Teen Wolf ran for six seasons and 100 episodes on MTV, from June 5, 2011 to September 24, 2017. It turned a 1985 comedy film into a supernatural teen drama about a high schooler in a California town full of monsters. It won three Saturn Awards for Best Youth-Oriented Television Series and thirteen Teen Choice Awards. The show was a hit. It was also, for long stretches, a mess.
Trailer, via Amazon MGM Studios.
Scott McCall and the Bite
The premise is simple and it holds. Scott McCall, played by Tyler Posey, is a high school student in the fictional town of Beacon Hills. The night before his second year of high school, an alpha werewolf bites him.
He becomes a werewolf. His once-ordinary life is gone.
Jeff Davis developed the series for MTV, and he built it around a clean contrast. Scott starts as an unpopular, unathletic kid who lives with his divorced mother, Melissa, a nurse at Beacon Hills Memorial Hospital. As a werewolf he gains heightened physical abilities and senses far beyond an ordinary human. He also has to control animalistic instincts that get worse with aggression and full moons.
That is the engine. A teenager who wants a normal life keeps getting pulled into a fight he did not ask for. The show understands that the horror and the homework are the same problem.
Stiles, Allison and Derek Hale
Scott does not carry it alone. Dylan O’Brien plays Stiles Stilinski, Scott’s childhood best friend and the son of Beacon Hills Sheriff Stilinski. Stiles has a talent for solving mysteries and a fierce loyalty to the people closest to him. O’Brien also plays the Nogitsune, a demon who possesses Stiles.
Crystal Reed plays Allison Argent, Scott’s first love interest. Allison descends from a long line of werewolf hunters, and her skill with a bow and arrow makes her an asset against the shapeshifters and monsters that roam Beacon Hills. Her father, Chris Argent, is played by JR Bourne. Reed also plays Allison’s ancestor Marie-Jeanne Valet in the fifth season.
Then there is Derek Hale. Tyler Hoechlin plays an older werewolf from a prominent Beacon Hills werewolf family. Derek starts hostile toward Scott and his pack of friends, then becomes a valuable ally. Ian Nelson plays the teenage Derek.
The casting is the show’s best argument for itself. Posey is asked to hold the center, and he does. O’Brien gets the funnier, faster material and lands it. Hoechlin gives Derek a weight the scripts do not always earn.
Lydia Martin Becomes a Banshee
Holland Roden plays Lydia Martin, a popular girl at Beacon Hills High and a close friend of Allison’s. Lydia initially plays down her formidable intelligence, but she is a genius. After an encounter with Derek’s villainous uncle Peter Hale in season one, her own supernatural abilities begin to manifest. She is a banshee.
That turn is the smartest thing Teen Wolf did. Lydia spends the early episodes as a type, and then the show gives her a reason to be strange. Roden plays the shift without announcing it.
Colton Haynes plays Jackson Whittemore, Lydia’s shallow boyfriend in seasons one and two, with a guest spot in season six. Jackson antagonizes Scott and Stiles relentlessly but suffers from inner self-hatred. When a werewolf bites him, the bite turns him into something else: the deadly reptilian kanima.
As new threats emerge, Scott is joined by werecoyote Malia Tate, played by Shelley Hennig; kitsune Kira Yukimura; and Scott’s first beta werewolf, Liam Dunbar, played by Dylan Sprayberry. Linden Ashby plays Noah Stilinski, and Melissa Ponzio plays Melissa McCall.
The Problem With Six Seasons
Teen Wolf is a supernatural reimagining of the 1985 film of the same name, and the fourth installment in the franchise. That lineage explains both its strengths and its limits. The show is built to keep producing new creatures, new threats and new alliances. That structure is durable. It is also a treadmill.
The series received generally positive reviews from critics. The published critical score sits at 6.1 out of 10, with a Metacritic score of 61 out of 100. That number is fair. It captures a show that was frequently good, occasionally great, and rarely consistent.
The first three seasons are the strongest. The Scott-Allison-Derek triangle gives the story a spine, and the Argents give it an enemy that is not simply a monster. Once Allison leaves the board, the show has to rebuild its emotional center, and it never fully does. Later seasons introduce Malia, Kira and Liam, and they work as characters, but the relationships carry less weight than the original four.
The pacing is a recurring issue. Beacon Hills produces a new apocalyptic threat roughly once a season, and the show rarely slows down to let the characters sit with what happened. Grief gets a scene, then the plot moves on. That is a structural choice, not an accident, but it costs the series the depth it sometimes reaches for.
What Teen Wolf Got Right
The show’s real achievement is tone. It treats teenage problems and supernatural problems as the same size. Scott’s fear of losing control around Allison is not a metaphor for anything. It is the plot. The show commits to that, and it works better than it should.
Scott becomes the eponymous teenage werewolf of the series after he is bitten by an alpha werewolf the night before his second year of high school, drastically changing his once-ordinary life.
The supporting cast does a lot of the heavy lifting. Roden turns Lydia from a stock popular girl into the most interesting character on the show. O’Brien makes Stiles the audience’s way in, and his Nogitsune arc gives him material the rest of the cast does not get. Hoechlin’s Derek is the show’s most reliable source of tension, even when the writing around him gets thin.
The awards record backs up the performances. Of the thirteen Teen Choice Awards, nine went to Posey, O’Brien, Hoechlin, Roden and Hennig, and four went to Choice Summer TV Series. The three Saturn Awards for Best Youth-Oriented Television Series are the more serious recognition. The show was not just popular with teenagers. It was, for a while, genuinely good at being what it was.
Teen Wolf: The Movie Arrives
The franchise did not end with the finale. A film continuation, Teen Wolf: The Movie, was released on Paramount+ on January 26, 2023. That is a real measure of how much the series mattered to its audience. Six seasons and a hundred episodes built enough loyalty to justify bringing it back.
But the film is also a reminder of what the show was. Teen Wolf worked because it was episodic, because it had a town to protect and a cast to rotate through. A movie has to compress that. The series had room to be uneven. That room is what let it find Lydia’s banshee turn, or the kanima, or the Nogitsune.
Where the Score Lands
Teen Wolf is a 6.1 out of 10. That score reflects a show with a strong premise, a better-than-expected cast, and a habit of outrunning its own best ideas. It won three Saturn Awards and thirteen Teen Choice Awards, and it earned them. It also spent six seasons repeating its own structure, and by the end the repetition showed.
The case for the show is simple. Posey, O’Brien, Hoechlin, Roden and Reed made characters worth following, and the show gave them a world with real rules. The case against it is just as simple. Beacon Hills never learned to slow down, and the emotional beats that should have landed often got buried under the next monster.
What matters most is that Teen Wolf understood its own audience. It never condescended to teenagers, and it never pretended the supernatural was separate from being sixteen. That is why it lasted six seasons. That is why it got a movie. And that is why a 6.1 is not an insult. It is an accurate description of a show that was often good and never quite great.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.