President Trump hosted President Xi Jinping of China for nearly two days of ceremony in Washington, and the two leaders appeared to enjoy each other’s company throughout the visit. They strolled together at the National Archives, where they viewed original copies of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. The visit included a state dinner. And they left behind a set of small, partial agreements that fall short of the full reset both sides had hoped for.
The Archives Visit
At the National Archives, Trump joked that China has 6,000 years of history, which is longer than even Chinese estimates. Xi responded by praising the U.S. founding spirit from 250 years ago. The exchange was warm, if somewhat vague.
The Trade Truce
The most concrete outcome was a temporary extension of a trade agreement regarding rare earths. The U.S. confirmed the extension by two months through January. That is far shorter than what both sides hoped for.
Feng reported that mutual distrust scuppered the possibility of a longer extension. The deal is now temporary, not permanent.
Tariffs and Other Announcements
The U.S. and China are expected to announce joint tariff reductions on about $30 billion of goods on both sides soon. Trump also mentioned that Iran came up in talks with Xi, though he did not provide details. China is a major economic supporter of Iran and bought up most of Iran’s oil exports in the past.
Unresolved Issues
Not everything was settled. Artificial intelligence remains a sticking point, and Taiwan remains an unresolved issue between the two governments. Rob Schmitz recalled that shortly after Trump won the 2016 election, he took a congratulatory call from the president of Taiwan, breaking decades of diplomatic protocol and the One China policy.
Trump was quick to criticize China and Xi at that time for taking part in America’s economic decline. Now, a decade later, Trump is showering Xi with praise and hosting a lavish welcome.
Chinese Media Coverage
Chinese state-run media coverage this week showed an American president staging VIP treatment for his Chinese counterpart, similar to U.S. media imagery. The messaging shows the world’s biggest superpower regards China as an equal, a powerful message to the people of China.
China’s economy is currently sluggish, and many people are questioning whether the government can continue to promise real economic growth. The visit offered a moment of warmth, but it did not address the underlying tensions.
What Actually Changed
The visit produced three tangible outcomes:
- A two-month extension of the rare earths trade agreement, expiring in January.
- Expected joint tariff reductions on about $30 billion of goods.
- Acknowledgment that Iran was discussed, though details were not provided.
None of these are game-changers. The rare earths extension is temporary, and the tariff reductions are expected to be announced soon. The AI and Taiwan disputes remain unresolved.
The temporary nature of the rare earths extension is telling. Both sides wanted a longer deal, but distrust got in the way. That is a pattern worth noting.
The visit also raised questions about consistency. Trump criticized China and Xi over America’s economic decline in 2016, yet now he is hosting Xi with lavish pomp. The shift in tone is visible, but the underlying substance of the relationship has not changed.
The Chinese media framing — an American president treating China as an equal — is a powerful message to the people of China. But it is a message, not a policy.
What Comes Next
The January expiration of the rare earths extension means the question of a longer deal will return soon. The tariff reductions are expected to be announced soon.
The unresolved issues — AI and Taiwan — will not go away on their own. They will require sustained attention from both leaders.
The visit was a success at being a visit. It was not a success at resolving the underlying conflict between the world’s two largest economies.
It was a display, not a decision.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs keeping the channels open for trade and diplomacy between the two countries and is against a foreign policy built around confrontation. The visit produced a few modest, temporary agreements and some warm words, but the underlying disputes over artificial intelligence and Taiwan remain unresolved.
The rare earths extension is temporary rather than permanent, and the tariff reductions are still expected to be announced. The visit was a display of warmth, not a decision. The underlying substance of the relationship has not changed, despite the shift in tone since 2016.
The January expiration of the rare earths extension will bring the question of a longer deal back into focus. The unresolved issues of AI and Taiwan will require sustained attention from both leaders. The paper will continue to watch how the two sides handle these disputes, and whether the channels stay open for trade and diplomacy.
Source material: “Trump gave Xi Jinping a warm welcome. What did the talks accomplish?,” NPR.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.