“The Mindy Project” is a sitcom about a doctor who cannot stop dating. That premise sounds simple, and mostly it is. Mindy Lahiri, played by creator Mindy Kaling, runs a small OB-GYN practice in New York City while trying to find love and keep her job. The show ran for six seasons on Fox before moving to Hulu, where it ended in 2017.
The core problem is that Lahiri is constantly falling for men who are either unavailable or wrong for her. The comedy comes from her inability to see it. The show is warm, messy, and often funny, but it rarely goes deeper than its own jokes.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures Home Entertainment UK.
Lahiri’s Problem
Lahiri is the kind of woman who tells her patients they can do anything, then spends her nights making bad choices. She is confident, sometimes annoyingly so, and she talks too much. Her co-workers tolerate her because she is good at her job, even if she is terrible at relationships.
Danny Castellano, played by Ed Weeks, is her best friend and love interest. He is a Catholic man with a sharp tongue and a soft spot for Lahiri. Their banter is the engine of the show, and it works because Weeks plays the cynic while Kaling plays the optimist. Their scenes together are the show’s high points.
Jeremy Reed, played by Ike Barinholtz, manages the practice. He is a British doctor who is awkward and charming in equal measure. Morgan Tookers, played by Barinholtz, is a former prisoner who became a nurse. Tamra Webb, played by Xosha Roquemore, is a blunt nurse. Beverly, played by Beth Grant, is a receptionist with a wandering eye. Colette Kimball-Kinney, played by Fortune Feimster, and Dr. Jody Kimball-Kinney, played by Garret Dillahunt, round out the group.
The show is at its best when it focuses on these characters and their interactions. Lahiri’s coworkers are quirky, and the show leans into that quirkiness without losing sight of their humanity. They are all trying to live normal lives in a job that is anything but normal.
The Romantic Comedies
Each episode is structured around a romantic complication. Lahiri meets a new man, he is perfect, then something goes wrong. The show is full of these plots, and they follow a familiar pattern:
- Lahiri meets a new guy.
- They connect over a shared interest.
- He has a flaw she ignores.
- The flaw becomes a problem.
- Lahiri realizes she should have listened to her instincts.
- She moves on, or he moves on, and the cycle begins again.
This structure is predictable, but it is also effective. The show knows what it is doing, and it does not try to be something else. It is a romantic comedy, and it delivers on that promise.
The problem is that the show rarely questions its own premise. Lahiri is always the one who makes mistakes, and the show rarely asks why. There is a pattern to her behavior, but the show does not examine it. Instead, it simply repeats the cycle.
The Season Changes
The show went through several cast changes during its run. Stephen Tobolowsky’s role was eliminated after the second episode, and he returned in voice-over only in the eighth episode to explain that his character had retired. Amanda Setton’s role was also eliminated, and Anna Camp was downgraded to a recurring cast member. Both left after the twelfth episode, and neither character was mentioned again.
For the second season, Xosha Roquemore was upgraded to a series regular role after recurring in the final three episodes of the previous season. Adam Pally was also upgraded to a series regular role just prior to the production of the season’s fifth episode. He had previously signed onto the series in a recurring role but had filmed only two episodes prior to being promoted.
In the third season, Zoe Jarman’s role was eliminated from the show. Like Setton and Camp’s departures in the first season, the absence of her character was never addressed. Adam Pally left the series after the season’s thirteenth episode, a condition of his upgrade.
These changes kept the show fresh, but they also disrupted the chemistry that had developed between the actors. The show never fully recovered from losing key performers, and the later seasons felt thinner as a result.
The Hulu Move
The move from Fox to Hulu changed the show’s tone. The network switch happened in the middle of the sixth season, and it marked a shift in the show’s identity. The show became more intimate, less reliant on big set pieces, and more focused on the characters themselves.
The move was a practical decision, but it also allowed the show to explore different stories. Without the constraints of broadcast television, the show could be more explicit and more honest about relationships. The final season benefited from this freedom, even if it meant the show was less accessible to casual viewers.
The Verdict
“The Mindy Project” is a solid sitcom that never quite reaches greatness. It is consistently funny, and it has a heart that shines through its flaws. The show is at its best when it slows down and lets its characters breathe. Those moments are rare, but they are memorable.
The show’s biggest weakness is its unwillingness to challenge its own premise. Lahiri is a character who makes the same mistakes over and over, and the show never asks why. It is a romantic comedy, and it does not need to be more than that, but it could have been better if it had explored Lahiri’s patterns.
The show is also uneven across its seasons. The first few seasons are strong, but the later ones suffer from cast changes and a loss of focus. The Hulu move helped, but it could not fix everything.
Here is how the show’s strengths and weaknesses break down:
- Strong lead performance: Kaling brings energy and charisma to the role.
- Solid supporting cast: The ensemble is well-chosen and well-used.
- Consistent humor: The show is reliably funny, even when it is predictable.
- Weak character development: Lahiri’s mistakes are never questioned or explained.
- Uneven seasons: Later seasons suffer from cast changes and a lack of direction.
“They didn’t really want Mindy to have a boss in the office.”
That line sums up the show’s approach to storytelling. The show is comfortable with its characters, but it is uncomfortable with its own questions. It is a show about a woman who cannot stop dating, and it never asks why she cannot stop.
The show ended in 2017, and it remains a cult favorite. It is not a classic, but it is a comfort watch. It is a show that knows what it is and does not apologize for it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
