“Heroes Reborn” arrives with a simple promise: return to the characters we loved in the original “Heroes” series, now older, wiser and ready to face a new threat. The NBC series picks up years after the events of the earlier show, following a group of evolved humans who discover a virus spreading through the population, giving ordinary people abilities overnight. The premise sounds bold. The execution, too often, does not match it.
The show’s central problem is pacing. Sixteen episodes are stretched across a single season, and the writers spend far too much time explaining what happened in the past rather than moving forward. Flashbacks dominate the early hours, showing the lives of the main characters before their powers emerged. These scenes are occasionally sharp, but they slow the momentum of the present-day storyline to a crawl. By the time the season finally gets around to building toward a confrontation with the virus’s architect, the audience has forgotten why they should care.
Trailer, via televisionpromosdb.
The Virus That Carries the Show
The viral element is the strongest thread in “Heroes Reborn.” The idea that a disease can trigger evolution is both timely and scientifically grounded enough to feel less absurd than the usual “Heroes” plot device. Unlike the show’s previous iterations, which leaned heavily on fantasy, this version ties its superhuman abilities to a biological process that could exist in the real world. That grounding gives the series a foothold it never quite builds on.
The show also benefits from a strong ensemble cast. Zachary Levi leads as Noah Bennet, the former Company agent turned reluctant leader of a resistance movement. He brings a worn-in gravitas to the role, carrying scenes with a quiet intensity that anchors the chaos around him. His scenes with Amy Rutberg, who plays a character named Audrey, are some of the best in the season, pairing a seasoned professional with a newcomer who holds her own.
The Supporting Cast Falls Short
The supporting cast is where “Heroes Reborn” stumbles. Masi Oka returns as Hiro Nakamura, and his performance is a mixed bag. Some of his moments are genuinely funny, especially when he grapples with the modern world’s technological changes. Others are flat, with his quips landing as empty jokes rather than character insight. The show also introduces a new villain, played by Danny Huston, who is supposed to be a looming presence but never quite reaches it. His scenes are staged with menace, but the writing fails to give him a motive beyond generic evil.
The show’s attempt to bring back old favorites is also uneven. One character, Claire Bennet, returns after a long absence, and her arc feels rushed. The writers try to reset her storyline in a few episodes, but the emotional weight of her past is diluted by the show’s need to move on. Another returning character, Peter Petrelli, is given a larger role, and his scenes are some of the most engaging in the season. But even his presence cannot overcome the broader structural problems.
The Middle Stretch Drags
The middle stretch of the season is where “Heroes Reborn” loses its audience. After the initial setup, the show spends several episodes circling the same ideas: the virus, the resistance, the government conspiracy. Characters repeat information to each other, and the tension that should build between them fades into repetition. The show’s attempts to raise the stakes through action sequences are hampered by a script that cannot decide whether it wants to be a thriller or a family drama.
There are a few standout episodes. One, titled “The Art of War,” shifts focus to a character named Tracy Strauss, played by Ali Larter. Her storyline explores the consequences of having a power that disrupts time itself, and it is one of the season’s most coherent arcs. Another episode, “One Giant Leap,” centers on Hiro’s journey to the moon, where he discovers a secret that connects the virus to a larger cosmic event. Both episodes demonstrate what the show could have been if it had trusted its premise more.
The Final Stretch Weakens
The season finale tries to tie everything together, but the payoff is underwhelming. The reveal of the virus’s true origin is telegraphed well in advance, and the final act rushes through a resolution that feels rushed. The show’s attempt to set up a second season is undermined by the lack of closure for the characters who have spent the entire season fighting for survival.
The ending also leaves unresolved questions about the fate of key characters, which feels like a bait-and-switch for viewers who invested their time in this story. It is a frustrating note to end on, and it undercuts the emotional weight of the season’s quieter moments.
What Works in “Heroes Reborn”
Despite its flaws, “Heroes Reborn” has a few elements that work. The visual effects are competent, and the show’s depiction of the virus’s spread is genuinely unsettling. The music, composed by Bear McCreary, adds a sense of dread that the writing sometimes lacks. And the show’s commitment to exploring the consequences of its premise, rather than simply using it as a jumping-off point for spectacle, is admirable.
Here is a quick rundown of the season’s strengths:
- Strong performances from Zachary Levi and Ali Larter
- A compelling viral concept that grounds the fantasy in science
- Well-executed standalone episodes like “The Art of War” and “One Giant Leap”
- A score by Bear McCreary that enhances the tone
Where the Season Misses
The season’s weaknesses are just as numerous. The pacing is inconsistent, with stretches of pure filler sandwiched between moments of genuine tension. The writing leans on exposition instead of subtext, making the characters feel like mouthpieces for information rather than people. And the show’s attempt to balance multiple storylines across a large ensemble results in a narrative that is diffuse rather than focused.
Here is a quick rundown of the season’s weaknesses:
- Over-reliance on flashbacks that slow the present-day story
- A villain who never feels truly threatening
- A finale that rushes through its conclusion
- Unresolved character arcs that leave the audience hanging
The Verdict on “Heroes Reborn”
“Heroes Reborn” is a mixed bag. It has a solid core of ideas and a talented cast, but the execution falls short of its ambitions. The season’s strengths are scattered across individual episodes rather than woven into a cohesive whole. For fans of the original series, there are moments of genuine pleasure. For casual viewers, the show’s slow start and uneven middle may make it a hard sell.
The show’s legacy is complicated. It tried to revive a franchise that had fallen out of favor, and while it succeeded in generating some buzz, it failed to fully recapture the magic of its predecessor. The season ends with a cliffhanger, but it feels more like a placeholder than a genuine cliffhanger. The audience is left waiting, but the show has not earned that patience.
“Heroes Reborn” is a flawed but watchable addition to the “Heroes” canon. It is worth a look for dedicated fans, but newcomers should be warned that the slow start and uneven pacing may test their patience. The show’s best moments are memorable, but they are surrounded by a structure that cannot support them.
The score for “Heroes Reborn” is 5.3 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
