Kathryn Bigelow’s Zero Dark Thirty opens on a black screen. Audio from September 11, 2001 plays over it — calls from inside the towers, dispatchers, a voice saying the second plane has hit. No images. Then the film cuts to a CIA black site in Pakistan in 2003, and holds there for the next two and a half hours.
Zero Dark Thirty is a 2012 political action thriller written by Mark Boal, produced by Boal, Bigelow and Megan Ellison, and financed independently through Ellison’s Annapurna Pictures. It dramatizes the near decade-long hunt for Osama bin Laden and ends with the May 2, 2011 raid in which he was killed. It runs 157 minutes. It is the best American film of its year, and the argument that surrounded it has not aged as well as the film has.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Entertainment.
Maya Watches a Man Break
Jessica Chastain plays Maya, a fictional CIA analyst. We meet her in 2003 at the U.S. embassy in Pakistan, watching as officer Dan Fuller, played by Jason Clarke, runs the interrogation of Ammar, a detainee suspected of links to several of the September 11 hijackers. Boal’s script does not flinch from the approved enhanced interrogation techniques. Ammar gives up unreliable information about a suspected attack in Saudi Arabia. He also gives up a name: Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti, bin Laden’s personal courier.
That name is the spine of the film. Everything after it is Maya pulling a thread.
Chastain plays the part with almost no release valve. Maya has no life outside the file. She has a colleague and friend in Jessica, played by Jennifer Ehle, and that is the closest thing to warmth in her story. The performance won Chastain the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Motion Picture, Drama, and it earned her an Academy Award nomination in the same category. It is a study in a person who has decided that one fact matters more than anything else, and the film never asks us to find her likable to find her credible.
A Name Nobody Wants to Believe
In 2005, Maya sits across from a detainee named Faraj, who denies knowing any courier called Abu Ahmed. Maya reads the denial as concealment. It is the first time the film shows her mind working in a way her colleagues cannot follow, and it will not be the last.
The middle stretch is a procedural. Analysts trade fragments. A Jordanian detainee claims to have buried Ahmed in 2001. Another colleague brings Maya information from Morocco, gathered after 9/11, suggesting Ahmed is likely a man named Ibrahim Sayeed. Maya decides the man reported dead was Ahmed’s brother, not Ahmed.
Dan, now a senior officer at CIA headquarters, gets the phone number of Sayeed’s mother from a Kuwaiti prince. The price is a Lamborghini Gallardo Bicolor. It is the one moment of dark comedy in the film, and Boal earns it by never winking at it.
Jessica Dies at a Base in Afghanistan
The film’s hardest turn comes in 2009. A Jordanian doctor highly placed in al-Qaeda offers to become a U.S. spy for $25 million. Jessica travels to a U.S. base in Afghanistan to meet him. He is a triple agent loyal to al-Qaeda, and he detonates a suicide vest, killing Jessica and several other CIA officers.
It is the scene the film is built around, and it is not a twist. It is a cost. Maya responds by redoubling her efforts to find Abu Ahmed and bin Laden, and Chastain plays the shift without a single speech about grief. The film does not stop for her. It just keeps moving through the next set of phone numbers.
Mark Strong, Kyle Chandler and a Deep Bench
Bigelow assembles a deep bench and uses it the way a good director uses a bench — briefly, precisely, without ceremony. Mark Strong is George. Kyle Chandler is Joseph Bradley. Edgar Ramírez is Larry from Ground Branch. James Gandolfini plays the C.I.A. Director. Chris Pratt is Justin and Callan Mulvey is Saber, both members of the Naval Special Warfare Development Group. Fares Fares is Hakim. Reda Kateb is Ammar.
None of them get a monologue. That is the point. Zero Dark Thirty is a film about an institution, and institutions are made of people who each hold one piece and hand it off.
A Raid Shot in the Dark
The final act depicts the U.S. military raid on bin Laden’s compound in Pakistan, where he was killed on May 2, 2011. Bigelow shoots it largely in the dark and largely without score. There is no triumph music. There is a body, and there is a person on the ground counting it, and then there is a long quiet shot of Maya alone on a plane.
The tagline for the film is “The greatest manhunt in history.” The film itself never says that. It says something narrower and more interesting: that the manhunt cost specific people specific things, and that the ending does not refund them.
Senators Called It Pro-Torture
Zero Dark Thirty was accused of being pro-torture by U.S. senators John McCain, Dianne Feinstein and Carl Levin. That charge is the loudest thing that has ever been said about this film, and it is the least useful. The accusation was a political criticism, not a legal proceeding, and it produced no charge against the filmmakers. It stands as an argument, and it remains an open one.
The film shows enhanced interrogation techniques producing a name. It also shows that name leading to years of dead ends, and it shows a detainee giving up unreliable information under those techniques. What the film actually depicts is a bureaucracy that could not tell the difference between a lead and a lie, and a single analyst who could. Whether the interrogation scenes constitute an endorsement is a question the film deliberately leaves open.
The criticism landed because the film refuses to editorialize. That refusal is the same quality that makes it good.
What the Craft Does
Boal’s screenplay was nominated for Best Original Screenplay at the 85th Academy Awards. The film also took nominations for Best Picture, Best Actress for Chastain, Best Film Editing and Best Sound Editing. It won Best Sound Editing, in a tie with Skyfall, which Sony also distributed.
The editing and sound work are not decoration. The film’s tension is built almost entirely in the cutting and the mix — the hum of a room, the pause before a phone number is read out, the way a scene ends a beat earlier than you expect. Bigelow and her team made a talk-heavy procedural feel like a thriller without ever cheating the material.
It grossed $132 million worldwide, appeared on 95 critics’ top ten lists of 2012, and drew Golden Globe nominations including Chastain’s win. Those numbers describe a film that landed. They do not describe why it lasts.
The Order of What Matters
Here is the ranking, as this paper sees it, of what Zero Dark Thirty actually accomplishes:
- Chastain’s Maya — a performance with no vanity and no exit, the film’s whole engine.
- The sound design and editing — the reason a decade of phone numbers plays as suspense.
- Boal’s structure — ten years compressed without a single wasted scene.
- The raid sequence — restrained, dark, and correctly uninterested in glory.
- The supporting cast — deep, brief, and never indulged.
The torture controversy sits outside that list. It was a fight about what the film was perceived to say, conducted largely by people who had not yet seen how little the film says on purpose.
Key Numbers
- Title: Zero Dark Thirty
- Year: 2012
- Director: Kathryn Bigelow
- Writer: Mark Boal
- Runtime: 157 minutes
- Genres: Thriller, Drama
- Tagline: “The greatest manhunt in history.”
- Worldwide gross: $132 million
- Academy Award nominations: 5 (Best Picture, Best Actress, Best Original Screenplay, Best Film Editing, Best Sound Editing)
- Academy Award wins: 1 (Best Sound Editing, tied with Skyfall)
- Golden Globe nominations: 4, including a win for Chastain
- Critics’ top ten lists of 2012: 95
- Metacritic: 95/100
- Score: 9.5/10
Zero Dark Thirty is a film about a woman who is right and cannot prove it, made by people who understood that the proving is the story. Bigelow and Boal do not ask the audience to admire Maya or the agency she works for. They ask the audience to sit in the room while the work gets done, and to notice what the work takes.
That is a harder film than the one its critics described. It is also a better one. The interrogation scenes are uncomfortable because they are meant to be, not because they are an argument. The raid is quiet because the film has already spent its noise. Maya’s last shot on that plane is the only ending the film could have earned.
Chastain, Boal and Bigelow made the definitive American procedural of its decade. Nothing since has matched its discipline.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
