Sonic Colors arrived on the Wii in November 2010 with a job to do. Sega had spent the years before it delisting Sonic games with sub-average Metacritic scores, a house-cleaning meant to raise the value of a brand that had taken a beating. Sonic Team’s answer was a platformer set in outer space, built around an alien race called the Wisps, and made for a wider demographic than the series usually chased. It mostly works.
Trailer, via IGN.
Doctor Eggman’s Incredible Interstellar Amusement Park
The setup is the best joke the series has told in years. Eggman opens an amusement park in space, claims he has turned over a new leaf, and invites the world to enjoy it. The park is made of planet-sized attractions, five small planets chained to each other, each split into seven parts: six acts and a boss level. Sonic and Tails investigate, meet an alien named Yacker, and learn the truth: Eggman has enslaved the Wisps and plans to use their energy for a mind-control laser aimed at Earth.
That premise does real work. It gives Sonic a reason to run through a theme park instead of another grim fortress, and it lets the level design breathe. The hub is a menu of planets, and as you clear them more open up. Finish them all and a bonus seventh planet unlocks to close the story. It is a clean structure, and it keeps the game moving.
Wisps and the Boost
The Wisps are the headline addition, and they earn the billing. They are power-ups that raise attack power and open routes Sonic cannot reach otherwise, and they exist for a practical reason: the developers wanted to diversify the gameplay without slowing it down. That is the right instinct. A Sonic game lives or dies on momentum, and bolting new toys onto a character who is supposed to be sprinting is how these games usually go wrong.
Sonic keeps most of what he had in Sonic Unleashed. The Sonic Boost raises his speed and lets him smash through objects. A homing attack destroys enemies from a distance. A stomp takes out whatever is below him. A double-jump rounds it out. Some levels fire him forward at high speed and demand a quick step to dodge walls; others hand him a drift mechanic for sharp turns. The camera shifts between third-person and side-scrolling, often mid-level, and the seam is smoother than it has any right to be.
Two Versions, One Grade
Development began in 2008, after Sonic Unleashed wrapped. The team read the criticisms of past games and made two decisions that shape everything here. First, Sonic is the only playable character. No friends tagging along, no alternate campaigns to dilute the run. Second, they worked to balance speed against platforming rather than letting one eat the other. Both choices show.
The game was designed for a wider demographic than previous games, specifically children and fans of the Super Mario series.
Sega shipped two versions at once. Sonic Team built the Wii game; Dimps built a Nintendo DS version with different gameplay. The Wii version’s ending is simple: Eggman tries to fire his cannon at the world, wreckage from an earlier boss fight jams it, and the park starts to explode. Sonic confronts him, Eggman powers a final robot with the Nega-Wisps, and the machine turns the powers of every Wisp Sonic has met against him. As it weakens, the Wisps break free and help Sonic finish the fight. The Wisps carry Sonic out. Back on Earth, Yacker says thanks.
What Holds It Back
The flaws are real and they are not small. Difficulty is uneven in a way that reads as unconsidered rather than deliberate, and some critics knocked the multiplayer mode as thin. The grade system, which rates each level from S to D based on performance, feels to this paper like it rewards replay more than a first pass — a strange thing to build into a game pitched at younger players.
Then there is the pitch itself. Sega designed Sonic Colors for children and for fans of the Super Mario series, and you can feel that target in the level layouts. That is not a knock. It is the reason the game is coherent. But it also means the ceiling is lower than the premise suggests. A mind-control laser, an enslaved alien race, a theme park built on their captivity — that is dark material, and Sonic Colors never quite commits to it. The stakes stay bright and bouncy, and the story resolves without much weight.
What matters here is that Sega’s brand strategy and Sonic Team’s design instincts pointed the same direction. The delistings were a cleanup. Sonic Colors was the argument that the cleanup was worth it. It made Sonic the only playable character, balanced speed against platforming, and introduced Wisps that solved a design problem instead of papering over one.
Critics mostly agreed. Reviews were generally positive, with praise for the graphics, audio, soundtrack, gameplay and replay value, and many calling it a return to form. IGDB’s critic aggregate, drawn from five outlets, puts it at 7.5 of 10. That is a fair number for a game that is confident and well-built but wobbles on difficulty and ships a disposable multiplayer mode.
7.5 of 10 (IGDB critic aggregate, 5 outlets).
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
