Michael Bay’s The Island arrived in July 2005 with a premise borrowed from science fiction’s back catalogue and a budget that could have funded a small space program. It cost $126 million to produce. It opened on July 22, 2005, distributed by DreamWorks Pictures in North America and Warner Bros. Pictures internationally. It earned $36 million at the United States box office and $127 million overseas, for a $162 million worldwide total.
Trailer, via Amblin Entertainment.
Lincoln Six Echo and the Lottery
The film opens in 2019 inside a sealed compound. Ewan McGregor plays Lincoln Six Echo, a resident of what the movie calls a Utopian facility. Scarlett Johansson plays Jordan Two Delta. They and everyone else in the compound live under a strict set of rules.
The residents are told the outside world is too contaminated to support life, save for one pathogen-free island. Each week, a lottery selects one resident to leave and go live there. The tagline is “Your time will come…”
Lincoln starts having dreams he knows are not from his own experiences. Dr. Bernard Merrick, the scientist who runs the compound and is played by Sean Bean, grows concerned and places probes in Lincoln’s body to monitor his cerebral activity. That is the setup. It is efficient, and it is familiar.
The Moth in the Ventilation Shaft
Lincoln secretly visits the off-limits power facility in the basement, where technician James McCord, played by Steve Buscemi, works. There he finds a live moth in a ventilation shaft. That single insect tells him the outside world is not contaminated after all.
He follows the moth to another section and finds the truth. The lottery is a system to remove inhabitants from the compound. The winner is used for organ harvesting, surrogate pregnancies and other purposes for a wealthy sponsor. Every resident is a clone of that sponsor.
Merrick learns Lincoln knows. Lincoln runs. Jordan has just been selected for the island, and she runs with him. They come out in the desert. He explains what he has found. Merrick hires Albert Laurent, a Burkinabé mercenary and former GIGN operative played by Djimon Hounsou, to bring them back.
What the Movie Does With Its Own Idea
This is where The Island should tighten into something sharp. Instead it loosens. Lincoln and Jordan find McCord in a bar. He lays out the full scheme: the residents are clones of wealthy sponsors, kept ignorant about the real world and conditioned never to question their environment or their history. It is a clean explanation of a premise the audience worked out an hour earlier.
The film has been described as a pastiche of “escape-from-dystopia” science fiction from the 1960s and 1970s — Fahrenheit 451, THX 1138, Parts: The Clonus Horror, Logan’s Run. That description is accurate, and it is not a compliment. A pastiche can be a homage or a heist. The Island never decides which one it is doing.
Michael Clarke Duncan and the Supporting Cast
The cast is deeper than the script deserves. Michael Clarke Duncan plays Starkweather Two Delta, also called Jamal Starkweather. Ethan Phillips is Jones Three Echo. Brian Stepanek is Gandu Three Echo. Noa Tishby voices the community announcer, that calm voice that runs the compound’s daily life. Siobhan Flynn is Lima One Alpha. Troy Blendell and Jamie McBride play members of Laurent’s team.
Buscemi gets the best of the small roles, because McCord is the one character allowed to be amused by any of this. Hounsou has the harder job. Bean plays Merrick as a man doing sums, which is the right read and the only interesting one available.
The Problem Is the Middle
Bay can stage a chase. The escape from the compound, the run through the desert, the pursuit — these move. The runtime is 136 minutes, and the first act earns its length. The compound is built with real texture: the rules, the lottery, the announcer, the power facility in the basement. You believe the place.
Then the film leaves it, and the belief drains out. The conspiracy, once explained, has no second layer. The villains are wealthy sponsors who use the clones for organ harvesting and surrogacy. That is a real thing to be afraid of, but the movie treats it as a reveal rather than a system.
The middle of The Island is where the film stops being about anything. It becomes a series of set pieces connected by exposition. McCord’s bar speech is the clearest example. It is a lecture, and it arrives after the audience has already done the work.
What Actually Holds Up
Two things. The first is the moth. A live insect in a ventilation shaft is a small, concrete, physical clue, and it is the best-written moment in the film. Lincoln does not hack a computer or find a file. He sees a bug where no bug should be. That is how you write discovery.
The second is the lottery itself. The weekly ceremony, the announcer, the hope — that is the film’s real invention. It is a machine for making people want to die. The residents do not resist it. They compete for it. That idea is worth a better movie than the one wrapped around it.
The published critical score is 5.0 out of 10, with a Metacritic score of 50 out of 100. That is the right number, and it is right for a specific reason. The Island is not a bad film. It is a film with a good first act, a strong central image and no idea what to do after the reveal.
The Order of What Went Wrong
Here is the sequence, ranked by how much each choice cost the film:
- The reveal arrives too early and explains too much. Once McCord lays out the cloning scheme in the bar, there is nothing left to discover.
- The outside world is never made real. The compound is a place. The desert, the bar, the city — these are backdrops.
- Laurent is hired to find and return the clones, and the film does little with the assignment beyond the chase.
- The runtime. At 136 minutes, the film has room to develop its ideas and spends that room on pursuit instead.
- The lottery. It is the best idea in the film, and it is abandoned once Lincoln and Jordan leave the compound.
That list is not a list of failures of craft. Bay’s craft is fine. It is a list of failures of nerve. The film keeps reaching for the safe version of its own story.
The Verdict on The Island
The Island wants to be a warning about people who will build a whole class of human beings to harvest. It has the cast for it. McGregor and Johansson are both better than the material, and they play the clone confusion straight, which is the correct choice. The compound is a genuinely unsettling creation. The moth is a genuinely good scene.
But the film is a pastiche that never becomes its own thing. It borrows the look and the structure of better movies without borrowing their willingness to sit in the discomfort. The dystopia here is a set. The conspiracy is a speech. The escape is a chase.
The source gives $126 million to produce and a $162 million worldwide total. Those are the figures, and they are the only ones on the record here. Mixed reviews were the correct response to a film that is half a good idea.
The part worth watching is the first act, and the part worth remembering is the moth. Everything after the ventilation shaft is a movie that has already told you its secret and has nothing else to say.
5 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
