WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
ShopCartAccount
Advertisement

She Was Pretty Review: Shin Hye Sung Loses Everything, and Go Mi Nam Wants Him Anyway

A tale of ruin, pride, and the quiet desire of one woman for a ruined man she cannot have.

By mitch·5 min read
A man sits alone in a dim apartment, his expression worn and humbled.

She Was Pretty is a romantic comedy about second chances, but it isn’t really about romance at all. It’s about failure, pride, and the quiet humiliation of being passed over. The 2015 Korean drama follows a man who loses everything—his job, his girlfriend, his dignity—and a woman who watches him fall and decides she wants him anyway. It’s a show about wanting what you can’t have, and then having it.

The premise is simple. Kang Tae Oh plays Shin Hye Sung, a handsome, successful man whose life collapses after he cheats on his girlfriend. His career ends, his friends abandon him, and he becomes a social outcast. Kim Ji Won plays Go Mi Nam, a former classmate who has spent her life chasing a dream that never materialized. She sees Shin Hye Sung at his lowest and decides to help him rebuild his life. The catch: she’s not doing it for him. She’s doing it for herself.

Trailer, via MBCdrama.

Advertisement

Shin Hye Sung’s Fall

Shin Hye Sung’s arc is the engine of the show. He goes from a confident, charming man to a broken one in a matter of weeks. The cheating is not a plot device; it’s a wound that never heals. His humiliation is physical, emotional, and public. He loses his apartment, his car, and his reputation. The show doesn’t soften this. It shows the pain of losing everything you’ve built.

His journey is also a study in humility. He has to learn to ask for help, to accept kindness, and to let others define him. That’s difficult for a man used to being the center of attention. The show tracks his slow recovery through small victories: a new job, a new friend, a new apartment. Each step is earned, not handed to him.

Go Mi Nam’s Plan

Go Mi Nam is the show’s real hero. She’s a woman who has always wanted what she couldn’t have: a successful career, a loving family, a happy ending. She’s never gotten any of it. She watches Shin Hye Sung fall and sees an opportunity. She helps him, but her motives are selfish. She wants to be the one who fixes him, the one who makes him whole again.

Her plan is simple: she’ll help him, and he’ll fall in love with her. It doesn’t work that way. The show is honest about this. She falls in love with him, but she never tells him. The tension comes from watching her struggle with her feelings while pretending they don’t exist. It’s a painful watch.

The Romance That Isn’t Romantic

The relationship between Shin Hye Sung and Go Mi Nam is the heart of the show, but it’s not a traditional romance. They don’t declare their feelings. They don’t kiss. They don’t even admit they like each other until the very end. The show is patient about this. It waits for the moment when they finally see each other clearly, and when that happens, the payoff is earned.

Their scenes together are the best in the show. They talk about their pasts, their fears, and their dreams. They laugh together, they fight together, and they support each other. The chemistry is real, and the show trusts the audience to feel it without spelling it out.

The Supporting Cast

The show also does a great job with its supporting characters. Shin Hye Sung’s ex-girlfriend is cruel, but she’s also human. She’s hurt, and she’s angry, and she acts on that anger. Go Mi Nam’s family is warm and chaotic. Her mother is a loud, loving presence, and her father is a quiet, supportive one. These characters aren’t just background noise. They shape the main characters’ lives in meaningful ways.

The show also includes a subplot involving Shin Hye Sung’s old boss, who tries to sabotage his comeback. This subplot adds tension without stealing focus from the central relationship. It’s a reminder that the world doesn’t want Shin Hye Sung to succeed. The show handles this subplot with restraint, letting it simmer in the background.

The Writing and Direction

The writing is sharp and funny. The show knows when to be serious and when to be silly. There are jokes about dating apps, about office politics, and about the absurdity of adult life. The humor never undermines the drama. It lightens the load.

The dialogue is natural. The characters talk like real people. They pause mid-sentence. They repeat themselves. They trail off. The show is full of small moments that feel genuine, like a conversation where one person is thinking about something else while they’re talking.

The direction is clean and unobtrusive. The show doesn’t rely on flashy visuals. It relies on performances and composition. The camera lingers on faces during conversations. It frames the characters in rooms that reflect their moods. The lighting is soft and warm when the characters are happy, and cold and harsh when they’re sad.

The show also knows when to cut away. It doesn’t linger on a tearful goodbye or a tender embrace. It cuts away, leaving the moment hanging in the air. That restraint makes the emotion land harder.

The Ending

The ending is bittersweet. The show doesn’t tie everything up neatly. It leaves some threads loose. That’s a strength, not a weakness. The show trusts the audience to understand that life doesn’t end with a bow. It continues, messy and unpredictable.

The final scene is a quiet one. Shin Hye Sung and Go Mi Nam sit together, and they talk about their future. They’re not sure what it will look like, but they know they want to build it together. It’s a hopeful note, but it’s not a happy one. The show acknowledges that happiness is temporary and that the road ahead will have bumps.

Key Facts Box

  • Title: She Was Pretty
  • Year: 2015
  • Network: SBS
  • Runtime: 20 episodes
  • Score: 8.3/10

What Works

  • A strong lead performance from Kang Tae Oh
  • A nuanced, layered performance from Kim Ji Won
  • Sharp, natural dialogue
  • Clean, unobtrusive direction
  • A patient, character-driven story

What Doesn’t Work

  • The pacing drags in the middle episodes
  • Some subplots feel underdeveloped
  • The resolution is a bit abrupt

She Was Pretty is a smart, funny, and emotionally honest show. It’s about failure, but it’s also about resilience. It’s about wanting what you can’t have, and then having it. It’s a show about the quiet moments—the ones that make up a life—and it treats those moments with care. It’s a show worth watching, and it earns its 8.3 out of 10.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

TV reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.