New York City is now the first city in America to ban subscription traps. The click-to-cancel rule took effect on Thursday, and it changes how businesses handle automatic payments.
The rule is simple: canceling a subscription must be as easy as signing up. A gym that lets customers join online cannot force them to call or visit in person to end the membership. The city expects the rule to save New Yorkers between $21.5 million and $162.5 million annually.
Samuel Levine, the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) commissioner, says the rollout has been a sharp contrast to his earlier work at the Federal Trade Commission. He calls the city’s implementation “night and day” compared to his FTC experience.
The Rule That Failed at the Federal Level
The idea behind NYC’s rule was tried once before, at the national level. An appeals court struck down a federal version of the rule for procedural issues. That federal effort did not survive.
NYC is taking a different path. Instead of waiting for Washington to act again, the city is enforcing its own version. Levine believes more municipalities will act before the federal government does.
The city’s approach is straightforward. It requires businesses to make canceling as easy as signing up. That means if a company offers online enrollment, it also has to offer online cancellation.
The rule applies to subscription services across the board, from gyms to streaming services to recurring delivery plans. The requirement is the same for every business: the exit door cannot be smaller than the entrance.
How the Portal Works
Complaints can be filed through a new consumer portal. The portal handles unclear subscription terms, delayed cancellations, and undisclosed auto-renewals. DCWP reviews each complaint and may seek refunds or help cancel subscriptions.
Patterned noncompliance at a business could prompt investigation and legal action. Businesses face fines starting at $525 per violation.
The portal was built by the mayor’s Public Interest Technology (PIT) Crew in 10 weeks. That rapid development is notable on its own, but the city’s argument for the portal runs deeper than speed.
Levine says the portal avoids the “chatbot doom loop” problem of the White House’s America.gov. He calls the portal experience far different from going to a DMV to renew a license.
“We proposed this rule this year. We finalized it this year. It’s taking effect this year. This is the speed of government as it should be.”
The Commissioner’s Background
Levine served as the Federal Trade Commission consumer protection chief under Lina Khan. He is now the DCWP commissioner. His perspective on the federal effort is direct: the city’s version is working where the national one stalled.
The FTC under current Chair Andrew Ferguson has taken an initial step toward reestablishing a similar rule. But Levine’s prediction is clear: cities will move faster than the federal government.
What the Rule Covers
The rule applies to any business that charges customers automatically. Whether the service is a gym membership, a streaming subscription, or a monthly delivery plan, the requirement is the same.
A gym that allows online sign-ups cannot require callers or in-person visits to cancel. The rule is designed to remove friction from the cancellation process.
The city’s estimate of savings comes from a range of $21.5 million to $162.5 million annually.
How the Enforcement Works
DCWP reviews complaints and may seek refunds or help cancel subscriptions. Patterned noncompliance at a business could prompt investigation and legal action.
Businesses face fines starting at $525 per violation. Those fines apply per violation, which means a company that fails to comply across multiple subscriptions could accumulate substantial costs.
The State and Local Approach
NYC’s approach is a practical response to a broken national system. The city is using its own powers to protect its residents. The result is a working rule where a federal attempt failed.
Levine sees this as a model for other governments. He describes the FTC rule as a “model” for other governments, and he expects cities to follow NYC’s lead.
The city’s approach is simple: build a portal, enforce the rule, and protect the consumer. The city is moving forward on its own terms.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs the DCWP’s narrow rule and is against any expansion into broader AI or technology regulation that would favor the giants over the small business. The subscription trap rule is a targeted fix for a specific harm, and the city’s implementation is a model of what government can do when it acts with purpose.
The rule covers automatic payments across subscription services, requiring businesses to make canceling as easy as signing up. It is a light-touch approach that aims at a single problem rather than trying to regulate an entire industry.
The paper is against broad new rulebooks, agencies widening their own reach, and rules the biggest firms helped write. A rule like this one — focused, narrow, and aimed at a real harm — is the kind of law that protects people without crushing small businesses.
Key Facts Box
- Rule took effect: Thursday
- Fines start at: $525 per violation
- Annual savings estimated: $21.5 million to $162.5 million
- Portal built in: 10 weeks by PIT Crew
- Commissioner: Samuel Levine, former FTC consumer protection chief under Lina Khan
- FTC chair: Andrew Ferguson
What This Means for New Yorkers
The rule is now live. Anyone who feels trapped in a subscription can file a complaint through the new portal. The city’s promise is that cancellation should be as easy as enrollment.
Levine’s comparison to the DMV is telling. He wants the experience of canceling a subscription to feel nothing like the bureaucratic nightmare of renewing a driver’s license.
The city’s approach is a practical response to a broken national system. It is a working rule where a federal attempt failed.
The portal itself is a small victory. Built in 10 weeks, it avoids the chatbot problems that plagued the White House’s America.gov. That matters because consumer portals are only useful if they actually work.
Clay Tribune supports this kind of targeted regulation. The rule is narrow, focused, and aimed at a real problem. It is the kind of law that protects people without crushing small businesses.
The city’s approach is a model for other governments. More municipalities will likely follow NYC’s lead. The federal government may eventually act, but the city is not waiting.
The rule is now law. New Yorkers can cancel subscriptions with the same ease they signed up for them. That is a change worth noting.
Source material: “NYC is now the first city in America that bans sketchy subscriptions,” The Verge.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.