Agatha Christie’s novel And Then There Were None has been adapted for television several times, but the 2015 BBC version starring Charles Dance stands out. It earns an 8.6/10, a score that reflects both its faithful adaptation and its tense, well-crafted direction.
The story follows ten strangers who accept an invitation to a remote island off the Devon coast. Each is hiding a secret, and each is marked for death by a mysterious host. The cast includes Dance as Justice Wargrave, Miranda Richardson as Emily Brent, and Michael Gambon as Thomas Rogers. The ensemble is strong, and the chemistry between actors carries much of the tension.
Trailer, via BBC.
The Island Setting
The location is crucial. The island is isolated, fog-bound, and inhospitable. The production team shot on location in Cornwall, and the landscape reads as a character in itself. The camera lingers on the cliffs, the sea, and the crumbling mansion, building a sense of dread that the script never has to spell out.
The director uses long takes and static shots to let the audience breathe. Characters walk through rooms while the camera stays fixed, and the silence between lines speaks louder than any dialogue. This restraint pays off in the later episodes, when the body count rises and the survivors grow desperate.
The Body Count
The deaths follow the novel’s pattern, with each victim tied to a specific crime committed in their past. The show does not soften these connections. Emily Brent is exposed as a cruel employer. Thomas Rogers is revealed as a thief. The moral weight of each death is heavy, and the show trusts the audience to sit with discomfort rather than explain it away.
The final twist, which reveals the identity of the killer, is a moment of genuine shock. The reveal changes the reading of everything that came before it, and the episode that delivers it earns its reputation.
“Ten little soldiers singing, Ten little soldier boys swinging”
The nursery rhyme that opens each episode returns at the end, and the final image of the empty mansion is chilling.
Sound Design
The score is minimal, and the sound design does most of the work. Footsteps echo in the corridors. A door creaks. A clock ticks. These small details build a sense of unease that the visuals alone could not achieve.
The pacing is steady. The show runs at a deliberate clip, allowing each death to land with full force before moving on to the next. The result is a viewing experience that feels measured rather than rushed.
Final Score
The 2015 adaptation of And Then There Were None is a masterclass in slow-burn suspense. It respects the source material while finding new ways to scare. The performances are uniformly excellent, the setting is atmospheric, and the finale lands with real power.
It is not perfect. Some plot threads feel rushed, and the middle stretch drags slightly, but the strengths outweigh the weaknesses. This is a show that rewards patience and attention, and it leaves a lasting impression.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
