Hatoful Boyfriend is a visual novel about dating pigeons, and it knows exactly what it is. The 2011 game asks players to pick a feathered partner from a roster of male pigeon characters, then navigate a high school setting full of drama, side quests and occasional pigeon-related jokes. It is strange, occasionally mean-spirited and surprisingly easy to recommend despite its flaws.
Trailer, via DevolverDigital.
The Premise
The game takes place in a school populated almost entirely by birds. Students walk hallways, sit in classrooms and attend events like any other high school story, but the cast is composed of different species of pigeons. The protagonist is human, which sets up some friction with the bird-only world around her. The premise alone is enough to draw players in, even before they meet any of the characters.
The Cast
The roster of male pigeon characters offers a range of personalities. Each one comes with his own backstory, interests and quirks, giving players plenty of reasons to choose favorites. The writing leans heavily on stereotypes about gender and personality type, which can feel dated today. Some characters are clearly designed to be unlikable, and the game does not pretend otherwise.
The Gameplay
Players move through text-based scenes by choosing dialogue options, reading through story developments and making choices that shape the relationship with their current partner. There is very little mechanical variation beyond that. The pacing can drag during sections where nothing much happens, and the game relies heavily on its writing to carry the player through those moments. Dialogue options that feel like filler rather than meaningful choices can frustrate players looking for a deeper experience.
The Humor
The humor in Hatoful Boyfriend is the game’s strongest asset. Jokes about pigeons being pigeons land well, and the game’s willingness to poke fun at its own premise keeps things light even when the story turns serious. That said, the game also includes moments that are genuinely mean-spirited, especially toward female characters, which can undercut the lighter tone.
The Problem Areas
The game’s treatment of female characters is problematic. Female characters are frequently sidelined, objectified or used as plot devices rather than full people. This is not a flaw that gets fixed over time; it is present from the start and shapes nearly every scene involving a woman. Players who care about representation will find little comfort here.
The pacing drags in places, particularly during stretches of exposition that add little to the story. Some dialogue options feel like filler rather than meaningful choices, which can frustrate players looking for a deeper experience. The game also leans heavily on its visual style, which is simple and cartoonish, and some players may find that limiting compared to more polished productions.
How It Compares
| Feature | Hatoful Boyfriend | The Game That Followed |
|---|---|---|
| Setting | Bird-only high school | Expanded bird world |
| Cast | Male pigeon characters | Larger cast, mixed species |
| Gameplay | Text-based choices | More varied systems |
| Tone | Light, occasionally mean | Lighter, more inclusive |
The game that followed in its wake expanded the world far beyond the high school setting, adding more characters, more locations and more systems for players to engage with. By contrast, Hatoful Boyfriend feels smaller, more limited and less ambitious in scope.
Final Word
Hatoful Boyfriend is a strange, often uncomfortable game that manages to be entertaining anyway. Its humor lands, its premise is genuinely clever and its cast of characters is memorable. But the game’s treatment of women and its occasional cruelty toward certain characters make it hard to fully recommend without reservation. For players willing to look past those flaws, there is a solid visual novel buried underneath the controversy.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
