Park Chan-wook’s Stoker wants to be a slow-burning Southern Gothic mystery, but it keeps getting pulled back toward a thriller that wants to be faster than its own setup can justify. The film follows India Stoker, played by Mia Wasikowska, as she learns her uncle Charlie, played by Matthew Goode, is moving into the family house after her father Richard’s sudden death. The premise is promising. The execution keeps losing focus.
Trailer, via SearchlightPictures.
India Stoker and the Family
India is a withdrawn, observant teenager whose world shrinks even further after her father’s death. Her mother Evie, played by Nicole Kidman, is described as emotionally disturbed, which the film leans on for tension rather than depth. Dermot Mulroney plays Richard, and Jacki Weaver plays Aunt Gin, India’s great-aunt, whose arrival sets the plot in motion.
Charlie arrives unannounced and immediately becomes a presence India cannot shake. His dark charisma draws Evie in, while India watches him from a distance, suspicious of his motives. The film spends its early runtime establishing this dynamic, and it works best when it stays grounded in the domestic space of the family house.
The Mystery Deepens
The plot thickens when Mrs. McGarrick, the head caretaker, disappears. Charlie and Evelyn grow closer, and India’s attempts to push him away fail. Then Aunt Gin shows up, and things take a darker turn. She expresses doubt about Charlie’s travels and changes hotels out of fear, losing her phone and trying to call the Stokers’ home from a phone booth.
Charlie arrives at the booth and strangles Gin with his belt. India discovers Mrs. McGarrick’s body in the freezer and realizes Charlie is a murderer. That moment is the film’s strongest payoff, and it should carry the rest of the story. Instead, the film keeps adding threads — a school bully named Chris Pitts, played by Lucas Till, whom India stabs with a pencil; a classmate named Whip Taylor, played by Alden Ehrenreich, who attempts to rape India — that dilute the central mystery rather than building on it.
What Works and What Doesn’t
The film’s strengths are its performances and its atmosphere. Mia Wasikowska brings a quiet intensity to India that holds the screen through long stretches of dialogue. Nicole Kidman plays Evie with a fragile edge that keeps her from being a cartoon. Matthew Goode’s Charlie is the most compelling presence in the film, a man who moves through the story with a sense of purpose that makes everyone around him uneasy.
The film also knows how to build dread. Park Chan-wook, working in English for the first time, shows a sure hand with lighting and composition, creating a sense of unease that lingers long after a scene ends. The film’s tagline, “Innocence ends,” captures its thematic concern with coming-of-age and loss, even if the execution doesn’t fully live up to it.
Where the film falters is in pacing and coherence. The middle section drags, with too much time spent on secondary characters and their reactions rather than on the central mystery. The film introduces a school bully and a potential rapist without giving either thread enough room to resolve cleanly. The result is a film that feels unfinished, as if it were cut down from a longer version that needed more time to breathe.
The Verdict
Stoker is a film with a good idea and a talented cast that can’t quite escape its own excess. The performances are strong, the atmosphere is strong, but the plot keeps losing its thread. The film’s best moments come when it trusts its central relationship between India and Charlie, and its worst moments come when it tries to pile on more violence and more suspects.
It’s a film that rewards patience but punishes itself for not trusting its own setup.
Key Facts Box
- Director: Park Chan-wook
- Writer: Wentworth Miller
- Runtime: 99 minutes
- Release date: 1 March 2013 (US release via Fox Searchlight Pictures)
Cast
- Mia Wasikowska as India Stoker
- Nicole Kidman as Evie Stoker
- Matthew Goode as Charlie Stoker
- Dermot Mulroney as Richard Stoker
- Jacki Weaver as Aunt Gin Stoker
Plot Points
- Charlie announces he is staying indefinitely to help support India and Evie
- Mrs. McGarrick disappears and is later found dead in the freezer
- Aunt Gin is strangled by Charlie at the phone booth
- India stabs Chris Pitts with a pencil at school
- Whip attempts to rape India before Charlie intervenes and breaks his neck
The film’s ambition is visible in its framing and its cast, but its discipline isn’t quite there. Stoker is a film worth seeing for its atmosphere and its actors, but it falls short of the mystery it promises to deliver.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
