“Everybody Loves Raymond” ran on CBS for nine seasons and 210 episodes, from September 13, 1996, to May 16, 2005. It won 15 Emmys from 69 nominations. It is, by any measure the industry keeps, one of the most decorated sitcoms of its era.
It is also, at 6.8 out of 10, a show whose reputation runs ahead of its achievement.
The case for “Everybody Loves Raymond” starts with its premise. Ray Barone (Ray Romano) is a sportswriter for Newsday. He lives in Lynbrook, Long Island, with his wife Debra (Patricia Heaton) and their three children: Ally (Madylin Sweeten) and the twins Geoffrey and Michael (Sawyer and Sullivan Sweeten). His parents, Frank (Peter Boyle) and Marie (Doris Roberts), and his brother Robert (Brad Garrett), live directly across the street.
That is the whole engine. A man with a wife and three kids, and his family of origin close enough to walk over unannounced. The show built nine years on it.
Trailer, via Everybody Loves Raymond.
Phil Rosenthal and the CBS Turnaround
Phil Rosenthal created the series. It was produced by Where’s Lunch and Worldwide Pants Incorporated, in association with HBO Independent Productions, and most episodes were filmed in front of a live studio audience.
That live-audience detail matters more than it sounds. A multi-camera sitcom shot before a crowd has to earn its laughs in the room, and “Everybody Loves Raymond” did. The show has been credited with helping revive CBS after the network struggled through the late 1980s and early 1990s. That credit is real. CBS in the mid-1990s was not the CBS of the 1970s, and this show was part of what pulled it back.
The cast is the strongest argument the series has. Romano plays a version of himself — a stand-up comic turned sitcom father, loosely based on the real Romano, who also has twin boys and a girl. Heaton’s Debra is overworked, underappreciated and stressed, and the show lets her yell and occasionally attack inanimate objects. Garrett’s Robert is 6 feet 8½ inches, the tallest Barone, jealous of the attention Marie gives Ray, and possessed of a nervous habit of touching food to his chin before eating it — once called “crazy chin.” Roberts and Boyle, both film actors, play Marie and Frank.
Marie Barone and the Favoritism Engine
Marie favors Ray over Robert. That is the show’s central wound, and it is the reason Robert works as a character rather than a punchline. Robert has been a New York City police officer for over 23 years. He has achievements. They do not register with his mother. The show returns to this again and again, and it is the closest “Everybody Loves Raymond” comes to genuine pain.
Ray, meanwhile, is emotionally unable to take a stand on anything, especially if it puts him in conflict with his mother. The exception, per the show’s own logic, is when he protests about sex or some trivial matter. That is a sharp character note. It is also a narrow one. A protagonist who cannot engage is a protagonist who cannot change, and nine seasons is a long time to watch a man not change.
Debra’s frustration boils over and gets vented at Ray. She has a fractious relationship with Marie, but shares tender moments with Robert and occasionally Frank. Monica Horan plays Amy MacDougall-Barone, who becomes part of the family. The relationships are drawn with care. The question is whether care is the same as depth.
What the Rankings Actually Say
The awards and rankings are where the gap between reputation and quality shows.
| Measure | Source | Rank or count |
|---|---|---|
| Emmy Awards | Academy of Television Arts & Sciences | 15 wins from 69 nominations |
| All-time funniest TV comedy | Complex | 49th |
| Best all-time series | TV Guide | 60th |
| Best sitcom starring a stand-up comedian | Rolling Stone | 11th |
| Best sitcom of all time | Rolling Stone | 35th |
| Best written TV series (with South Park) | Writers Guild of America | 63rd |
| All-time television programs | Hollywood Reporter poll of 779 actors, 365 producers, 268 directors | 96th |
Look at that table closely. Fifteen Emmys is a serious haul. But the rankings tell a different story. Complex puts it 49th among funniest comedies. TV Guide puts it 60th among all series. The Writers Guild puts it 63rd for writing, alongside South Park. In the Hollywood Reporter poll — 779 actors, 365 producers, 268 directors — it lands 96th.
Those are respectable numbers. They are not numbers that describe a canonized classic. A show that wins 15 Emmys usually ranks higher than 96th among industry professionals. The industry gave “Everybody Loves Raymond” awards. The industry did not, when polled, put it near the top.
The Casting That Made It Work
The casting is genuinely interesting, and it explains why the show works as well as it does.
Casting director Lisa Miller chose Heaton and Garrett for the non-titular leads, and Roberts and Boyle, both film actors, for the parents. For Heaton, this was her fourth lead role in a sitcom, after “Room for Two” (1992–1993), “Someone Like Me” (1994) and “Women of the House” (1995). She read the pilot during pilot season and thought it was “beautifully written,” though she found Debra uninteresting. She was babysitting and clipping coupons at the time, which made her stressed — and that stress is in the performance.
Miller had to “Taft-Hartley” Romano, who did not have much acting experience, to get around Screen Actors Guild requirements. He needed trainers to make sure he played a likable protagonist. That is worth sitting with. The star of a nine-season hit needed help being likable. The show’s solution was to write him as passive, and Romano’s natural low-key delivery carried it.
Garrett was the first actor cast after Romano, and the only one to audition without Romano in the room. CBS initially wanted a small, Danny DeVito-esque character with a “bulldog” attitude toward Ray. Garrett, much taller, played Robert as more “beaten-down” and, in his words, “succumb[ing] to the fact that he’s a loser.”
He, a much taller actor, portrayed Robert as more “beaten-down” and “succumb[ing] to the fact that he’s a loser”
That choice is the best thing in the show. Robert as a beaten-down giant is funnier and sadder than Robert as a bulldog. Garrett found the character the writers then had to write toward.
Where the Show Falls Short
Here is the problem with “Everybody Loves Raymond,” and it is the reason 6.8 is the right score rather than something in the eights.
The show is competent at everything and transcendent at nothing. It has a great cast, a clean premise and a reliable joke engine. It does not have a point of view about its own material. Ray’s passivity is presented as a comic flaw, not examined as a failure. Marie’s favoritism is a running gag, not a study of what it does to Robert over decades. Debra’s rage is a punchline about housework.
The live-audience format is part of that. Shot before a crowd, the show plays for the room. That means big reactions, broad beats and jokes that land on the first bounce. It is skilled work. It is also safe work.
The Verdict on Everybody Loves Raymond
The 15 Emmys are real. The CBS turnaround credit is real. The cast — Romano, Heaton, Garrett, Roberts, Boyle, Madylin Sweeten, Monica Horan — is real, and Garrett’s Robert is the performance that will last.
But the rankings are the tell. A show that professionals rank 96th among all television programs, 63rd for writing, and 49th among comedies is a good show, not a great one. The awards reflect a well-liked, well-made sitcom that CBS needed. The polls reflect what people actually think when they are not handing out trophies.
“Everybody Loves Raymond” is a show you can watch for nine seasons without ever being surprised. That is a compliment and a limit, and the limit is why it sits at 6.8.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.