Hocus Pocus is a movie that knows exactly what it wants to be: a spooky, silly, family-friendly Halloween romp with three witches who are genuinely terrifying until the very moment they’re not. Directed by Kenny Ortega, with a screenplay by Mick Garris and Neil Cuthbert, and a story by David Kirschner and Garris, the film centers on the Sanderson sisters — Bette Midler as Winifred, Sarah Jessica Parker as Sarah, and Kathy Najimy as Mary — who are accidentally resurrected in Salem, Massachusetts, on Halloween night. The kids who bring them back, Max Dennison (Omri Katz), his sister Dani (Thora Birch), and their friend Allison (Vinessa Shaw), have to stop the witches’ reign of terror before it’s too late.
The premise is simple, and it’s the film’s greatest strength. A trio of witches, banished to death three centuries earlier, are brought back by a candle lit in the wrong place at the wrong time. That setup gives the movie a clear goal and a built-in clock, and the filmmakers lean into both. The result is a film that feels smaller than its ambitions suggest, but it has a hold on its audience that has kept it alive long after its initial run.
Trailer, via HJr.
The Witches and Their Curse
Midler, Parker, and Najimy are the engine of Hocus Pocus, and they deliver performances that are genuinely menacing before they become cartoonish. The film sets up the witches as genuine threats, and it doesn’t let up on that threat for the first half. Their curse — that a virgin will light the Black-Flame Candle and resurrect them — hangs over the whole story, and the film spends real time building the dread of what happens if it comes true.
The curse itself is a clever device. It gives the witches a reason to exist, and it gives the kids a reason to act. The film trusts that setup, and it pays off by making the stakes feel real even when the tone shifts toward comedy.
The Kids and Their Cat
Max, Dani, and Allison are the heroes of the story, and the film treats them with a warmth that grounds the magic. Omri Katz plays Max as a reluctant hero, Thora Birch plays Dani as fiercely loyal, and Vinessa Shaw plays Allison as the quiet outsider who becomes the heart of the group. The film also introduces Binx, the immortal black cat who was turned into a cat by the witches centuries earlier, and his presence adds a layer of guilt and loyalty that the story leans on heavily.
The cat is a small role, but it’s a meaningful one. He serves as a bridge between the past and the present, and his return helps the kids understand why the witches are so dangerous.
The Problem With the Tone
Where Hocus Pocus stumbles is in its tonal consistency. The film moves from horror to comedy to family entertainment without warning, and the shift often lands awkwardly. The witches start as terrifying figures, and then the movie pulls back just enough that the fear turns into a joke. That pull is the film’s biggest problem, and it’s a structural issue that the cast can’t fully overcome.
The film’s central problem is that it can’t decide what kind of story it wants to tell. It wants to be scary, but it wants to be funny. It wants to be a family film, but it wants to have teeth. Those impulses are not compatible, and the movie flounders when it tries to balance them.
The Climax
The climax of Hocus Pocus is a sequence of songs, dances, and a final confrontation that stretches the runtime and tests the audience’s patience. The film earns its ending, but getting there requires a stretch of broad, musical comedy that doesn’t quite land. The songs are performed with energy, but they feel less like a payoff and more like a detour.
The final confrontation is the film’s strongest moment. The witches are at their most unhinged, and the kids are at their most resourceful. The tension builds, and the resolution is earned.
The Legacy
Hocus Pocus didn’t perform well at the box office. It lost Disney around $16.5 million during its theatrical run, and it was considered a failure on release. But the film found a second life through annual airings on Disney Channel and Freeform, where it became a Halloween staple. Every year, the film sees a spike in home media sales, and it has developed a devoted following that has turned it into a cult classic.
The franchise has expanded beyond the film. There’s a sequel novelization, a theme park attraction, a TV special, and a short film. A sequel, Hocus Pocus 2, arrived on Disney+ on September 30, 2022, and a third film is currently in development.
The film’s legacy is built on repeat viewings, not on its original release. Its success is a story of persistence and timing, not of critical acclaim.
Ranking the Elements
Here’s how the elements of Hocus Pocus stack up:
- The witches — Midler, Parker, and Najimy — are the best part of the film.
- The setup — the curse and the resurrection — is the strongest writing in the script.
- The kids — Max, Dani, and Allison — are likable and grounded.
- The tone — the film’s refusal to commit to one genre — is its biggest weakness.
- The climax — the songs and dances — is the weakest stretch of the film.
The film’s strengths are real. Its weaknesses are also real, and they’re structural ones that no amount of charm can fix. The result is a film that works better in memory than it does on screen.
Hocus Pocus is a film that knows exactly what it wants to be, and it delivers that thing. It’s a Halloween movie that’s fun, funny, and occasionally frightening, but it’s not a great movie. It’s a good one that has been unfairly elevated by years of annual screenings.
The score is 4.3 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
