The bunker has a skylight. That is the detail 10 Cloverfield Lane hangs on, and it is the detail that makes the film work. Michelle finds it in the control room, padlocked from the inside, with the word “HELP” scratched into the glass and an earring she recognizes from a photograph Howard showed her. Everything before that moment is a tense two-hander about trust. Everything after it is a countdown.
Dan Trachtenberg directs in his first feature, from a script by Josh Campbell, Matthew Stuecken and Damien Chazelle. It runs 104 minutes. The film is the second entry in the Cloverfield franchise, produced by J. J. Abrams and Lindsey Weber, and it began life as a spec script called The Cellar before Bad Robot turned it into a standalone sequel to the 2008 found-footage film.
Trailer, via Paramount Pictures.
Howard, Michelle and the Truck That Hit Her Car
Mary Elizabeth Winstead plays Michelle, who leaves her New Orleans apartment after an argument with her fiancé. That night she drives through rural Louisiana and hears news reports of blackouts in several major cities. A truck strikes her car off the road. She wakes chained in a bunker with an injured leg.
John Goodman is Howard, the man who took her there. He says he saved her life, that the air outside is poisoned after an attack, and he gives her a tour of the space he built. John Gallagher Jr. is Emmett, Howard’s construction assistant, who is already inside and who tells Michelle the attack is real — he begged to be let in after he saw it.
The cast is small and the room is smaller. Suzanne Cryer has a cameo as the woman who tries to enter the bunker, covered in lesions, screaming, and dies at the airlock. Bradley Cooper voices Ben, Michelle’s fiancé, in a cameo heard rather than seen.
A Viewport, Two Pigs and a Story That Mostly Holds
Howard shows Michelle two decayed pigs through a viewport at the airlock. He says the attack killed them. Michelle also sees Howard’s truck and remembers it striking her car. She talks to Emmett in private. He backs Howard’s story.
That is the film’s engine: two men, one woman, three accounts of the same night, and a sealed door. Howard’s version has holes. Emmett’s version has a witness. Michelle’s version has her own memory of the truck, which Howard later explains away by saying he hit her car by accident while rushing to the bunker.
The explanation is plausible. That is what makes it frightening. A lie that fits the available facts is harder to refuse than an obvious one.
The Dinner Table Is Where the Threat Lives
Howard turns jealous at dinner when Michelle and Emmett grow close. It is a small scene and it does more work than any of the film’s louder moments. The danger in 10 Cloverfield Lane is not the air outside. It is a man who built a bunker and now decides who gets to stay in it.
Michelle steals Howard’s keychain and runs for the airlock. She is about to open the outer door when she sees the woman with the lesions screaming to be let in. Michelle retreats. She is, for the moment, convinced.
That sequence is the film’s best argument for itself. It gives the audience the escape they want and then takes it away with evidence, not with a speech. The retreat costs Michelle something and it costs the viewer the same thing.
Over the following days the three of them settle into a routine. Howard talks about his daughter and shows Michelle a photograph. Something loud passes overhead. The ventilation system fails.
The Skylight, the Earring and the Scratched Word
Howard sends Michelle through a small duct to restart the ventilation. In the control room she finds the padlocked skylight with the word scratched into the glass and the earring from the photograph. She tells Emmett. He recognizes it.
This is the turn. Up to here the film has asked whether Howard is a liar or a lunatic. The skylight answers a different question: whether anyone has been in this bunker before Michelle, and what happened to her. The earring is the proof. The scratched word is the proof. The padlock is the proof.
The film is presented in a third-person narrative, unlike the found-footage style of its predecessor. That choice matters. A camera held by a character cannot show you a room that character has not entered. Trachtenberg’s camera can. It can show Michelle the photograph and then show her the earring in a locked room, and the audience can make the connection a beat before she does.
Where 10 Cloverfield Lane Sits Against Cloverfield
The two films share a title and a producer and very little else. The comparison is worth making because the franchise’s whole method depends on it.
| Cloverfield (2008) | 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) | |
|---|---|---|
| Narrative style | Found footage | Third person |
| Setting | New York City under attack | Underground bunker in rural Louisiana |
| Scale | Citywide destruction | Three people in one room |
| Threat | Visible monster | A man with a keychain |
| Production title | — | Valencia |
The table shows the trick. 10 Cloverfield Lane takes the franchise’s premise — something terrible has happened — and removes every way of confirming it. There is no skyline to watch fall. There is a viewport, two dead pigs and a man’s word.
What the Bunker Gets Right
The film premiered in New York City on March 8, 2016, and was released in select countries on March 10. It drew positive reviews and grossed over $110 million worldwide. A successor, The Cloverfield Paradox, was released on February 4, 2018.
Principal photography took place under the title Valencia in New Orleans, Louisiana. That is a small footprint for a film this controlled, and the control shows. The bunker is a single set with a handful of rooms, and Trachtenberg uses the duct, the airlock and the viewport as a full vocabulary of suspense.
Goodman is the reason it holds. Howard is warm for long stretches. He cooks. He explains. He shows you his daughter’s photograph. The performance never announces the threat, which means the threat is always present. Winstead carries the other half: Michelle is not a passenger, and the film gives her the keychain, the duct and the skylight to work with.
The Score
That is the published critical score, and it is close to right. The film’s first two acts are tighter than most thrillers manage, and the skylight reveal is a genuine piece of construction — evidence, not exposition. The third act is where the film spends some of that credit. Once the bunker stops being the whole world, the film has to decide what kind of movie it is, and it reaches for a bigger answer than the bunker acts earned.
The earring is the part worth watching. A photograph shown over dinner becomes a locked room becomes a decision. That is how you build a thriller: plant a small object, let the audience forget it, then hand it back at the worst possible moment. 10 Cloverfield Lane does that better than it does its ending, and better than most films in its franchise ever try.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
