Netflix brought back the Tanner family in 2016, and the result was a show that spent five seasons trying to decide whether it wanted to be a revival or a rerun. Fuller House, created by Jeff Franklin, premiered on February 26, 2016, and ran for 75 episodes across five seasons, ending on June 2, 2020. It is a sequel to Full House, the ABC sitcom that ran from 1987 to 1995. That is the pitch, and it is also the problem. The show arrives with a built-in audience and almost nothing new to say to it.
Trailer, via Netflix.
D.J. Tanner-Fuller Moves Back Home
The setup is a direct inversion of the original. D.J. Tanner-Fuller, played by Candace Cameron Bure, is a veterinarian and a widowed mother of three sons. Her husband Tommy died in the line of duty as a firefighter. She moves back into her childhood home in San Francisco with her father Danny, and when Danny leaves for work, she stays and accepts help from her sister Stephanie, played by Jodie Sweetin, and her best friend Kimmy Gibbler, played by Andrea Barber.
The three women raise D.J.’s sons: 13-year-old Jackson, 7-year-old Max, and baby Tommy Jr. Kimmy’s teenage daughter Ramona moves in too. The house still belongs to Danny Tanner, which is the kind of detail the show leans on hard. It is the same set, the same city, the same arrangement of adults and children. The gender roles are flipped. That is the whole idea.
The Cast Returns, With One Glaring Exception
Most of the original ensemble came back, either as regulars or in guest spots. John Stamos recurs as Jesse Katsopolis and also produced. Lori Loughlin returns as Becky Katsopolis, Bob Saget as Danny Tanner, and Dave Coulier as Joey Gladstone. Dylan and Blake Tuomy-Wilhoit appear again as Nicky and Alex Katsopolis. Juan Pablo Di Pace plays Fernando, Kimmy’s ex-husband, and Scott Weinger returns as Steve Hale, D.J.’s high school boyfriend.
The main new roles went to:
- Michael Campion as Jackson Fuller
- Elias Harger as Max Fuller
- Soni Bringas as Ramona Gibbler
One absence defines the revival more than any return. Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen shared the role of Michelle Tanner in Full House. They declined to participate. Ashley had not acted in years and had no plans to restart. Mary-Kate considered it but passed, citing her fashion career. The producers wrote Michelle into New York City, focused on fashion. It is a tidy workaround, and it leaves a hole the show never fills.
A Release Plan Built on Nostalgia
Netflix ordered thirteen episodes for season one and dropped them all worldwide on February 26, 2016. Season two followed on December 9, 2016. Season three was split: nine episodes on September 22, 2017, and the rest on December 22, 2017. Netflix renewed the show for a fourth season on January 29, 2018, and released it on December 14, 2018. On January 31, 2019, the show got a fifth and final season of eighteen episodes. The first half premiered on December 6, 2019; the second half on June 2, 2020.
That is a lot of scheduling for a show this thin. The binge model suits a revival because it lets the audience mainline the nostalgia in one sitting. It also exposes how little there is underneath. Once you have seen the old faces and heard the old catchphrases, you are left with a family sitcom that plays it safe in every direction.
What Five Seasons Actually Added Up To
The reception tells the story. The first season drew generally negative reviews. Later seasons improved but stayed mixed. That arc is familiar for revivals: the first batch gets graded on the shock of seeing everyone again, and the later ones get graded as television. Fuller House never really cleared the second bar.
The published critical score is 3.5 out of 10, with a Metacritic rating of 35 out of 100. That is a low mark even for a revival that critics were ready to dislike.
The show’s central bet is that the original formula still works if you swap the genders and add a laugh track’s worth of callbacks. It mostly does not. D.J., Stephanie and Kimmy are given adult problems, but the writing treats them with the same weight as a seventh-grader’s crush. The dead husband is a premise, not a wound. The firefighter detail is stated and then set aside. Nothing costs anything for long.
The Olsen absence matters more than the show admits. Michelle was the original’s breakout, and her refusal to return is the one honest signal that this revival was a business decision before it was a creative one. The workaround, a fashion career in New York, is fine. It is also a reminder that the people who made Full House famous had reasons to stay away.
Fuller House is not unwatchable. It is comfortable, and comfort is exactly what it was built to sell. But comfort is not the same as craft, and five seasons of it do not add up to a single episode that justifies the revival on its own terms. The audience got the reunion it wanted. It did not get a show.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.