Twin Peaks: the dead girl, the FBI agent, and the town that never explains itself
The body of Laura Palmer washes up on a beach near a small Washington state town, and FBI Special Agent Dale Cooper arrives to investigate. That is the first hour of Twin Peaks, and it is still one of the most efficient hooks American television has produced.
Agent Cooper and the Town That Watches Back
David Lynch and Mark Frost created Twin Peaks, which premiered on ABC on April 8, 1990, and ran two seasons until its cancellation in 1991. The show returned in 2017 for a third season on Showtime. Three seasons, 48 episodes, first aired in April 1990, last aired in September 2017.
The series follows Cooper, played by Kyle MacLachlan, as he works the murder of local teenager Laura Palmer, played by Sheryl Lee. The narrative borrows from detective fiction. But its uncanny tone, supernatural elements, and campy, melodramatic portrayal of eccentric characters pull just as hard from American horror and soap opera. Lynch’s fingerprints are on the surrealism, the distinctive cinematography, and the offbeat humor. Angelo Badalamenti composed the score with Lynch.
What holds it together is MacLachlan. He plays Cooper straight, and the show needs that. Around him the town is a nest of oddities, and the murder is only the surface of it. The investigation leads Cooper deep into the surrounding woodland and into his own soul. That is the actual subject.
Sheryl Lee, Cast by Accident
The casting story is worth telling because it explains the show’s power.
Lynch intended to cast a local girl from Seattle as Laura Palmer, reportedly “just to play a dead girl,” because of budget constraints. The local girl was Sheryl Lee. Lynch later said: “But no one—not Mark, me, anyone—had any idea that she could act, or that she was going to be so powerful just being dead.”
Then Lynch shot the home movie that James takes of Donna and Laura, and he saw something. “She did do another scene—the video with Donna on the picnic—and it was that scene that did it,” he said. Lee became a semi-regular addition, appearing in flashbacks as Laura and playing Maddy Ferguson, Laura’s similar-looking cousin.
The show also stocked its cast with actors from an earlier era. Richard Beymer, Piper Laurie, and Russ Tamblyn came from 1950s film. James Booth, Michael Ontkean, and Peggy Lipton filled out the veteran ranks. Isabella Rossellini was originally cast as Giovanna Packard but dropped out before shooting on the pilot. The character was reconceived as Josie Packard, of Chinese ethnicity, and the role went to Joan Chen.
What Twin Peaks Built
The original run was followed by the 1992 feature film Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me, a prequel to the series. The success created a media franchise, with tie-in books starting with The Secret Diary of Laura Palmer. The 2017 revival, under Lynch’s direction, included much of the original cast.
The show’s afterlife is the part that matters most. It gained a devoted cult following and has been referenced across a wide variety of media. The accolades include a Golden Globe Award and nominations for 27 Primetime Emmy Awards, with two wins.
Here is the ranking of what the show gets right, in order of how much it matters:
- The central murder and Cooper’s investigation, which give the surrealism a spine.
- The uncanny tone and the soap opera melodrama, which make the town feel alive and wrong at once.
- Badalamenti’s score with Lynch, which sets the register before a single line lands.
- The offbeat humor, which keeps the dread from becoming a monotone.
Strip out any one of those and the whole thing sags.
| Element | First two seasons (ABC) | Third season (Showtime) |
|---|---|---|
| Network | ABC | Showtime |
| Run | 1990–1991 | 2017 |
| Created by | Lynch and Frost | Lynch and Frost |
| Cast | Original ensemble | Much of the original cast |
The Verdict on Twin Peaks
The first two seasons are the ones that changed television. In this paper’s view, they showed that a mass audience would follow a murder mystery into pure surrealism, and they did it on a broadcast network with commercials. That is the achievement. The 2017 season is a different animal: less a continuation than a return. Whether it works is a matter of taste, but it does not depend on the original cast carrying it.
The weak point is the same as the strong point. The show’s refusal to resolve is what makes it memorable and what makes stretches of it maddening. The uncanny tone is not a flaw to be fixed. It is the engine.
Twin Peaks does not need a defense in 2026. Its influence is everywhere, and the cult following it earned after cancellation has long since been vindicated. The thing to note is how much of it still holds up on its own terms: the pilot, the score, Lee’s dead girl who turned out to be the whole show.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.