WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
ShopCartAccount
Advertisement

FUBAR Review: Comedy and Drama Can’t Sit Together Comfortably

A review of FUBAR, a sitcom about six friends sharing a house whose comedy and drama fail to blend smoothly.

By mitch·4 min read
Six friends sit together in a living room, laughing and enjoying each other's company.

FUBAR is a 2023 television series about a group of young adults who live together and deal with family, relationships, and the usual growing pains of being in your twenties. It follows a familiar pattern: six friends, a shared apartment, and a rotating cast of problems. The show tries to balance comedy and drama, but the mix often feels uneven.

The premise is simple. Six friends share a house and navigate their lives through work, love, and the occasional disaster. The show leans heavily on physical comedy, awkward situations, and the kind of jokes that rely on the characters being in a room together.

Trailer, via Skydance.

Advertisement

The Characters

The ensemble cast is the strongest element of the series. Each character brings a distinct personality to the group dynamic, and the writers spend time developing their backgrounds and motivations. The chemistry between the actors is evident, and scenes where they interact naturally feel like they could carry an episode on their own.

Comedy vs. Drama

The show attempts to split its focus between comedy and drama, but the mix is often uneven. The comedy tends to be broad and physical, while the drama relies on personal stakes and emotional weight. These two modes often clash, leaving episodes feeling either too silly or too heavy-handed to land.

The pacing suffers as a result. Some episodes lean entirely on gag after gag, while others slow down to focus on a single relationship or plot thread. This inconsistency makes it difficult for viewers to settle into a steady rhythm.

Writing Weaknesses

The dialogue is where FUBAR shows its age. Lines are often delivered with a flatness that reads as dated, and the show’s attempt to capture contemporary culture sometimes misses the mark. References to social media, technology, and current events feel out of touch, which can pull viewers out of the story.

There is also a tendency to repeat jokes and gags across multiple episodes. A punchline or a setup that worked once loses its power quickly when it returns unchanged later. This repetition can make the middle stretch of the season feel less fresh than the early episodes.

Visual Style

The production values are modest. The sets are simple, the lighting is functional, and the overall look is clean but unremarkable. There are no major visual flourishes or stylistic choices that set the show apart from other sitcoms of its era.

That said, the show does benefit from a consistent aesthetic. The apartment looks lived-in, the streets look like a real city, and the locations feel grounded rather than staged. This consistency helps the show maintain a sense of reality even when the jokes are landing poorly.

Music and Sound

The score is sparse but effective. It knows when to swell during dramatic moments and when to stay quiet during dialogue-driven scenes. The songs used over the credits and between scenes add a light touch without overwhelming the material.

The sound design is similarly functional. The show doesn’t ask for much in this area, and it gets what it needs. The audio is clean, the voices are clear, and there are no distracting technical issues.

Where It Works

When FUBAR commits fully to its characters and their relationships, it succeeds. Episodes that focus on a single emotional arc, such as a breakup or a family conflict, tend to resonate more than those built around slapstick. The show’s best moments come when the comedy serves the drama rather than competing with it.

The ensemble also holds up in these quieter stretches. The actors have enough range to shift between comedy and drama convincingly, and their performances carry the weight of the more serious material.

Where It Falls Short

The show’s reliance on physical comedy and predictable setups limits its appeal. Gags involving mishaps, accidents, and pratfalls are deployed frequently, and while some land well, many feel worn out by the middle of the season. The humor is often aimed at younger audiences, and it doesn’t always translate to viewers looking for more sophisticated comedy.

The writing also struggles with depth. Characters are defined more by their reactions to situations than by their inner lives. This makes it harder to care about their outcomes, since their motivations and histories remain thin.

Final Word

FUBAR is a show with a promising premise and a talented cast, but it falls short of realizing its potential. The comedy is hit-or-miss, the drama is underdeveloped, and the writing shows its age in both tone and topical references. When it commits to its characters, it works. When it leans on its gags, it falters.

The series is not a failure, but it is a disappointment. It has moments of genuine warmth and laughter, but it never quite coalesces into a show that rewards sustained attention. It is watchable, occasionally funny, and forgettable.

Comparison of Comedy and Drama Elements

Element Comedy Drama
Tone Broad, physical Personal, emotional
Pace Fast, gag-driven Slow, focused
Focus Situations, setups Relationships, arcs
Effect Silliness Heavy-handedness

The table captures the core problem: comedy and drama are trying to occupy the same episode, but they rarely sit together comfortably. That tension is what makes the show uneven, and it is why the score reflects a series with promise that never quite delivers on it.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

TV reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.