Gears of War: Judgment released in North America and Australia on March 19, 2013, and in Europe on March 22. Developed by People Can Fly with Epic Games and published by Microsoft Studios for the Xbox 360, it is a prequel to the entire franchise and a spin-off of the Gears of War series. The answer it gives to how Damon Baird and Augustus Cole became the men players already knew is a courtroom.
Trailer, via XBOX.
Kilo Squad on Trial
Judgment sets its story six weeks after Emergence Day, the moment the Locust horde erupted from beneath the planet Sera. Baird, Cole, Onyx Guard cadet Sofia Hendrick and former UIR soldier Garron Paduk are put on trial by Colonel Ezra Loomis and given the chance to explain their actions. Each mission is a different member’s recollection, so the campaign unfolds as testimony rather than as a march forward.
The charge at the center of it is Baird’s unauthorized use of a Lightmass Missile, which carries a death penalty. Kilo defends themselves from a massive Locust attack, and Loomis has them arrested. The hearing is not an open thread; it is the frame the story resolves through.
The fighting runs through the coastal city of Halvo Bay: Old Town, the Museum of Military Glory, the Onyx Guard Academy, the Seashore Hills mansion of Professor Elliot, and the island of Onyx Point. Kilo encounters Locust General Karn and his mount Shibboleth at the museum, and the squad’s answer to him is the missile they are not supposed to fire.
Stars, Troy, and Aftermath
The campaign splits into six chapters, and unlike the wide environments of earlier Gears games, each mission is self-contained. You cannot return to an earlier mission’s setting. Every mission is scored on kills, head shots and gibs, with up to three stars awarded. An optional harder setting — a time limit, a restriction on usable weapons — raises the score.
Forty stars unlocks “Aftermath,” a separate one-chapter campaign that follows the events of Gears of War 3. It awards no stars and offers no harder setting.
| Feature | Main campaign | Aftermath |
|---|---|---|
| Chapters | Six | One |
| Star scoring | Yes | No |
| Harder optional setting | Yes | No |
| Story position | Prequel, six weeks after Emergence Day | Follow-up to Gears of War 3 |
The beacon bot Troy is the campaign’s best structural idea. Kilo protects it at the Academy, defends it while it downloads launch codes at Elliot’s mansion, then sends it across the rooftops of Old Town to guide the missile home.
What the Tribunal Gets Right
Rob Auten and Tom Bissell wrote the story, and Steve Jablonsky composed the score with Jacob Shea. Development began in 2011 after Gears of War 3, with Epic bringing in People Can Fly after the two studios collaborated on Bulletstorm the same year. The decision to set Judgment before the first game, and to follow Baird and Cole before they meet Marcus Fenix and Dominic Santiago, is the whole point of the exercise.
It mostly works. Baird as the sharp-tongued mechanical genius and Cole as the boisterous former Thrashball player are given room the trilogy never afforded them, and the tribunal frame gives the shooting a reason to be recounted.
The scoring system is where Judgment loses its footing. Star ratings and optional restrictions sit awkwardly against a series built on cover shooting, and the self-contained missions cut against the scale the earlier games traded on. The result is a tighter game that is also a smaller one.
The commercial story is blunter. Judgment underperformed, selling only 1 million copies by August 2013. Critics gave positive reactions, while fans gave a mixed reception.
What matters most is the frame. The tribunal structure and the Baird-and-Cole pairing are the parts worth the trip; the scoring gimmick and the shrunken maps are the parts that date it. This is a prequel that earns its place in the series by showing its leads cornered and explaining themselves — a smaller, stranger Gears than the trilogy promised, and more interesting for it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
