MSI’s Katana 15 HX B14W gaming laptop is being reviewed by PC Gamer, and the verdict is mixed — so mixed that the review itself ends with a garbled reference to a “union divided.” The piece praises the laptop’s UK price, its components, and its connectivity, then abruptly stops with a quote from a famous man. It is a review that ends before it finishes, and that ending is the story.
The Laptop’s Specs
The Katana 15 HX B14W packs a Core i7 14650HX CPU, an RTX 5060 GPU, 16 GB of dual-channel 5,600 MT/s DDR5 RAM, and a 2560×1440 IPS-level display running at 165 Hz. It also includes WiFi 6E, Bluetooth, three USB Type-A ports, a USB-C, Ethernet, 3.5 mm audio, and HDMI out. The SSD is a Samsung PM9C1b PCIe 4.0 drive based on Samsung’s Piccolo controller and 236-layer TLC V-NAND, topping out at 7 GB/s read and 5.7 GB/s write.
The laptop is priced at £1,300 in the UK, and PC Gamer calls that a solid deal. The review notes that the price works out to roughly three days of heating this coming winter if you forgo your radiators — a framing that leans on the UK’s notoriously cheap dental care and its reputation for surprisingly good cooking. For a budget gaming laptop, the spec sheet looks strong for the money.
The Pricing Problem
The review’s headline complaint is the pricing split between the US and the UK. In the US, the Katana 15 HX B14W costs $1,800, which PC Gamer describes as absurd. That price puts it near identical specs to the Lenovo Legion 5, which offers a far better OLED screen for less money. The difference between the two prices is $500, and the review frames the disparity as the laptop’s central flaw.
The review’s tone on this point is blunt. It quotes a famous man saying “a union divided cannot stand,” and suggests that MSI’s own division between its US and UK pricing is the real meaning behind that line. The reviewer is clearly irate with the apparent division the laptop has between its US and UK pricing, and the price gap is presented as a reason to avoid the machine entirely.
The Performance Trade-offs
The laptop’s CPU has a 115 W TGP, but the review says it often taps out at half that power. Flailing clock-speeds follow, and the reviewer suspects the issue is CPU bottlenecking. That limitation means the GPU does not get the full headroom it should, and the system’s performance suffers as a result.
The screen is also a sticking point. PC Gamer describes the IPS-level display as underwhelming, noting that the specification “doesn’t look anything” like the promised standard. The review does not specify what exactly is missing, but the implication is that the panel falls short of the marketing promise.
The Build Quality
The review describes the build quality as okay, but nothing special. The laptop has a big bold and ostentatious design, with a hexagonal screen bezel and a body shape that screams “for the gamer.” That aesthetic could be a problem for users who want a machine that travels to business meetings without announcing itself.
The connectivity options are plentiful, though the review notes that you may still need a USB hub or dongle if you want to attach extra peripherals. The reviewer admits that the experience is comfortable enough on the move, and compares it favourably to the Razer Blade 16, which costs a staggering five grand or thereabouts and lacks an Ethernet port.
The Value Question
PC Gamer’s assessment of value is a double-edged sword. In the UK, the laptop is a solid deal. In the US, it is a bad one. The review frames the situation as mostly dependent on which part of the globe you sit, and the conclusion is that the Katana 15 HX B14W is only worth buying if you are in the UK.
The review lists several reasons to buy:
- A cheap UK deal for a versatile laptop
- A CPU and GPU combo that leads the field in ray tracing performance
- A solid spec-sheet for the price
It also lists several reasons not to buy:
- The “gamer” aesthetic, which is big bold and ostentatious
- A CPU and GPU combo that is not fully unlocked
- A screen that does not live up to its IPS-level billing
The review’s final line is a fragment. After describing the screen as underwhelming, it cuts off mid-sentence, leaving readers to wonder what the reviewer was about to say. The garbled reference to a “union divided” that cannot stand is the last word, and it reads as a framing device rather than a failed joke.
What We Make Of It
The review’s own ending is a reminder that reviews are written by humans, and humans sometimes make mistakes. A review that ends mid-sentence is a rare sight, and it speaks to the chaotic nature of the piece as a whole.
The review is funny, it is opinionated, and it is frustrating. The laptop itself is a solid machine for the UK price, but the US price is a deal-breaker, and the performance limitations and the underwhelming screen are real issues. The review captures that tension, but it leaves the reader hanging on what the reviewer was about to say.
The review’s final line is a fragment, and it reads as a framing device rather than a failed joke. The review is titled “MSI Katana 15 HX B14W gaming laptop review,” but it ends before it finishes.
| Region | Price | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| UK | £1,300 | Worth considering |
| US | $1,800 | Not recommended |
The review’s own ending is a reminder that reviews are written by humans, and humans sometimes make mistakes. A review that ends mid-sentence is a rare sight, and it speaks to the chaotic nature of the piece as a whole.
The review is funny, it is opinionated, and it is frustrating. The laptop itself is a solid machine for the UK price, but the US price is a deal-breaker, and the performance limitations and the underwhelming screen are real issues. The review captures that tension, but it leaves the reader hanging on what the reviewer was about to say.
Source material: “MSI Katana 15 HX B14W gaming laptop review,” PC Gamer.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.