Sinister wants to scare you. It mostly succeeds. The 2012 horror film follows Ellison Oswalt, a true-crime writer who finds a box of disturbing home videos while renovating a house. He watches the footage and discovers a pattern of ritualistic murders across decades. The tapes become a trap, and the movie leans on dread over jump scares.
“Sinister” is a slow-burn thriller that earns its scares through atmosphere.
Trailer, via Blumhouse.
The Premise
Ellison, played by Ethan Hawke, thinks he has found a fresh angle on his crime books. What he finds instead is a collection of homemade films documenting killings. Each tape shows a family murdered in the same ritualistic way. As Ellison watches, the crimes start to look less like isolated events and more like a connected terror.
The Setup
The film builds slowly. It spends its early runtime establishing Ellison’s character, his wife Tracy, and his young sons. The setup is deliberate, giving the audience time to care about the family before the threat fully materializes. The pacing is methodical, which works in the first half but strains the patience later.
The Tapes
The tapes themselves are the core mystery. Each one shows a family being killed, often in front of their children. The ritualistic nature of the murders is consistent across all the footage. This consistency is a strength, giving the film a clear shape even as the tension grows.
The Villain
The antagonist is never named. He appears only as a shadowy presence in the tapes, a figure who orchestrates the killings. The film refuses to explain him directly, leaving the audience to fill in the gaps with fear. This approach is bold, though it also leaves the ending open-ended and frustrating.
The Payoff
The climax arrives after a long build-up. Ellison confronts the villain in a final confrontation that tries to resolve the mystery of the tapes. The resolution is abrupt, almost too quick after the extended setup. The film ends with a question rather than a definitive answer, which some viewers find satisfying and others find unsatisfying.
The Craft
The direction is steady. The cinematography keeps the house dark and claustrophobic, with shadows doing much of the work. The performances are solid, especially Hawke’s, who carries the weight of a man pushed past his limits. The score is minimal, letting the silence do the heavy lifting.
Comparing the Two Halves
| Element | First Half | Second Half |
|---|---|---|
| Pace | Deliberate | Strained |
| Tension | Rising | Peaking |
| Effect | Atmospheric | Overstretched |
The Verdict
Sinister is a competently made horror film that leans heavily on atmosphere over spectacle. It succeeds best when it is patient, letting dread accumulate slowly. The second half loses some of that control, rushing toward a conclusion that feels rushed. The tapes remain the film’s strongest element, carrying a consistent terror that the script cannot quite match.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
