Frank Capra’s It’s a Wonderful Life arrived in 1946 as a Christmas fantasy drama that few expected to become a holiday staple. It stars James Stewart as George Bailey, a man in Bedford Falls who has spent his life giving to others and who, on Christmas Eve, stands ready to take his own life. The film runs 131 minutes. It was nominated for five Academy Awards, including Best Picture, and lost money anyway.
Trailer, via Paramount Movies.
George Bailey and the $8,000
The story turns on money and what it costs to be decent. George keeps Bailey Brothers Building and Loan alive against Henry F. Potter, the avaricious board member who owns most of the town. George gives his tuition savings to his brother Harry. He and Mary Hatch, played by Donna Reed, skip their honeymoon to keep the company solvent during a run on the bank. On Christmas Eve, Uncle Billy loses $8,000, and George’s troubles begin.
That is the engine of the film: a man’s small, unglamorous sacrifices stacked so high they become a life.
Clarence Odbody Earns His Wings
The intervention comes from above. Clarence Odbody, a guardian angel second class played by Henry Travers, is assigned to save George so he can earn his wings. Clarence shows him the lives he touched and what Bedford Falls would look like had he never existed. Lionel Barrymore plays Potter. Thomas Mitchell plays Uncle Billy.
Capra cast Stewart without Stewart hearing the story first, according to Capra’s autobiography. Henry Fonda was also considered. Ginger Rogers turned down the role of Mary because she considered it “too bland,” a decision she later questioned in her memoir. For 17 supporting roles, Capra considered more than 170 established actors.
The performances hold because Stewart plays a good man who does not know he is one. That was the hardest role to cast, and Capra knew it.
Here is what matters most about It’s a Wonderful Life, ranked:
- Stewart’s George, the film’s whole argument in one performance.
- The final act, where Clarence’s tour turns sentiment into something earned.
- Donna Reed’s Mary, warmer and sharper than the script requires.
- Barrymore’s Potter, a villain with no redeeming scene and no need for one.
The film’s break-even point was $6.3 million, roughly twice its production cost, and it did not come close on release. Its U.S. copyright expired in 1974 after a lack of renewal, and it entered the public domain. That accident, more than any marketing, made it a Christmas classic. The reputation is deserved, but the film earns it late. It is a slow build to a finale that still works.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
