Jon Hamm plays a newsman caught up in a real-life kidnapping in American Hostage, and the result is a crime thriller that respects its 1970s setting and its actors. The show, based on a podcast of the same name, tells the story of Tony Kiritsis, an Indianapolis man who kidnapped his mortgage broker in February 1977. The crisis unfolds over 63 hours, and the drama centers on Fred Heckman, the local radio host Tony demands speak to him live.
Hamm stars as Heckman, reprising the role he played in the podcast. He is joined by Giovanni Ribisi as Tony Kiritsis, and Kristoffer Polaha plays Dick Hall, the mortgage broker held captive.
The Story Behind the Show
In February 1977, Tony Kiritsis kidnapped his mortgage broker, Dick Hall. The incident captured the attention of Indianapolis residents, and the case faded into history despite making national news at the time. The podcast version of American Hostage starred Jon Hamm and was revisited in 2022.
The show follows the hostage situation as it unfolds over 63 hours. Fred Heckman, a local radio host, becomes the central figure when Tony insists he be the one to talk to him. The series uses split-screen editing to show the impact of the conversations on everyone around them, from the station staff to the police to Tony’s family.
Hamm and Ribisi Carry the Weight
Hamm brings his gravitas to the role of Fred Heckman, a man who has a code of journalistic integrity. The character is no Don Draper, the reviewer notes, and Fred’s duty to the news erodes as the crisis drags on. He didn’t ask to become part of the story, but he finds himself unable to stop it.
One of Hamm’s best scenes comes at the end of Episode 4. Fred, in his calmest voice, reveals a devastating family secret on the air while trying to calm Tony down. It’s a deeply moving moment, and it works because of Hamm’s restraint.
Ribisi plays Tony Kiritsis as a man pushed to his limits. He is paranoid and unpredictable, leaving viewers on edge whether they know the story or not. Yet it’s hard not to root for him, especially when he seems like a victim of big business and a system that wouldn’t give him a fair shot. Ribisi strikes a perfect balance between grandiose, erratic, and empathetic.
The Supporting Cast Rounds Out the Season
The show’s expanded runtime allows room for deeper character development. Fred’s wife Barbara is played by Mireille Enos, and his coworkers Ben Hairston and Ginny are played by William Jackson Harper and June Laporte, respectively. Harper stands out as a foil to Fred throughout the season, questioning his impartiality as the situation continues.
Through flashbacks, viewers see how Hairston grows into his own as one of the few journalists of color in the newsroom. When Fred is temporarily ousted from WIBC, Ben offers a steadier command than station manager Jerry Morris.
The series also explores the gender politics of the era. Characters like Ginny, Barbara, and Dick’s wife reflect the women’s liberation movement of the time. Ginny’s storyline highlights subtle workplace sexism when a news story she works on is axed by Fred moments before she’s supposed to be on the air. Barbara and Ibby bond throughout the larger-than-life situation, with Barbara being the only one who can connect with Ibby while her estranged husband is a hostage.
How the Show Builds Its World
The show’s editing style is a key part of its identity. The score often relies on a ’70s drum groove, and the editing features split screens that bring together Fred and Tony’s scenes over the radio. The technique shows the reactions of Fred’s station staff, the police officers, and Tony’s family members in the vicinity.
It’s not just a stylistic choice. The split frames communicate the ripple effects Tony and Fred’s conversations have on the surrounding audience. The show also uses flashbacks to explore the characters’ pasts, including how Hairston grew into his role as a journalist of color.
| Element | Podcast Version | TV Version |
|---|---|---|
| Runtime | Roughly 30 minutes per episode | Around 50 minutes per installment |
| Format | Audio only | Audio and visual storytelling |
| Lead actor | Jon Hamm | Jon Hamm |
| Medium | Podcast | Streaming series |
A Tight Story Without Loose Ends
American Hostage is an anthology series like True Detective, meaning each season tells a complete story. The first season delivers a complete narrative without too many open threads. That approach works in favor of the show, giving it a clear arc from beginning to end.
The momentum stays steady even when the show slows down for flashbacks or poignant scenes. The crime thriller remains gripping throughout, and the added runtime pays off by allowing for richer character development.
What the Review Says
Collider‘s review argues that the show succeeds thanks to commanding lead performances, a strong supporting cast, and stylish editing. The review praises the performances of Hamm and Ribisi individually, but also notes that they are at their best together, whether in person or talking at either end of a phone call.
The review also notes that some true-crime podcasts have made the leap to television successfully, citing The Dropout as an example. Others, like WeCrashed, have been less successful. American Hostage falls into the former category.
A Compelling True Story
The story of Tony Kiritsis is a real one, and the show treats it with care. The podcast version kept the story tight, but the TV version expands it while preserving the tension. The show balances the drama of the hostage situation with the personal stakes for everyone involved.
Fred Heckman’s role as the trusted voice in local news is central to the plot. Tony wants his story told by the most trusted voice, and Fred becomes that voice. The show explores the ethical dilemmas that come with that responsibility.
The Final Word on the Season
American Hostage is a worthy adaptation of a compelling true story. The performances of Hamm and Ribisi are excellent, and the editing is distinctive. The show respects its 1970s setting while telling a gripping crime story.
The season delivers a complete story without too many loose ends. It’s a strong entry into the true-crime anthology format, and it sets a high bar for future seasons.
Key Facts Box
– Story: Based on the 2022 podcast of the same name
– Time period: February 1977, Indianapolis
– Runtime: Around 50 minutes per installment
– Streaming platform: MGM+
– Lead actors: Jon Hamm as Fred Heckman, Giovanni Ribisi as Tony Kiritsis
– Supporting cast: Mireille Enos as Barbara, William Jackson Harper as Ben Hairston, June Laporte as Ginny
The show is a reminder that true-crime stories can be told with style and substance. It respects its source material while expanding it for a new medium. The performances are strong, the editing is distinctive, and the story is compelling.
Source material: “'Mad Men' Meets 'True Detective' in Jon Hamm's Newest Crime Thriller | Review,” Collider.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.