“The Quick and the Dead” wants to be a Western that breaks the genre’s rules, and it mostly succeeds. Sam Raimi directs Sharon Stone, Gene Hackman, Russell Crowe and a young Leonardo DiCaprio in a shoot-em-up that trades romance for speed. The film is a quick-draw elimination tournament set in Redemption, a town run by the ruthless Herod. The Lady, a mysterious gunfighter, rides in to get even for her father’s death.
Trailer, via Unseen Trailers.
The Tournament Rules
The setup is simple. Herod runs a single-elimination contest where any contestant can challenge any other, no challenge can be refused, and fights continue until one contestant yields or dies. That’s the whole movie in one sentence.
Herod kills Ace Hanlon early, a braggart who took credit for some of Herod’s outlaw kills. The Lady and The Kid win their matches easily. Cort, a preacher who renounces violence, gets a cheap gun from Herod that holds only one bullet at a time. He still wins his first-round duel, drawing despite himself. Herod kills Clay Cantrell, a hired gun, before the quarterfinals, declaring all duels now to the death.
The Cast Against the Setting
Stone plays The Lady as cold and calculating, a woman who doesn’t care about the prize money. Hackman plays Herod as pure evil, a mayor who runs the town with fear. Crowe plays Cort as a man who can’t help himself, a preacher who draws anyway. DiCaprio plays The Kid as a young man who thinks Herod is his father, hoping to earn his respect by winning the tournament.
The supporting cast fills out the field. Tobin Bell plays Dog Kelly, Keith David plays Sergeant Cantrell, Lance Henriksen plays Ace Hanlon, Pat Hingle plays Horace, Gary Sinise plays Marshall, Mark Boone Junior plays Scars. Roberts Blossom plays Doc Wallace, and Kevin Conway plays Eugene Dred.
The Tournament Schedule
| Round | Match | Result |
|---|---|---|
| First | Herod vs. Ace Hanlon | Herod wins |
| First | The Lady vs. opponent | Wins |
| First | The Kid vs. opponent | Wins |
| First | Cort vs. opponent | Wins |
| Quarterfinals | Herod vs. Cort | Herod wins |
| Quarterfinals | The Lady vs. The Kid | The Lady wins |
The Film’s Legacy
The movie opened poorly at the box office, earning mixed reviews on release. Years later, critics have warmed to it, praising the performances, direction, cinematography and score. Some call it underrated in Raimi’s catalog.
That reputation is fair. The action scenes are fast and brutal, and the performances hold up better than the script. Stone is cool and confident, Hackman is unhinged, Crowe is tense, and DiCaprio is awkward and desperate. The film also stands apart from standard Western fare, with a focus on quick-draw contests rather than horseback chases.
The Verdict
The film is uneven. The premise is strong, the execution is weaker. The tournament format gives the movie a structure, but the pacing drags in stretches, and some fights feel rushed while others drag on too long. The dialogue leans on exposition that could have been trimmed.
The Lady’s reasons for entering the tournament are thin, and her relationship with The Kid feels underwritten. The film also leans heavily on spectacle over character, which limits the emotional weight of its final act.
The film earns a 4.9 out of 10. It’s a solid, occasionally great Western that falls short of greatness due to a thin script and a few too many slow stretches. Stone, Hackman, Crowe and DiCaprio carry it, and the quick-draw tournament gives it a unique identity. It’s a flawed gem worth revisiting, not a masterpiece.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
