Stephen King’s “Bag of Bones” arrives on A&E as a two-part miniseries, and it wants to do two things at once: grieve a husband and wife, and scare a man who sees dead people. The grief lands harder than the scares. Pierce Brosnan plays Mike Noonan, a bestselling novelist whose wife Jo dies suddenly in a bus accident. The series follows him as he retreats to their lakeside cabin in Maine, where he gets pulled into a custody fight over a young widow’s child, and where he starts seeing Jo’s ghost, a 1930s singer named Sara Tidwell, and a local history of fathers drowning their daughters in the lake.
It is a slow burn, and it knows it is a slow burn. The first episode sets up the tragedy and the cabin, the second ramps up the supernatural tension, and both lean heavily on Brosnan’s performance to hold the middle together. The series is based on King’s 1998 novel of the same name, adapted for television by Matt Venne from a screenplay by Mick Garris, who also directs.
Trailer, via Simon & Schuster Books.
Mike’s Grief Is The Real Horror
Brosnan plays Mike as a man who can’t move past the loss. He suffers writer’s block, has nightmares about the cabin, and watches his wife’s ghost appear around him. The script spends real time in the aftermath, showing Mike’s numbness and his inability to write, before the supernatural elements kick in. That patience pays off. When the ghost stories arrive, the audience already cares about Mike because we’ve spent an hour with him before he sees anything strange.
The supporting cast helps keep the human drama grounded. Annabeth Gish plays Jo, and Melissa George plays Mattie Devore, the widow whose child is caught in the custody battle with Mike. Matt Frewer plays Sid, Mike’s brother, and William Schallert plays Max Devore, the wealthy grandfather who wants custody of Kyra. The series leans on these relationships to anchor the horror, so when the ghost stories start, the stakes feel personal rather than abstract.
Sara Tidwell And The Drowning History
Sara Tidwell is the ghost who plays records of her own music, and she appears in Mike’s dreams of her last day alive in 1939. Her presence gives the series a historical hook — the town’s dark history of fathers drowning their daughters in the lake, a local legend called “Dark Score Crazy.” This folklore adds texture to the setting, but it also slows the pacing further. The series jumps back and forth between Mike’s present grief, his nightmares, and flashbacks to Sara’s life, and some viewers may find that structure less compelling than the novel’s original narrative.
The custody battle between Mattie and Max is the engine that moves the story forward. Max offers Mike a deal: he will drop the custody fight if Mike agrees to leave them alone and not press charges. Mike agrees, and Max commits suicide afterward. The resolution feels rushed, almost as though the series needed to end before the plot could fully resolve itself. The finale ties the ghosts, the drowning legend, and the custody fight together, but it does so quickly, leaving the emotional weight of the earlier episodes hanging in the air.
Brosnan Holds The Cabin Together
Brosnan carries the series through its slow stretches. He plays Mike as a man who is both grieving and scared, and he manages to make the supernatural moments feel urgent rather than silly. The ghostly visitations escalate naturally from Mike’s nightmares, and Brosnan sells each one with a quiet intensity that keeps the viewer invested even when the plot stalls.
The series also benefits from its setting. Dark Score Lake in Maine is a beautiful, isolated location, and the cabin itself becomes a character of sorts. The series uses the lake to build dread, with the drowning legend lurking beneath the surface of every scene set near the water. The visual style is atmospheric, with muted colors and shadows that suggest the presence of something unseen.
What Works, What Doesn’t
The pacing is the biggest problem. The first episode is mostly setup, and the second episode rushes to tie everything together. Some viewers may find the middle section tedious, particularly the extended sequences of Mike’s nightmares and flashbacks to Sara’s past. The series also leans heavily on exposition, with characters explaining the backstory of the drowning legend and the nature of the ghosts in long conversations rather than showing them through action.
The cast delivers uniformly solid performances across the board, but the script doesn’t always give them room to breathe. The ensemble is large, and the series tries to juggle too many threads at once — the grief, the custody fight, the ghosts, and the local legend — which dilutes the impact of each element.
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Brosnan’s performance | Anchors the series emotionally | None |
| Setting and atmosphere | Beautiful, isolated cabin in Maine | None |
| Story structure | Slow buildup of grief before the supernatural | Middle sections drag, rushed ending |
| Supporting cast | Solid performances across the board | Too many threads, diluted impact |
A Tale Of Grief, Not Of Terror
“Bag of Bones” is at its best when it is about Mike’s grief, and at its worst when it is trying to be a horror show. The supernatural elements are present and effective, but they are secondary to the central tragedy of Mike losing his wife. The series understands this instinctively, which is why Brosnan’s performance holds the whole thing together.
The series is a mixed bag, and its strengths and weaknesses are closely linked. The slow, patient approach to grief is what makes the later horror scenes work, but the slow approach also means the middle section drags. The resolution is rushed, and the local legend of the drowning fathers feels like a subplot that could have been trimmed rather than stretched out.
“Bag of Bones” is a thoughtful, atmospheric adaptation that struggles with pacing. Brosnan’s performance elevates the material, and the setting is genuinely unsettling, but the middle section drags and the ending feels rushed. It is a solid entry in King’s television canon, but it falls short of greatness.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
