The wife believed her husband would eat like her, but when he rejected that, the disagreement grew worse. The tale, known as “Woman’s Unreasonable Expectation For Her Marriage Surfaces After Spouse Refuses Vegetarian Diet,” relates how she spent years telling him she had no issue with his fondness for meat and fish. Now the scent of cooked meat wafts through their house, and quarrels arise in its wake.
The Wife’s Complaint
The woman is angry because her husband declined to become a vegetarian. The narrative first frames her demands as unrealistic, before stepping back to reference research by psychology professor Hal Herzog.
A study by Herzog and his colleagues revealed that both vegetarians and vegans tend to connect themselves with people who also do not eat meat. The findings cover close friendships and romantic relationships. Abandoning meat can thus pose a barrier to dating, with the causes lying in how society views shared meals and drinks.
“Across all cultures, much human social life revolves around the sharing of food and drink,” Herzog wrote. “It’s safe to say that a moral vegetarian would not feel comfortable sitting around a family Christmas dinner table in which the main course was a five-pound hunk of rare rib roast.”
The Couple’s Standoff
So far, the two people have not sat down together to work through their problems. One partner is unwilling to give up meat entirely for now. Given that refusal, finding middle ground seems unlikely, particularly when one person will not bend within reason.
Marisa Cohen, a licensed marriage and family therapist, gave advice on handling the situation. Instead of trying to make your partner believe your plans are the best, approach the discussion with love and compassion, she said.
The idea, according to Cohen, is for partners to cooperate rather than oppose each other. She suggests that a couple might benefit from sitting down together, sorting through their feelings, and then working toward a solution that suits the situation.
What the Research Says
The way vegetarians view themselves ties closely to what they eat, according to Herzog’s findings. His work shows that both vegetarians and vegans tend to bond with other people who don’t eat meat through close friendships and romantic partnerships.
Food carries immense cultural and social weight, and across every society, much human social life revolves around the sharing of food and drink. A moral vegetarian would find it uncomfortable to sit around a family Christmas dinner table where the main course is a five-pound hunk of rare rib roast.
The Way Forward
When you demand your partner live their life the way you want, and they do not wish to, trouble is bound to follow. Cohen warns that small concessions made now can turn into resentment later on, with one person feeling the weight of carrying more than their share.
Finding a solution that satisfies both sides could prove to be the more practical approach. If needed, getting guidance from someone with experience is another course of action worth considering.
The narrative poses a question about identity and what people expect from marriage. Being a vegetarian often forms part of a person’s sense of self, so asking a spouse to give up that way of eating feels like asking them to give up part of who they are. It is a demanding request, which is why the wife’s complaint holds more significance than the headline indicates.
| Stage | Detail |
|---|---|
| Years prior | Wife says she has no problem with husband’s liking for meat and fish |
| Recent events | Husband refuses to go vegetarian |
| Current state | Escalated confrontations over the smell of cooked meat and fish |
| Professional view | Marisa Cohen advises working together from a place of love and compassion |
Research into how diet shapes identity is what the wife’s complaint is not unreasonable in context, even if the headline frames it that way. The story itself acknowledges the depth of the issue, citing Herzog’s work.
Finding common ground through conversation is the sensible approach, according to Cohen. It involves hashing out feelings and arriving at a solution that satisfies both sides. Professional guidance remains available should the circumstances call for it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.