ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

True Lies: James Cameron’s Spy Comedy Has a Hollow Middle

A deep dive into James Cameron's True Lies, the 1994 spy comedy with Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jamie Lee Curtis, and why its middle never holds.

By mitch·8 min read
An armored vehicle races through a city street as a helicopter fires upon it.

James Cameron’s True Lies puts Arnold Schwarzenegger in the middle of a marriage that is also a cover story. Harry Tasker tells his wife Helen and his daughter Dana that he sells computer hardware. He actually works for Omega Sector, a top-secret U.S. counterterrorism agency. The 1994 film runs 141 minutes, and for most of them Cameron keeps two machines running at once: a spy thriller about stolen nuclear warheads and a domestic comedy about a husband who has been lying since before the wedding.

The pitch is clean, and the tagline says it outright: “When he said I do, he never said what he did.” That is the whole engine. True Lies is at its best when the two halves collide, and at its weakest when it decides the spy half can carry the movie alone.

Trailer, via treskate2.

Advertisement

Harry Tasker, Computer Salesman

The opening is the lie in miniature. Harry infiltrates a party in Switzerland hosted by billionaire Jamal Khaled. He approaches Khaled’s art dealer, Juno Skinner, posing as a potential art entrepreneur. Juno is also a paid agent of Crimson Jihad, the terrorist organization led by Salim Abu Aziz. When Harry visits her later, Aziz’s men try to kill him. He fights them off and loses Aziz in a pursuit.

What he also loses is Dana’s birthday party, the one Helen and Dana planned for him. That is the film’s real subject arriving on schedule: the cost of the cover story, paid by the people who do not know they are paying it. Cameron stages the action well. He is a director who understands that a chase is a geography problem before it is a stunt, and the party sequence has a cold, expensive precision that the rest of the film never quite matches.

Then the movie changes shape, and this is where it gets interesting.

Simon the Used Car Salesman

Harry goes to Helen’s office to reconcile. Instead he overhears her arranging to meet someone called Simon. He assumes an affair. He uses Omega Sector resources to find out that Simon is a used car salesman who pretends to be a spy to seduce women. Bill Paxton plays Simon, and he is the funniest thing in the picture — a man performing espionage as a pickup technique, complete with the vocabulary and the sunglasses.

Harry and other Omega agents arrest Helen and Simon in disguise, then Harry terrifies Simon into staying away from Helen. He and Gib interrogate her while hiding their identities. What they learn is not infidelity but a midlife crisis. Helen is bored. She is desperate for adventure. She wants a life that has some weather in it.

So they build her one. Omega arranges a staged spy mission: Helen is to seduce a mysterious figure, who is actually Harry, and plant a bug in his hotel room. It is a cruel joke dressed as a gift, and Cameron plays it as comedy. The sequence works because Jamie Lee Curtis commits completely — to the nerves, the embarrassment, the sudden thrill of being good at something dangerous.

Aziz, Juno, and Four Warheads

The fake mission collapses. Aziz’s men burst in and capture Helen and Harry. The couple is taken to an island in the Florida Keys, where Helen learns the truth about her husband’s double life — and that he was misleading her even before they were married.

The supporting cast around this turn is doing solid, specific work. Art Malik plays Aziz straight, which is the right call. Tia Carrere’s Juno gets the film’s most thankless job, a villain who has to be glamorous and menacing in the same scene. Tom Arnold’s Gib is the comic relief who actually relieves. Eliza Dushku plays Dana, the daughter who exists mostly to be in danger. Charlton Heston shows up as Spencer Trilby, and the film treats him like a monument, which he is.

Here is the shape of the whole thing:

  • Harry Tasker, the agent who cannot tell his wife what he does
  • Helen Tasker, the wife drawn unknowingly into a staged mission
  • Gib and Faisil, the team that makes the lie operational
  • Juno Skinner, the art dealer working for Crimson Jihad
  • Aziz, the man who smuggles the warheads
  • Simon, the used car salesman pretending to be all of the above

That last bullet is the joke the movie is built on, and it is a good one. Every man in True Lies is performing a version of himself. Simon performs a spy. Harry performs a salesman. Aziz performs a cause. The only person not performing is Helen, which is why she is the one who gets hurt.

The First $100 Million Movie

The production history matters here, because it explains what you are watching. True Lies was the first Lightstorm Entertainment project distributed under Cameron’s multimillion-dollar deal with 20th Century Fox. It was the first major production for Digital Domain, the visual effects company Cameron co-founded. And it was the first film to cost $100 million.

You can feel that money on screen. The film was nominated at the Academy Awards and the BAFTAs in the Best Visual Effects category, and the technical ambition is not hard to spot. The screenplay is based on the 1991 French comedy La Totale!, and that lineage shows in the domestic material, which is where the film is most patient with the slow burn of a marriage going stale.

What the Box Office Said

True Lies received mostly positive reviews and grossed $378 million worldwide, making it the third-highest-grossing film of 1994. Curtis won the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Motion Picture Musical or Comedy, and the Saturn Award for Best Actress. Cameron won the Saturn Award for Best Director. The film was nominated for seven Saturn Awards overall.

That is a lot of hardware for a movie that is, at heart, a sitcom with a fighter jet in it. The awards tell you what the industry saw: a technical achievement with a movie star at the center and a director who could deliver both. They do not tell you whether the thing holds together, and it does not, entirely.

The order of what actually works goes like this:

  1. Jamie Lee Curtis, who finds a real person inside a premise that could have been a sketch
  2. The party infiltration, which is Cameron at his most controlled
  3. Bill Paxton’s Simon, a small part that steals more than it should
  4. The Florida Keys finale, which is loud and long
  5. The nuclear warhead plot, which never generates the fear it needs to

The warheads are the problem. Crimson Jihad smuggles four multiple independently targetable reentry vehicle nuclear warheads into the United States, and the film treats this as a scheduling inconvenience rather than a catastrophe. The stakes are announced but never felt. Aziz is a villain with a plan and no interior life, and the movie does not seem to notice the gap.

The 2004 Ruling in Paris

There is one more fact that sits oddly beside the film’s legacy. In 2004, the Court of Appeal of Paris ruled that True Lies and La Totale! were plagiarized from an unproduced 1981 screenplay called Émilie, by Lucien Lambert. A film that spent its whole runtime insisting on the difference between the real thing and the performance of it was, a decade later, found to have borrowed its foundation from someone else’s unproduced work.

That is not a reason to dismiss True Lies. Plenty of good films have messy origins. But it is a reason to be careful about how much credit the movie’s cleverness deserves. The central idea — a spy whose marriage is the hardest operation he runs — is a strong one, and Cameron executes it with real craft. The question is whether the craft is doing the work or covering for a script that does not sustain its best idea to the end.

Once Helen knows the truth, the film has no more tension to generate from its central premise, so it settles into the capture and the escape. The final act is competent. It is also the stretch where the movie stops being about anything.

A streaming television series adaptation premiered in 2023, which tells you the premise still has pull. It does. A marriage built on a lie is inexhaustible material. True Lies just does not exhaust it.

What Holds Up

What holds up is Curtis. She is the reason to watch this now, and she was the reason to watch it then. Her Helen starts as a woman written off by her own husband and ends as someone who has seen through him. The film does not quite know what to do with her once she knows, and that is its central failure.

Schwarzenegger is fine, and he is doing exactly what the movie needs him to do, which is be a wall that things bounce off. But the film’s heart is in the domestic scenes, and its money is in the action scenes, and Cameron never fully reconciles the two.

The 2004 Paris ruling is the detail worth remembering, not because it diminishes the film but because it rhymes with it. True Lies is a movie about a man who cannot be honest with the person closest to him, made by people who, a court later found, were not entirely honest about where the story came from. That is either a coincidence or the most on-the-nose thing about it.

True Lies is a good time with a hollow middle. The first half is sharp, the second half is expensive, and the whole thing is carried by a performance the script does not deserve. It was the third-highest-grossing film of 1994 and it won Curtis a Golden Globe, and both of those facts are real. What it does not have is a third act that earns the premise. Watch it for Curtis. Stay for the collapse of the fake mission. Do not expect the warheads to mean anything.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.