ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

One Joke About a Dungeon Carries This 2021 Comedy

The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter review: 12 episodes of Noir, Emma and an LP economy that runs on pleasure, with a death condition the show rarely uses.

By mitch·6 min read
A young man stands before a glowing dungeon entrance, ready to descend into the unknown.

The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter ran for 12 episodes on MBS, from January 8 to March 26, 2021. It built its whole premise on a joke most fantasy anime are too embarrassed to make out loud: the hero’s power runs on pleasure.

Noir Stardia, the third son of a minor noble family, does not receive a job as a librarian because more prominent nobles interfere. His childhood friend Emma Brightness then gives him a job offer, and she has a cure for the headaches his rare skill causes him. He wishes to become an adventurer, finds a dungeon, and meets the legendary adventurer Olivia Servant.

That is the engine. Everything else in the show is a delivery system for it.

Advertisement

Trailer, via Crunchyroll.

Noir Stardia and the librarian post he did not get

The setup is small and mean in a way that works. Noir is the third son of a baronet, a noble of the lowest rank, and he is a self-described coward who would like to take it easy. He applies to be a librarian. He does not get it, because more prominent nobles interfere.

That single rejection is the whole reason he ends up at the adventurer’s academy, and the show is smart enough to let it sting before the wish fulfillment starts.

Ryota Osaka voices Noir in the Japanese track. The character is born with the rare Great Sage skill, which hands him unlimited knowledge for a time and then punishes him with terrible headaches. He stops using it. He is, by his own account, not brave. The show never really disputes that.

Emma Brightness and the cure for a headache

Miyu Tomita voices Emma, Noir’s childhood friend and his first love. She has the cure for the headaches: kissing her eases the aftereffects, and the two fall into a routine of kissing, hugging and flirting that reads as genuine affection and also, conveniently, pays out points.

She takes a part-time job as a librarian to work beside him, finds out he did not get the post, and quits shortly after to take the heroes exam with him just to stay at his side.

That is the best-written relationship in the series. Emma is popular with the opposite sex, Noir included. He has been in love with her since childhood and dreams of marrying her. The show does not pretend this is a mystery.

Olivia Servant and the three skills

Inside a secret dungeon, Noir meets Olivia Servant, voiced by Yui Horie, a legendary adventurer trapped inside for centuries. She bestows on him three skills — Create, Bestow and Edit — that let him upgrade his own powers and other people’s by spending LP, or Life Points.

The points come from joyful experiences. They also come with a real cost: if his LP is fully depleted, he can die. That is the one piece of the premise with teeth, and the show returns to it less often than it should. Olivia is the most interesting figure in the cast and gets the least room.

Lola, Luna and Alice fill out the roster

Rumi Okubo voices Lola, Akari Kito voices Luna, and Yuki Nagano voices Alice. The English dub casts Zeno Robinson as Noir and Lizzie Freeman as Emma. The ensemble exists to supply the “alluring members of the opposite sex” the skill description demands, and the show is honest about that function.

The genre tags tell you what you are buying: Animation, Comedy, Action & Adventure, Sci-Fi & Fantasy. It is a comedy first. The action is competent but rarely the point.

What the light novel and manga did first

Meguru Seto wrote the light novel series, illustrated by Note Takehana. It ran online from January 2017 to February 2021 on Shōsetsuka ni Narō, the user-generated novel site. Kodansha picked it up and has published six volumes since August 2017 under the Kodansha Ranobe Books imprint.

Tomoyuki Hino drew the manga adaptation for Kodansha’s Niconico-based Suiyōbi no Sirius service, from May 2018 to June 2023, collected in twelve tankōbon volumes. Seven Seas Entertainment licenses both the light novel and the manga in North America. The anime, by Okuruto Noboru, aired on the Animeism programming block.

That is a long runway for a premise this thin, and it shows in the adaptation’s confidence. The show knows exactly what it is.

The points system is the whole show

Here is the ranking that matters, from most to least successful element of The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter:

  1. The LP economy, which turns affection, meals and flirtation into a spendable resource with a death condition attached.
  2. Emma and Noir’s relationship, which is warm, reciprocal and carries actual history.
  3. Olivia Servant, a centuries-trapped legend who deserves her own arc and does not get one.
  4. The academy setting, which is standard and does little the genre has not already done.
  5. The supporting cast, who are defined almost entirely by their availability to the protagonist’s point balance.

The top two entries are why the show works. The bottom two are why it never becomes more than a good time.

Noir’s Great Sage skill is the cleverest piece of design in the series. Unlimited knowledge that hurts him to use is a real limitation, and the fix — Emma’s kisses — ties his power directly to the one relationship the show bothers to build. The show does not need a villain when it has a headache and a girlfriend.

Where the 12 episodes leave it

One season, 12 episodes, first aired January 8, 2021, last aired March 26, 2021. Noir enrolls at the Hero Academy and uses his skills to improve his power, and the LP system keeps humming underneath.

The light novel serialized online from January 2017 to February 2021, closing before the anime’s March 2021 end date, and the manga ran through June 2023. The source lists one season of 12 episodes and nothing further.

The verdict on The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter

This is a show built on a single good idea, executed with enough charm to carry 12 episodes and not much more. The LP system is the reason to watch. It gives every scene a number attached to it, and the number can kill Noir, which is more stakes than most comedies in this lane bother to install.

The weakness is that the show rarely tests its own rules. The death condition sits there, mentioned, and the series prefers meals and flirting to the risk of actually spending Noir down to nothing. A premise with a blade in it should use the blade.

Emma is the other reason to stay. The childhood-friend romance is not a subplot here; it is the mechanism, and the show treats her feelings as real rather than as a reward dispensed to the hero. Noir has been in love with her since childhood and dreams of marrying her. That is more respect than the genre usually offers the character in her position.

What holds it back is everything around that core. Lola, Luna and Alice are voices and designs more than they are people. The academy is furniture. Olivia, the one figure with genuine mystery behind her, is spent as a tutorial. The Hidden Dungeon Only I Can Enter is a good comedy that could have been a stranger, sharper one.

It is worth your time if the premise sounds funny to you, because the premise is the show. If it does not, no amount of Emma Brightness will fix that. The series knows its audience and serves them without apology, which is its own kind of integrity.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.