Misfits turned a dirty community service yard into a superhero origin story, then spent five series refusing to act like one. The show premiered on E4 on 12 November 2009 and ended on 11 December 2013, running five series and 37 episodes under creator Howard Overman. The premise is simple: five young offenders sentenced to work in a community service programme get caught in a strange electrical storm and wake up with powers.
What made Misfits last is that the powers were almost never the point. The show is filed under Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Drama and Comedy, and it earns all three, but its real subject is a group of young people who have been written off by everyone, suddenly handed something that should change their lives and mostly using it badly.
Trailer, via Hulu.
Nathan Young, Alisha Daniels and the First Storm
The original cast arrived in 2009 and carried the show through its first two series. Antonia Thomas played Alisha Daniels, Iwan Rheon played Simon Bellamy, Lauren Socha played Kelly Bailey, Nathan Stewart-Jarrett played Curtis Donovan and Robert Sheehan played Nathan Young. That lineup is the reason people still argue about when Misfits peaked.
Sheehan left after the second series. His exit is the show’s first real fracture, and it is a hard one to take, because Nathan Young is the loudest engine the series ever had. Replacing him was never going to be clean.
Rudy Wade and the Rebuild
Joseph Gilgun joined in the third series as Rudy Wade. In this paper’s view, Rudy is a different kind of chaos rather than a copy of what came before, and Gilgun’s performance is the main reason the group holds together through the handover.
Then came the bigger break. After the third series, it was announced that Rheon, Thomas and Socha had left, and new cast members arrived: Karla Crome as Jess, Nathan McMullen as Finn Samson and Matt Stokoe as Alex. Midway through the fourth series, Stewart-Jarrett left as well, while Natasha O’Keeffe joined the cast as Abbey Smith.
By the end, the show had cycled through almost its entire original ensemble. That is a lot of turnover for a series built on a fixed group of five.
| Era | Cast additions | Cast departures | Series |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original run | Thomas, Rheon, Socha, Stewart-Jarrett, Sheehan | None | 1–2 |
| Rudy era | Gilgun as Rudy Wade | Sheehan after series 2 | 3 |
| Rebuild | Crome, McMullen, Stokoe | Rheon, Thomas, Socha after series 3 | 4–5 |
| Final stretch | O’Keeffe as Abbey Smith | Stewart-Jarrett midway through series 4 | 4–5 |
What the Powers Actually Do for the Show
Misfits works best when it treats the storm as an inconvenience rather than a calling. The premise gives the group a reason to stay in each other’s orbit, and the comedy comes from the gap between what they can do and what they are willing to do with it.
The genres listed for the show — Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Drama, Comedy — sit in that order, but the drama is doing more work than the label suggests. The series is about young offenders on a community service programme, and it never lets you forget the sentence hanging over them.
That is also why the cast changes hurt more than they should. When a show is about a specific five people, swapping three of them out is not a refresh. It is a different show wearing the same title.
Jess, Finn, Alex and the Cost of a Recast
The fourth and fifth series are where Misfits becomes a test of loyalty. Crome, McMullen and Stokoe are asked to carry a premise that was built around people the audience already knew, and the show keeps running because the format is sturdy.
The format is sturdy. That is the honest read. A strange storm, a group of outsiders, powers they did not ask for — that engine will turn over with almost any cast, and Misfits proves it by surviving three major exits and still reaching a fifth series.
But surviving is not the same as thriving. Our view is that the later series are watchable without being rewatchable, and that the original five were the best version of the show — a judgment about the performances, not a fact the source establishes about cast chemistry.
The Score and What It Measures
The published audience score for Misfits is 7.6 out of 10, based on 1,060 votes on TMDB. That number is a fair summary of a show that is better than its worst series and not as good as its best one.
A 7.6 is the score of a series with a great first act, a messy middle and a final stretch that keeps the lights on. It is not a knock. Five series and 37 episodes over four years of broadcast, 2009 to 2013, is a real run, and Misfits earned it.
The part worth watching is still the beginning. If you only ever see one stretch of Misfits, make it the first two series, with Sheehan, Thomas, Rheon, Socha and Stewart-Jarrett. That is the version of the show that made its reputation, and it is the version the 7.6 is really measuring.
The rest is a lesson in how long a good premise can carry a show after the people who made it good have gone. Misfits never became bad. It became a different, lesser thing, and it kept going anyway.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.