The Grudge is a horror film that refuses to build. It opens with a cursed house in Tokyo, a dead wife, a dead child, and a dead cat, and then it sits there, letting the pieces of the story pile on top of each other instead of move forward. Sarah Michelle Gellar stars as Karen Davis, a nurse who moves through the house as the curse claims one victim after another. The film is a remake of the Japanese horror film Ju-On, directed by Takashi Shimizu, and it is the first installment in the Grudge series.
Trailer, via TrailerHome.
The Curse and the Saeki Family
The curse in The Grudge is simple to state and hard to follow. When someone dies in rage or sorrow, the spirit remains where the body falls, and anyone who touches it dies, passing the curse to another. The film’s central family, the Saeki, are the source: Kayako Saeki, played by Takako Fuji, dies at the hands of her husband Takeo after he finds her diary, written about her lover Peter Kirk. She comes back as a restless spirit, and her son Toshio, played by Yuya Ozeki, follows her.
Karen Davis and the Williams Family
Karen Davis works at the house as a care worker after Yoko disappears, and she finds Toshio sealed in a wardrobe. She witnesses Kayako’s spirit falling down the stairs, and she becomes the next link in the chain. The Williams family, Matt and Jennifer, move into the house in 2004, and the curse quickly takes them. Jennifer feels lost in Japan, unable to speak the language, while Emma, Matt’s dementia-ridden mother, senses that something is wrong with the house.
A Nonlinear Structure That Doesn’t Hold
The Grudge is told through a nonlinear sequence of events, and that structure is the film’s biggest problem. The story jumps between the Saeki deaths in 2001 and the Williams deaths in 2004, and the transitions never fully connect. The film does not let the audience settle into a single timeline before it cuts to another, and the result is confusion rather than dread.
Horror That Feels Heavy
The horror in The Grudge is more about dread than jump scares, and that is the film’s strength. Takeo, the husband who murders Kayako, and his scenes are the most effective. The film holds on Kayako’s face, her hair, and her rage, and those moments carry more weight than the random deaths that follow them. The curse is a slow, heavy thing, and the film knows that.
When It Works
The film’s best scenes are the quiet ones. Karen Davis finding Toshio in the wardrobe, Emma sensing the wrongness of the house, and the scenes between Kayako, Takeo, and Peter all land because they are patient. The film knows what it is good at, and those moments show it. When it abandons that patience, the film loses its footing.
A Mixed Reception That Holds Up
The Grudge was released in North America on October 22, 2004, by Sony Pictures through its Columbia Pictures label. It grossed $187.3 million worldwide and received mixed reviews from critics.
The Williams Family Timeline
| Character | Role | Fate |
|---|---|---|
| Matt Williams | Moves into the Saeki house for his job | Dies |
| Jennifer Williams | Matt’s wife, feels lost in Japan | Dies |
| Emma Williams | Matt’s dementia-ridden mother | Dies |
| Susan Williams | Matt’s sister | Haunted by the curse |
Key Facts
- Director: Takashi Shimizu
- Screenplay: Stephen Susco
- Starring: Sarah Michelle Gellar, Jason Behr, Takako Fuji, Yuya Ozeki
- Runtime: 92 minutes
- Released: October 22, 2004
- Gross: $187.3 million worldwide
The Grudge is a film that knows its own rules and then breaks them. It is a remake of a film it directed, and it treats that source with more respect than it treats its own structure. The curse is a powerful idea, and the performances are often strong. But the film’s refusal to let the audience rest in a single moment of dread, to stay with a scene and let it breathe, is a flaw that the scares cannot overcome.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
