Argo opens on a wall of noise. A mob is climbing the fence of the United States Embassy in Tehran. It is November 4, 1979. The staff inside are burning papers and dialing phones that will not save them. Sixty-six people are taken hostage. Six get out the back and end up in the home of the Canadian ambassador, Ken Taylor, where they will spend weeks pretending to be someone else.
That is the setup for a film that is, on its surface, about a fake movie. It is also the best thing Ben Affleck has directed, and the strongest argument that a procedural can carry real dread when the procedure is absurd enough.
Trailer, via Warner Bros..
The CIA Man in the Room
Tony Mendez is a CIA exfiltration specialist, played by Affleck with a beard and a flat, tired voice. The State Department brings him in to look at options for getting the six out. He listens to their proposals and picks them apart. He does not have a better idea. He goes home and watches Battle for the Planet of the Apes.
That is the hinge of the whole film. A man with no plan watches a bad science-fiction sequel and sees a way out. The cover story he builds asks the six Americans to pose as a Canadian film crew scouting locations in Iran for a science-fiction picture. They will walk through the airport in Tehran carrying call sheets and business cards that describe a film that does not exist.
It is a ridiculous idea, and Argo knows it. The film never asks you to believe the plan is clever in the abstract. It asks you to believe that in a situation with no good options, a ridiculous plan is a plan.
Lester Siegel and the Fake Office
Mendez needs the cover to hold up under inspection, so he calls John Chambers, a Hollywood make-up artist who has done work for the CIA before. Chambers, played by John Goodman, points him toward Lester Siegel, a producer played by Alan Arkin.
The three of them set up a phony production company and manufacture the pretense of developing Argo, described in the film as a science fantasy adventure in the style of Star Wars. The scenes of Siegel and Chambers building a fake film out of nothing are the loosest and funniest in the picture. Arkin gets the best lines and the best posture. He plays a man who has spent a career selling things that do not exist and is delighted to find that skill suddenly matters.
The movie was fake. The mission was real.
That tagline is the film’s whole thesis in eight words. The Hollywood material could have been a detour. Instead it is the spine. Argo argues that the machinery of illusion — the call sheets, the posters, the rented office — is not a joke layered on top of a serious rescue. It is the rescue.
Six People in a Living Room
The six escapees are the part of the film that keeps it from floating away. Tate Donovan plays Bob Anders. Clea DuVall is Cora Lijek. Scoot McNairy is Joe Stafford. Rory Cochrane is Lee Schatz. Christopher Denham is Mark Lijek. Kerry Bishé is Kathy Stafford.
They are not commandos. They are embassy staff who have been hiding in a diplomat’s house long enough to get restless, and the film lets that restlessness sit. Stafford is the hardest to move. He does not want to trust a stranger with a cover story, and McNairy plays the resistance without turning it into a speech.
Mendez enters Iran under the alias Kevin Harkins. He passes along Canadian passports and fake identities, working with the cooperation and under the authority of the Canadian government. The six go along reluctantly, knowing Mendez is risking his own life alongside theirs. That detail is what makes the second half work. The Americans are not cargo. They are participants in their own escape, and every one of them knows the cost of a mistake.
The Bazaar and the Photographs
Two sequences tighten the screws. The first is a scouting visit to the bazaar, staged to keep the cover story alive. A hostile shopkeeper harasses the group and the visit turns bad. It is a small scene and it does more work than a chase would, because it shows how thin the cover really is. One suspicious man in a market is enough to end everything.
The second is quieter and worse. The revolutionaries reassemble embassy photographs that were shredded before the takeover. They realize some personnel are unaccounted for. The film does not need to explain what that means. The audience gets there first, and the rest of the runtime is spent waiting for the knock.
Bryan Cranston and the Clock
Bryan Cranston plays Jack O’Donnell, Mendez’s handler, and he is the film’s engine in the back half. He is the one pushing, calling, and running out of time while the escape plays out thousands of miles away. Kyle Chandler appears as Hamilton Jordan. Victor Garber plays Ken Taylor, the Canadian ambassador whose house and whose country make the operation possible.
Affleck directs all of this with a steady hand. The editing, which won an Academy Award, is the film’s real star. Argo cuts between Tehran and Washington and the fake production office in Los Angeles, and the crosscutting builds pressure without ever feeling like a gimmick. Alexandre Desplat’s score stays out of the way until it needs to push.
The screenplay is by Chris Terrio, adapted from Tony Mendez’s 1999 memoir The Master of Disguise and Joshuah Bearman’s 2007 Wired article “The Great Escape: How the CIA Used a Fake Sci-Fi Flick to Rescue Americans from Tehran.” Terrio’s script is efficient. It explains the mechanics of an exfiltration without turning into a briefing, and it gives every supporting player at least one moment that lands.
What Argo Gets Wrong
The film has been criticized for historical accuracy, including by commentators and by people who took part in the actual operation. That criticism is fair and it matters. Argo compresses, invents tension, and gives the CIA a larger role in the final escape than the record supports. The Canadian government’s contribution is acknowledged on screen, but the film’s center of gravity is always the American operative in the room.
This is the trade a historical thriller makes, and Argo makes it knowingly. The question is whether the invention serves the story or replaces it. Here it mostly serves. The film is not pretending to be a documentary. It is a movie about a movie, and it is honest about the fact that the version of events it is selling has been shaped for an audience.
What holds up is the texture. The fear in the living room. The absurdity of the production office. The way a cover story becomes a lifeline. Argo is a film about people who survive because someone else was willing to build a lie carefully enough to walk through.
The Score
Argo grossed $232 million worldwide and won three Academy Awards from seven nominations: Best Picture, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Film Editing. It won two Golden Globes, for Best Motion Picture – Drama and Best Director, with Arkin nominated for Best Supporting Actor. The runtime is 120 minutes.
The film earns its place. It is a thriller that trusts its audience to understand the stakes without being told, and a Hollywood satire that never undercuts the seriousness of what is happening in Tehran. The two halves do not fight each other. They reinforce each other, which is harder than it looks.
The weakest stretch is the middle, where the escapees circle the same argument about whether to trust Mendez. The film finds its footing again the moment the photographs come back together. That is the detail worth remembering. Not the chase, not the airport, but the quiet bureaucratic work of a revolution reassembling shredded paper until it finds the names that are missing.
Argo is not a perfect film. It is a confident one, made by people who knew exactly what story they were telling and what they were willing to bend to tell it. That confidence is the reason it still plays.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
