Robert Rodriguez’s adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein’s novel Starship Troopers is a loud, fast, and mostly empty war movie dressed up as satire. The film follows a group of cadets led by Johnny Rico as they fight the insectoid Arachnids across a series of brutal battles. The setup promises something sharp and political. The execution delivers something else entirely.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Entertainment.
Johnny Rico and the Cast
Johnny Rico, played by Casper Van Dien, carries the film through sheer charisma. His performance grounds the chaos around him, even when the script doesn’t. The supporting cast fills out the platoon with varying degrees of energy, but none of them get enough material to justify their presence.
The Arachnid Battles
The battles themselves are the film’s strongest element. Rodriguez stages large-scale action sequences with energy and spectacle, and the visual effects hold up better than most of the dialogue. The Arachnids look genuinely threatening, and the combat scenes move with a pace that keeps the audience engaged.
The Political Message
Heinlein’s novel was built around a political argument about citizenship and military service. Rodriguez’s version barely touches it. The film spends more time on explosions than on ideas, and the few attempts at satire land flat rather than sharp.
The Weak Script
The problem is the writing. The script is thin, the pacing is uneven, and the humor misses its mark again and again. One scene, in particular, tries to be a satirical dig at American politics and comes off as a cheap joke instead. The film’s attempt at commentary is buried under its own excess.
Visual Style
Rodriguez’s direction is competent, but it’s also flashy for the sake of being flashy. The color grading is bright and saturated, the editing is fast, and the camera work is kinetic. None of it elevates the material beyond its source.
Sound Design
The sound design is loud and effective. Gunfire, explosions, and the Arachnids’ screeches fill the theater with a sense of scale that the script can’t match. It’s a technical success in a film that struggles everywhere else.
A Short List of What Works
- The Arachnid battles
- Johnny Rico’s performance
- The visual effects
- The sound design
A Short List of What Doesn’t Work
- The political message
- The humor
- The writing
- The pacing
The Verdict
Starship Troopers isn’t a failure, but it isn’t a success either. It’s a film that takes a smart idea and buries it under spectacle. The battles are worth seeing, but the rest of the movie isn’t.
Key Facts Box
- Title: Starship Troopers
- Director: Robert Rodriguez
- Lead actor: Casper Van Dien
- Genre: War, science fiction, satire
- Running time: approximately 124 minutes
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
