“The Fall of the House of Usher” is a TV adaptation that takes Edgar Allan Poe’s 1839 story and turns it into something closer to horror than mystery. The show, made for the screen, drops the original’s gothic dread in favor of jump scares and gore, and mostly succeeds on its own terms even when it drifts from the source material. The premise is simple: a wealthy family’s fortune and reputation are crumbling, and the show follows the son who watches it all come undone. What changes is the cause of that fall — the show adds supernatural elements that Poe never wrote into the tale.
Trailer, via Netflix.
The Premise
The series follows Roderick Usher, whose family’s fortune and reputation are crumbling. As he descends into madness, strange things happen in the house. The show keeps the basic shape of the story but adds supernatural elements that Poe never wrote into the tale. That shift shapes every episode, since the whole series depends on horror rather than mystery to drive its plot forward.
What Works
The strongest stretch comes in the middle episodes, where the show leans fully into the horror tone. A scene involving the house itself, built around the idea that it has a life of its own, lands as one of the series’ best moments. The direction keeps the camera low and the lighting dim, giving the scenes a sense of dread that the script earns.
The lead performance carries the show. The actor plays Roderick with a mix of fear and exhaustion that makes the descent feel earned rather than staged. His sister Madeline gets her own arc, separate from the main plot, which gives the show room to explore both sides of the family’s fall. The supporting cast fills out the world around Roderick with characters who feel real rather than flat, rounding out a world that could otherwise feel thin.
Where It Falls Short
Not everything holds up. Some of the horror sequences depend too heavily on practical effects that look dated, and the pacing slows during stretches that add nothing new to the story. The show also leans on violence that feels added rather than necessary to the plot, which drags down the tone.
The adaptation is clearest about its changes in its opening episodes, where it explains the differences between the source text and the screen version. This honesty helps set expectations, but it also shows how far the show has moved from Poe’s original. Viewers expecting a faithful retelling will see early on that this version has gone its own way.
Final Word
The Fall of the House of Usher is a mixed bag, but the parts that work make it worth watching. The horror tone is consistent and often effective, while the additions to the story keep it fresh even when they stray from Poe’s original vision. It won’t satisfy viewers looking for a faithful adaptation, but as a standalone horror series, it delivers.
Key Facts
- Title: The Fall of the House of Usher
- Premise: A TV adaptation of Poe’s 1839 story about the fall of a wealthy family
- Strong point: The middle episodes and the house-as-a-character concept
- Weak point: Dated practical effects and pacing issues
- Score: 7.3 of 10
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
