“Good Trouble” takes the Fosters out of the house and puts them in a building full of strangers. The result is a sharper, more focused drama than its predecessor, one that finally lets the sisters Callie and Mariana Adams Foster grow up instead of just grow older.
Created by Peter Paige, Bradley Bredeweg, and Joanna Johnson, the series premiered on Freeform in January 2019 and ran for five seasons through March 2024. It follows Callie and Mariana as they move from their family home into a communal apartment building called The Coterie in downtown Los Angeles. The show received universal praise from critics, with its ensemble cast performances, tone, and diverse representations of Gen Z singled out for particular attention. It was nominated for three Teen Choice Awards and two GLAAD Media Awards.
Trailer, via Freeform.
The Move Out
The premise is simple. Callie and Mariana leave the family home behind and start living on their own. Callie becomes a law clerk for Judge Wilson, while Mariana becomes a software engineer. Their new neighbors include Malika Williams, a bartender and political activist; Alice Kwan, an aspiring stand-up comedian and building manager; and Gael Martinez, a bisexual graphic designer who falls for Callie.
The show doesn’t waste time on nostalgia for the old house. It drops the sisters straight into the adult world, complete with rent, jobs, and the awkwardness of sharing a living space with people they barely know. That shift is the whole point. The Fosters was a family drama about connection. Good Trouble is a young adult drama about independence.
Cast and Character Turns
Cierra Ramirez plays Mariana with a quiet strength that anchors the show. She’s the sister who stays behind while Callie moves away, and Ramirez makes that decision feel like a choice rather than a punishment. Maia Mitchell plays Callie as sharp and funny, though her exit in season four, when she joins the ACLU in Washington, D.C., cuts the heart of the series for a stretch.
Zuri Adele brings warmth to Malika, who becomes a steady presence in the apartment. Sherry Cola is a scene-stealer as Alice, the building manager whose jokes and complaints keep the show from getting too heavy. Gael, played by Tommy Martinez, gets the show’s most explicit romantic storyline, and the show handles his bisexuality with care and humor.
Bryan Craig arrives late as Joaquin Peréz, an investigative journalist looking for his estranged sister Jenna. He brings a mystery element the show hadn’t had before. Emma Hunton plays Davia Moss, a body-positive influencer and teacher who adds texture to the cast. Josh Pence plays Dennis Cooper, the oldest tenant and an aspiring musician.
Season Order and Casting
The show’s history is a slow build of additions and departures. Here’s how the seasons break down:
| Season | Premiere Date | Main Cast | Notable Additions |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | January 2019 | Mitchell, Ramirez, Adele, Cola, Martinez, Bart, Pence, Hunton | Mitchell and Ramirez lead the show |
| 2 | June 2019 | Mitchell, Ramirez, Adele, Cola, Martinez, Bart, Hunton, Kirby | Shannon Chan-Kent joins |
| 3 | February 2021 | Mitchell, Ramirez, Adele, Cola, Martinez, Quintana, Blair, Mitchell, Parker, Halevi | Quintana promoted to series regular |
| 4 | 2022 | Ramirez, Adele, Cola, Martinez, Quintana, Stewart, Craig | Mitchell exits as regular |
| 5 | 2023 | Ramirez, Adele, Cola, Martinez, Quintana, Stewart, Craig | Terry and Pinzon join |
The casting process was almost as eventful as the show itself. Tommy Martinez, Zuri Adele, Sherry Cola, and Roger Bart were announced in June 2018. Emma Hunton and Ken Kirby joined as recurring actors. By February 2022, Quintana was promoted to series regular, Bryan Craig joined as a new regular, and Booboo Stewart entered as recurring. Mitchell left both her role and her position as an executive producer to be with her family in Australia, though her character returned as a guest star in season five.
What Works
The show excels at small-scale drama. Its best scenes are kitchen conversations and hallway arguments, not courtroom speeches or political rallies. It trusts its characters to carry weight without spectacle. That trust pays off.
The show also benefits from its setting. The Coterie is a specific, lived-in place, and the show spends time in its hallways and common rooms. It’s a world that feels real, not staged.
The show’s tone is consistent across its run. It balances comedy and drama without tipping into either. It’s a show about growing up, and it never loses sight of why that matters.
Where It Falls Short
The show’s biggest weakness is its pacing. Some seasons drag, particularly the middle ones, where new characters arrive and leave without much purpose. The show’s habit of adding and removing recurring actors means some storylines feel unfinished rather than resolved.
There’s also a sameness to the later seasons. The show repeats its formula of Callie leaving town and Mariana holding things together, and that repetition starts to wear thin over time.
Final Word
“Good Trouble” isn’t perfect, but it’s consistently good. It’s a show that knows what it wants to be and mostly delivers on it. The acting is strong across the board, the writing is sharp, and the show’s commitment to its characters is genuine.
The show’s final season wrapped in March 2024. It ended on a note that felt earned rather than rushed, even if some threads were left hanging. The show’s legacy is secure, with its Teen Choice and GLAAD nominations standing as proof of its cultural impact.
Key Facts
– Premiered: January 2019 on Freeform
– Final episode: March 2024
– Seasons: 5
– Nominated for three Teen Choice Awards and two GLAAD Media Awards
The show earns its high score on craft alone. It’s a drama that respects its audience’s intelligence, and it rewards that respect with honest, well-played stories.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
