ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

A pianist who can’t hear his own playing finds a violinist who won’t let him quit

Your Lie in April: a piano prodigy who can't hear his own playing, a violinist who drags him back, and the lie that ends it. Review of the 2014 anime.

By mitch·6 min read
A solitary pianist sits before an empty grand piano in a dimly lit hall.

A piano prodigy stops hearing the instrument. That is the hook of Your Lie in April, and it is a better one than most series manage across a full run. Kōsei Arima was a child star, nicknamed the “Human Metronome” for his mechanical accuracy, until his mother Saki died and he broke down mid-recital. After that he could not hear his own playing. The notes flew off the page; all he heard was the thud of keys. He was fourteen. He quit.

Two years later, a violinist named Kaori Miyazono drags him back.

Your Lie in April aired on Fuji TV’s NoitaminA block from October 2014 to March 2015. It runs 22 episodes, one season, adapted by A-1 Pictures from Naoshi Arakawa’s manga, which was serialized in Kodansha’s Monthly Shōnen Magazine from April 2011 to February 2015. The show is classified as animation, comedy and drama. The comedy is the weakest of the three.

Advertisement

Trailer, via Aniplex USA.

Kōsei Arima and the Piano He Cannot Hear

The premise is a gimmick until it isn’t. Kōsei’s condition is specific: his hearing is otherwise unaffected, but his own piano produces only the sound of the keys coming down. He cannot hear the music he makes. He can hear everyone else’s.

That is the whole engine of the series, and it is a good one. Kōsei spends the early episodes avoiding the instrument. He double-checks sheet music for a part-time job, which is the only piano he touches. He views the world in monochrome, a detail the show takes literally in its palette before Kaori arrives and color creeps back in.

Natsuki Hanae voices Kōsei in Japanese, with Max Mittelman in English. Kento Yamazaki played him in the 2016 live-action film, and Shintarō Anzai in the stage adaptation. Hanae’s read is the spine of the thing. Kōsei is not sullen so much as hollowed out, and the performance keeps him sympathetic when the script lets him drift.

Kaori Miyazono Plays the Score Wrong on Purpose

Kaori is the corrective. She is Tsubaki’s classmate, a free-spirited violinist who has been criticized by judging panels for refusing to adhere strictly to the score. Audiences love her anyway. Her playing reflects her manic personality, and that is the point.

She meets Kōsei because she asks Tsubaki to set her up with Ryōta. That detail matters. Kaori does not arrive as a manic pixie sent to fix a boy. She arrives with her own wants, and the show lets her keep them. Risa Taneda voices her in Japanese, Erica Lindbeck in English. Suzu Hirose played her in the film, Arisa Matsunaga on stage.

Kaori convinces Kōsei to play again, first as her accompanist, later in a competition. She shows him his playing can be free and groundbreaking rather than metronomic.

The Lie, the Anemia, and the Surgery

Halfway through, the show changes shape. Kaori collapses during a performance. She later explains she is anemic and needs routine testing. She invites Kōsei to play with her at a gala. She does not arrive.

Her health deteriorates. She becomes dejected. Kōsei, meanwhile, is competing against Takeshi Aiza and Emi Igawa, two fourteen-year-olds who took up piano after watching him perform when they were younger. He befriends Takeshi’s younger sister Nagi and plays a duet with her. That duet motivates Kaori to attempt a risky and potentially deadly surgery so she might play with Kōsei once more.

She dies during the operation. Kōsei realizes it while playing the finals of the Eastern Japan Piano Competition, seeing her spirit accompanying him.

The show does not hide the ending so much as delay it. The title tells you there is a lie. The lie is not complicated. What matters is that the series earns the grief rather than springing it.

Tsubaki Sawabe and the Friends Left Standing

The supporting cast does real work. Ayane Sakura voices Tsubaki Sawabe, Kōsei’s childhood friend and next-door neighbor, who treats him like a younger brother and is concerned by his inability to move past his mother’s death. Erica Mendez voices her in English; Anna Ishii played her in the film, Misato Kawauchi on stage. Ryōta Watari, voiced by Ryota Osaka, rounds out the group.

Takeshi and Emi exist mostly as mirrors — what Kōsei looks like from the outside to people he inspired without knowing it. Nagi gives the back third a second relationship to carry, which the show needs once Kaori is hospitalized.

The cast, in parallel:

  • Natsuki Hanae as Kōsei Arima (voice)
  • Risa Taneda as Kaori Miyazono (voice)
  • Ayane Sakura as Tsubaki Sawabe (voice)
  • Ryota Osaka as Ryouta Watari (voice)

Why the Manga’s Reception Split and the Anime’s Didn’t

The manga won the 37th Kodansha Manga Award in the shōnen category in 2013. By June 2017 it had over 5 million copies in circulation. Its reviews were mixed. Critics praised the plot and characters and criticized the artwork and the emotional aspect — that last complaint is the interesting one, because it is the same charge that gets leveled at the anime by people who bounce off it.

The anime was largely praised for its plot, animation and soundtrack. That split is worth sitting with. The emotional register is not a bug in the adaptation; it is the adaptation’s whole bet. A-1 Pictures committed to it, and the soundtrack does more to sell the premise than any single scene. A show about a boy who cannot hear his own piano lives or dies on whether the music lands. Here it does.

The score sits at 8.6 out of 10 on TMDB across 1,181 audience votes. That is a high number for a series this willing to be maudlin.

What Actually Holds Up

The premise is the strongest thing here, and it is not a small thing. A protagonist whose disability is specific and tied directly to the art form the show is about — that is a clean piece of construction. Kōsei cannot hear himself. He can hear Kaori. The show builds 22 episodes on that asymmetry and mostly pays it off.

The comedy is the weak link. It sits awkwardly against the hospital scenes and the competition pressure, and it thins out as the series goes, which is the right instinct arriving late.

The ending is the part that will decide it for most viewers. Kaori’s death is telegraphed, and the show knows it is telegraphed. The question is whether the final competition sequence, with Kōsei playing while realizing she is gone, justifies the build. It does. The series is not subtle about grief, and it is not interested in being subtle. What it is interested in is the moment a performer stops performing and starts playing, and it gets there.

Your Lie in April is a melodrama that knows exactly what it is. The lie in the title is small. The loss is not, and neither is the recovery. It is one of the better music dramas of its decade, and it holds up because the central mechanic — a boy who cannot hear his own sound — is stranger and sadder than the romance wrapped around it.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.