Simon and Robyn Callem think they have moved on. They leave Chicago after Simon takes a job back in his hometown of Los Angeles, planning to settle down and start a family. Then Gordo Moseley shows up.
Joel Edgerton directs and writes The Gift, his feature directorial debut, and he plays the role of Gordo. Jason Bateman plays Simon, and Rebecca Hall plays Robyn. The film opens with a chance meeting at the mall, where Simon runs into his old classmate. Gordo starts visiting unannounced, bringing gifts. He invites the couple to a dinner party at his large home. He claims the other couple cancelled. He receives an urgent phone call and briefly leaves the house. After returning, he says the house belongs to his wife, who left him, taking their two kids. Simon is suspicious and tells Gordo to stay away. Robyn thinks it’s harmless.
That difference is the engine of the whole movie. Simon feels fear. Robyn feels comforted. Edgerton knows exactly where that split lands, and he spends the runtime building pressure underneath it.
Trailer, via Blumhouse.
Gordo’s Gifts
Gordo’s gifts pile up fast. The film tracks them carefully:
| Gift | Given To | Reaction |
|---|---|---|
| Koi pond | Simon and Robyn | Dead the next day |
| Dog | Simon and Robyn | Missing |
| Letter | Left in the mail | Ends with “I was willing to let bygones be bygones, I had nothing but good intentions” |
Each gift carries a small promise. Each gift also carries a warning. Robyn finds faucets left running and hears footsteps in the house. She steals her neighbor’s prescription pills to get through nights without sleep. The dog returns on its own. A note from Gordo arrives in the mail, ending with the line about good intentions.
Simon claims not to know its meaning. That refusal is the film’s central tension. Gordo is trying to repair something Simon never wanted repaired.
The Dinner Party
The dinner party is where the film’s central mystery peaks. Gordo invites the Callems over, claims the other couple cancelled, and then excuses himself for an urgent call. When he returns, he tells them the house belongs to his wife, who left him with their two kids. Simon is suspicious and tells Gordo to stay away. Robyn thinks it’s harmless.
That split is the film’s central engine. It drives every scene after it. Simon feels fear. Robyn feels comforted. Edgerton knows exactly where that split lands, and he spends the runtime building pressure underneath it.
Robyn’s Fall
Robyn faints at home. When she wakes in bed the next morning, Simon confronts her about the stolen pills. She admits she had a problem in Chicago. Things improve over time. Robyn becomes pregnant. One day, she sees Gordo watching.
The film doesn’t rush this reveal. It builds it slowly, through small details that add up: the running faucets, the footsteps, the dog’s disappearance, the dead koi. Each gift carries a small promise. Each gift also carries a warning.
The Cast
The supporting cast fills out the world around the Callems. Tim Griffin plays Kevin Keelor. Allison Tolman plays Lucy. Busy Philipps plays Duffy. Adam Lazarre-White plays Ron. Beau Knapp plays Detective Walker. Wendell Pierce plays Detective Mills. Mirrah Foulkes plays Wendy Dale. Nash Edgerton plays Frank Dale, in addition to his duties as the film’s stunt coordinator.
Jason Blum and Rebecca Yeldham co-produced the film. The production was tight, with a budget of $5 million and a runtime of 108 minutes.
Release and Response
The film was released in the United States on August 7, 2015, as the first film released by STX Entertainment. Critics responded positively to The Gift, praising Edgerton’s direction and screenplay, as well as Bateman, Hall and Edgerton’s performances. The film grossed $60 million worldwide on a budget of $5 million. That’s a modest return, but it’s a solid one for a film this small-scale.
The result was a thriller that stayed focused on the characters rather than the scares. Joel Edgerton directed, wrote, produced and acted in the lead role. Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall anchored the drama.
The Review
Critics responded positively to The Gift. The film grossed $60 million worldwide on a budget of $5 million. That’s a modest return, but it’s a solid one for a film this small-scale. The film was released in the United States on August 7, 2015, as the first film released by STX Entertainment.
The film’s success came from careful execution. Joel Edgerton directed, wrote, produced and acted in the lead role. Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall anchored the drama. The result was a thriller that stayed focused on the characters rather than the scares.
Final Word
The Gift is a tense, slow-burning thriller that rewards patience. The performances are strong across the board, especially Bateman and Hall, who sell the friction between Simon’s suspicion and Robyn’s comfort. The script holds together well, even when the pacing falters.
The film is a confident debut from Joel Edgerton, and it stands on its own terms. It’s worth watching for the craft on display, even if the final act stumbles.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
