The Harry Potter films are full of memorable scenes, yet one of the finest, the dance between Harry and Hermione from Deathly Hallows – Part 1, cannot be reproduced by HBO’s remake. It can’, and the explanation is straightforward — the scene does not exist in the books.
The dance was invented for the movies. It wasn’t in J.K. Rowling’s novels. That means the TV version can’t borrow it directly. But that doesn’t mean the spirit of the scene is lost. The remake can learn from what made it work.
The Dance That Wasn’t In The Books
After an argument with Ron Weasley over a Horcrux, Harry and Hermione find themselves alone in a tent, and they end up dancing together to [song]. It’s a moment of quiet intimacy between two people who have shared every hardship. Ron walks out on them in Deathly Hallows – Part 1; the film then cuts to the pair moving together, caught in a simple, tender rhythm.
When the movie first came out, the reviewer admits they hated the scene. “Partly that was due to being a somewhat insufferable book purist at the time and disliking any change,” they write. “But it was more that, being the same age as the actors, I found it incredibly cringe-worthy and awkward to watch.”
With each rewatch, time altered the reviewer’s view of the scene, and now they “utterly adore it.” It’s one of the most beautiful, human moments in the whole saga, they say, and it puts a spotlight on Harry and Hermione’s friendship.
Why The Remake Can’t Copy It
Staying faithful to the books is already a demand on the remake. The longer runtime allows room for material cut from the films, such as Peeves the Poltergeist’s casting and History of Magic lessons. Yet the dance poses its own separate difficulty.
It wasn’t in the source material. It was created for the screen. The remake can’t repeat it without borrowing from the movies themselves, and that’s a step the production shouldn’t take.
“There will be enough inevitable similarities in the TV show without it taking things created solely for the big screen, and a moment that really belongs to Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson.”
This particular performance is linked to a distinct duo of actors. The dancing is the domain of Radcliffe and Watson, and the television adaptation would have to construct its own interpretation from nothing.
What The Remake Can Learn Instead
The reviewer suggests the remake shouldn’t be afraid of invention. There’s room beyond what’s on the page, and that can still fit with being accurate to the books. The production is already doing this, with scenes like Ron and Hermione receiving their Hogwarts letters and a meeting between Albus Dumbledore and the Flamels.
The second lesson concerns discovering light within darkness. As the Harry Potter saga grows increasingly dark, the innocence of youth gets taken away. Yet the characters remain children, and their youth should not be abandoned entirely.
The later movies sometimes pushed too far in the more mature direction, the reviewer argues. That’s one of the reasons the dance stands out. It’s fun, it’s silly, and it’s a touching ray of light amid a bleak darkness.
The Emotional Weight Behind The Dance
The scene works because it’s bittersweet. Harry and Hermione are fighting for their lives and the fate of the world. Yet they’re able to hit pause, to remember that there has to be love and joy in the world — the things they are fighting for.
It’s a moment of tenderness and carefree joy. After being forced to grow up too fast, they have a moment that’s tender and carefree, showcasing the magical resilience of youth and the importance of friendship.
More Harry And Hermione Time
The reviewer also thinks there’s value in doing more with Harry and Hermione in the remake. Their friendship is quite lovely, and she’s there by his side even when Ron isn’t — both in The Deathly Hallows and, years earlier, in The Goblet of Fire.
But we don’t really get enough scenes of just the two of them, the reviewer argues. While it shouldn’t be the dance, more of that would be great for the Harry Potter remake.
The Balance The Remake Must Strike
The remake needs to balance three things:
- Faithfulness to the books
- Appeal to a nostalgic movie audience
- A new identity that sets it apart from the films
Sometimes the parts don’t match up. The films endure as cherished classics and a cultural reference point, fueling a travel and product industry. Several theme parks and other draws are constructed around the settings, outfits, and imagery from those productions.
Critics have already pointed out how much the TV series resembles the films. It seems like a difficult task to establish its own distinct identity when the movies were so successful, especially since theme parks and other attractions exist because of those locations, costumes, and imagery.
The Reviewer’s Final Word On The Dance
The critic admits they were mistaken about the dance from the very beginning. With each passing year, rewatch, and a little bit more wisdom, they’ve come to appreciate it more and more.
This moment stands out as one of the most touching, personal scenes across the whole series. It gives Harry and Hermione’s bond its time to shine, proving that their friendship alone was enough.
The Bottom Line For The Remake
The dance can’t be repeated in the TV version. It wasn’t in the books, and it belongs to Radcliffe and Watson. But the spirit of the scene — finding light amid darkness, remembering friendship, and hitting pause — is something the remake can absolutely borrow.
The reviewer’s closing guidance urges viewers to hold onto these moments of humanity as the TV series grows ever darker. Defeating a great evil is the show’s mission, and letting these tender moments come forward will improve the experience.
That’s the lesson from one of the greatest Harry Potter movie scenes. It can’t be copied, but it can be learned from.
See the video the story is built around at Screen Rant.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.