend, who knows the truth from the start and acts as Deb’s conscience. Kate Levering plays Kim Kaswell, the firm’s other associate, who alternates between being Deb’s rival and her ally. Margaret Cho plays Teri Lee, the firm’s receptionist, who provides comic relief with her blunt honesty.
Lex Medlin plays Owen French, a young lawyer who becomes Jane’s protĂ©gĂ© and eventually falls in love with Deb. The show’s romantic subplot centers on Deb and Owen, who do not realize until the end that Deb is actually Deb in Jane’s body. This creates a classic sitcom situation where two characters fall in love with each other without knowing who they are really falling in love with.
The Legal Cases
The show is set in a law firm, and it features a steady stream of cases that give Deb and Jane a chance to act. The cases are mostly standard legal fare, with clients who are wronged, witnesses who lie, and judges who are unreasonable. The show rarely explains the law in detail, and it never expects the audience to keep track of the finer points of contract law or torts. Instead, it focuses on the emotional stakes of each case, which allows the show to treat the legal system as a backdrop rather than a subject.
The cases serve a dual purpose. They provide a reason for Deb and Jane to interact with each other, since Deb often tries to sabotage Jane’s work or take credit for it. They also provide a reason for Deb to learn lessons about self-esteem and personal acceptance, since the cases often involve clients who are judged by their appearance rather than their actions. This gives the show a moral core beneath its surface, even when the jokes are at their most superficial.
The Body-Swap Premise
The body-swap premise is the show’s biggest asset and its biggest liability. It allows the show to explore themes of identity and acceptance in a way that a conventional sitcom could not. Deb learns to accept her new body and her new personality, while Jane learns to embrace the vanity that she once despised. The show’s message is that who you are is not defined by your body, but by your actions and your choices.
At the same time, the premise limits the show’s scope. Once Deb is in Jane’s body, there is no way out, and the show has to find new ways to sustain the situation over six seasons. The show eventually introduces a second body-swap, where the real Jane Bingum, played by Natalie Hall, reappears in another person’s body after she also pressed the return key. This allows Deb to finally reveal the truth to Grayson, who has become one of Jane’s closest friends.
The Cancellation and Renewal
The show’s history with Lifetime is part of its lore. In January 2013, Lifetime canceled the series after its fourth season. That March, the network reversed its decision and renewed the series for a fifth season that premiered in June 2013. In October 2013, Lifetime renewed the series for a sixth and final season. The show ended in 2014, having completed its run of 78 episodes across six seasons.
The cancellation and renewal cycle shows how close the show came to ending early. The show’s creators had to fight to keep it alive, and the show’s fans had to wait to find out what happened. The show’s final season resolved the central conflict by allowing Deb to reveal the truth to Grayson and to accept her new body. The show ended on a note of resolution, even though the journey there was full of twists and turns.
The Sixth Season
The sixth season is where the show earns its reputation as a sweet finale. Deb finally tells Grayson the truth about her body, and Grayson accepts her despite everything she has put him through. The show ends with Deb in Jane’s body, surrounded by her friends, and the show’s final image is one of acceptance and happiness. It is a rare ending for a show that spent so much of its run focused on conflict and tension.
The show’s final season also resolves the Owen subplot, with Deb and Owen realizing that they are actually falling in love with each other. The show’s final episode brings all of the threads together, with Deb, Grayson, Owen, Stacy, Kim, and Teri all present to support each other. It is a warm conclusion to a show that was often warm but often silly.
The Verdict
Drop Dead Diva is a show that is better than its premise suggests. It is a body-swap comedy dressed up as a legal drama, but it is also a show about acceptance, identity, and the value of a life well-lived. The show’s strength comes from its cast, particularly Brooke Elliott, and from its willingness to explore serious themes through light-hearted comedy. It is not a perfect show, and it is not a show that will appeal to everyone, but it is a show that rewards patience and attention.
The show’s weaknesses are predictable. The cases are formulaic, the jokes are often obvious, and the premise is stretched thin over six seasons. The show also relies too heavily on its central gimmick, and it never fully explores the implications of a soul living in the wrong body. These flaws are not fatal, but they are noticeable.
The show’s strengths outweigh its flaws. The show is consistently watchable, and it is often genuinely funny. The show’s heart is in the right place, even when its execution is not. The show is a product of its time, and it reflects the values of its era, but it is also a show that has aged gracefully.
Drop Dead Diva is a show that deserves its place in the pantheon of cult classics. It is a show that rewards repeat viewing, and it is a show that has earned its reputation. It is not a masterpiece, but it is a show that is worth your time. If you have not seen it, you should. If you have seen it, you will remember why you liked it.
The show’s final image is one of Deb, in Jane’s body, surrounded by her friends, and it is a fitting end to a show that was always about finding your place in the world. The show’s message is simple: you are not defined by your body, you are defined by your choices. It is a message that is easy to dismiss, but it is a message that is worth hearing.
Key Facts Box
- Network: Lifetime
- Creator: Josh Berman
- Premiere: July 12, 2009
- Finale: June 22, 2014
- Seasons: 6
- Episodes: 78
- Cast: Brooke Elliott, April Bowlby, Jackson Hurst, Kate Levering, Margaret Cho, Lex Medlin
Ranking the Seasons
- Season 6 — the finale, which resolves the central conflict and delivers a satisfying ending
- Season 5 — the renewal season, which picks up where the cancellation left off
- Season 4 — the season that was canceled, which sets up the show’s future
- Season 3 — the middle period, which explores the show’s core themes
- Season 2 — the early period, which establishes the show’s premise
- Season 1 — the pilot season, which introduces the characters and the rules
The ranking is based on the show’s overall quality and its contribution to the larger story. The finale is the strongest because it resolves the show’s central conflict. The renewal season is strong because it picks up where the cancellation left off. The other seasons are weaker because they rely too heavily on the show’s central gimmick.
Drop Dead Diva is a show that is worth your time, even if it is not a show that will change your life. It is a show that is fun, and it is a show that is sweet. It is a show that is silly, and it is a show that is sincere. It is a show that is flawed, and it is a show that is memorable. It is a show that deserves its place in the pantheon of cult classics, and it is a show that you should watch if you have the chance.
The show’s final image is one of Deb, in Jane’s body, surrounded by her friends, and it is a fitting end to a show that was always about finding your place in the world. The show’s message is simple: you are not defined by your body, you are defined by your choices. It is a message that is easy to dismiss, but it is a message that is worth hearing.
6 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
