Claude Zidi’s Asterix and Obelix Take On Caesar wants to be a grand comedy-adventure for the whole family, and it mostly succeeds — even if the magic potion that powers the story gets used less often than it should. This 1999 adaptation of the beloved comic books sets its action in 50 B.C., with Asterix and Obelix defending their small, well-protected village against the Romans. The film runs 109 minutes, and it draws on genres like Family, Adventure, Comedy, and Fantasy.
Trailer, via Haffi Hellfire.
The Gauls Are Revolting
The setup is simple. A magic potion made by Druids turns the villagers into mighty soldiers. When Roman troops carve a path through Gaul toward the English Channel, Caesar and his aide de camp Detritus find out about the secret elixir and capture the Druid leader who knows its formula. Asterix and Obelix are sent off to rescue him.
Christian Clavier plays Astérix, and Gérard Depardieu plays Obélix. The pairing works, with Depardieu’s physical comedy carrying much of the film’s humor. Roberto Benigni appears as Lucius Detritus, and Michel Galabru plays Abraracourcix. Claude Piéplu appears as Panoramix, Daniel Prévost as Prolix, Pierre Palmade as Assurancetourix, Laetitia Casta as Falbala, Arielle Dombasle as Mme Agecanonix, Sim as Agecanonix, Marianne Sägebrecht as Bonemine, and Gottfried John as Jules César.
The Potion That Carries the Story
The magic potion is the film’s engine, and it is used sparingly. That is the film’s biggest problem. A comedy that depends on a magical ingredient should let that ingredient shine, but the film spends too much time on chase scenes and political maneuvering instead. The result is a movie that feels more like a standard adventure comedy than a story about a village protected by a secret drink.
The Villagers Who Get Short Shrift
The supporting cast is strong, but the villagers get short shrift. Michel Galabru’s Abraracourcix and Claude Piéplu’s Panoramix carry their scenes well, but the film spends little time showing the full community that makes the village work. The village itself is a minor presence, and the film rarely lets viewers feel what life there is really like.
The Cast That Makes It Work
The performances hold the film together. Depardieu’s physical comedy is a highlight, and Benigni’s Lucius Detritus brings energy to a role that could easily play as a stock villain. The film’s tone stays light throughout, which helps cover some of its weaker moments.
What Works
- The chemistry between Clavier and Depardieu drives the film’s best scenes
- Benigni’s performance adds a layer of unpredictability
- Gottfried John’s Caesar brings menace without becoming cartoonish
- The film’s sense of humor stays consistent throughout
Where It Falls Short
- The magic potion gets used less often than it should
- The village and its people feel like a backdrop rather than a living community
- Some chase scenes stretch the runtime without adding much
- The pacing sags in the middle of the film
Asterix and Obelix Take On Caesar is a solid, if uneven, entry in the franchise. It has a strong cast and a clear sense of humor, but it struggles to live up to the very thing that makes the stories special. The magic potion that protects the village deserves more screen time, and the village itself deserves more attention.
The film is a good time, but it falls short of greatness.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
