Kirk Kettner is a TSA agent at Pittsburgh International Airport, and he has a problem: he is dating Molly McCleish, a drop-dead gorgeous party planner who is clearly out of his league. That is the premise of “She’s Out of My League,” and it should work. It does not.
Jim Field Smith directs from a script by Sean Anders and John Morris, and the film runs 104 minutes. It stars Jay Baruchel as Kirk and Alice Eve as Molly, with supporting turns from T.J. Miller, Mike Vogel, Nate Torrence, Krysten Ritter, Geoff Stults and Lindsay Sloane. The movie was filmed in Pittsburgh and finished production in 2008, then released by Paramount Pictures on March 12, 2010. It grossed $49.8 million against a $20 million budget.
Trailer, via hollywoodstreams.
Kirk and Molly
Baruchel plays Kirk as a nervous, awkward TSA agent who cannot believe his luck. Eve plays Molly as confident and successful, the kind of woman who should not be interested in someone like Kirk. The setup is simple and effective. What follows is not.
The Friends Who Doubt
Kirk’s friends and family warn him constantly that the relationship will not last. Stainer, played by T.J. Miller, ranks everyone on a scale of 0 to 10 and calls Kirk a “5.” Devon, played by Nate Torrence, is sensitive and married the only girl he ever kissed. Mike Vogel’s Jack provides helpful advice, and Lindsay Sloane’s Marnie is Kirk’s ex-girlfriend who now despises him.
Patty’s Skepticism
Krysten Ritter plays Patty, Molly’s sarcastic best friend, who thinks Molly chose Kirk only because he is “safe” and will not hurt her. This is the movie’s central tension: everyone around Kirk believes Molly will leave him, and the film spends its runtime proving them right.
The Date That Never Comes
On their date, Kirk tells Molly he dreams of being a pilot. She tells him she almost became something else. The conversation stops there. The film never delivers on its promise of showing what happens when Molly gets to know the real Kirk.
The Numbers Behind the Film
| Detail | Figure |
|---|---|
| Budget | $20 million |
| Gross | $49.8 million |
| Runtime | 104 minutes |
Where It Falls Short
The film’s problem is structural. It sets up a conflict — Kirk’s insecurity versus Molly’s attractiveness — and then mostly avoids resolving it. The jokes about Kirk being out of his league are repeated again and again, and the movie never finds a way to make them feel fresh.
The supporting cast is wasted. Miller’s Stainer is a comic creation begging for more screen time, and Vogel’s Jack could have provided real warmth. Instead, the film leans on cheap gags about Kirk’s appearance and his inability to connect with Molly.
The Verdict
“She’s Out of My League” is a film with a good idea and a weak execution. It is funny in spots, but the humor is predictable and thin. The romantic tension never builds, and the ending feels rushed and unsatisfying.
The film earns a 4.6 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
