“Insatiable” is a show about a girl who gets plastic surgery after losing weight. It sounds like it could work. It does not work.
The premise is simple: Paisley Cox, played by Debby Ryan, gains weight after a traumatic event and loses it through a program. She gets her old shape back and suddenly everyone wants her. The show treats her new body as a prize she has won. That is the whole joke.
Trailer, via Netflix.
Weight Loss as Plot Engine
The weight loss program drives the plot. It brings Paisley back into town, gives her a reason to be angry, and sets up her arc. It is also the show’s biggest problem. The show keeps telling us Paisley is beautiful now. It never tells us why anyone else thinks so.
Debby Ryan’s Performance
Debby Ryan carries the show on her own. She plays Paisley as a mix of anger and joy, and she sells both sides of her character. Her performance is the one reason to watch. Without her, the show falls apart.
Comedy That Misses
The comedy is where “Insatiable” fails completely. The jokes are mean-spirited and unfunny. They land badly. They feel like they were written to be cruel rather than clever. The show’s tone is awkward and off-putting, and it never finds a way out of that.
Message Thin and Obvious
The show wants to say something about beauty and confidence. It does not say it. Instead, it keeps showing Paisley getting attention for her body and expecting the audience to cheer for her. The message is thin and obvious. It is not clever, and it is not subtle.
Ten Episodes, Dragging Middle
The first season runs for ten episodes. It drags in the middle. The pacing slows down in the later episodes, and the show spends too much time on filler scenes that add nothing to the story. The ending does not resolve the season’s problems. It simply stops.
Critics Were Harsh
Critics were harsh on “Insatiable.” The show received a score of 2.5 out of 10. That score is fair. It is a show that tries to be edgy and ends up being mean. It is a show that wants to be funny and ends up being cruel.
“Insatiable” is a show that tries to be edgy and ends up being mean.
Verdict: Wasted Idea
“Insatiable” is a show that wastes a good idea. Debby Ryan deserves better material than this. The show’s heart is in the right place, but its hands keep reaching for cheap laughs. It is a show that is easy to watch but hard to enjoy.
The show is available to stream. If you want to see what it is about, you can watch the first episode. After that, you will know everything you need to know.
“Insatiable” is a show that critics scored 2.5 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
