Midterms 2026See who we think should earn your vote, based on our standardsThe guide →
WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

‘Reservation Dogs’ Review: Taika Waititi and Sterlin Harjo’s Landmark Show Earns Its 8.9

A review of Reservation Dogs, the FX series about four teens in rural Oklahoma seeking escape to California, with score 8.9/10.

By mitch·6 min read
Four teenagers sit together on a stoop in a Native American town, gazing westward toward distant mountains.

Four teenagers in rural Oklahoma want to get to California. That simple goal drives Reservation Dogs, the FX series created by Sterlin Harjo and Taika Waititi, and it turns out to be bigger than anyone expected. The show premiered on Hulu in 2021, and it has spent three seasons building a world that feels both specific to one small town and universal in its grief and longing. It is funny, sad, and often both at once. It is also, in the words of the American Film Institute, one of the ten best television programs of its year for three years running.

Trailer, via FX Networks.

The Four Rez Dogs

The core group is the Rez Dogs, four teenagers whose lives are defined by their friendship and their shared desire to leave. Elora Danan Postoak, played by Devery Jacobs, is the quiet one, carrying the weight of her family’s expectations. Bear Smallhill, played by D’Pharaoh Woon-A-Tai, is the jokester, but his jokes hide a deeper sadness. Cheese, played by Lane Factor, is the outsider, a white adoptee who finds himself caught between two worlds. Willie Jack, played by Paulina Alexis, is the wild card, full of energy and anger. Together they commit crimes, fight, and plan their escape.

Advertisement

Their friend Daniel, who dreamed of moving to California, died one year before the show begins. His absence hangs over every episode, and the Rez Dogs spend their days trying to honor him while also running from him. They talk about making the trip to California, but the trip itself becomes less important than the reasons they wanted to go. The show understands that the destination is not the point; the journey is everything.

A Town Built on Loss

The series takes place in a small town in the Muscogee Nation, a place where the characters spend their days “committing crime and fighting it.” That description captures the show’s tone perfectly: it is messy, chaotic, and honest. The adults are mostly absent, which leaves the teenagers to fend for themselves. This is not a fantasy of youth; it is a portrait of young people who have to grow up fast.

In Season 2, the Rez Dogs are still grieving Daniel’s death, and they have lost some of their connection to each other. The “California dream” does not turn out as they expected, and they feel disappointment and abandonment instead. They cope through humor, but they also face adult challenges. Financial problems and family responsibilities arise as they try to figure out their lives. The show does not let them off easy, and that is part of what makes it compelling.

A First of Its Kind

Reservation Dogs is the first American series to feature all-Native American writers and directors, along with an almost entirely Indigenous North American cast and crew. That is a historic achievement, and the show honors it by being grounded in the actual experience of its creators. The initial season was filmed entirely in Oklahoma, which is another first for a scripted series. The premiere date was August 9, 2021, International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples.

The show’s commitment to authenticity is evident in every scene. The dialogue sounds like real people talking, not like characters in a script. The jokes land because they come from a specific cultural perspective. The show does not explain itself to non-Native viewers; it trusts them to sit with the unfamiliar. That trust is rare in television, and it pays off.

The Critical Response

The show received widespread critical acclaim. It won two Peabody Awards and two Independent Spirit Awards. It was nominated for five Primetime Emmy Awards, including Outstanding Comedy Series and Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series for D’Pharaoh Woon-A-Tai. It also earned a Golden Globe nomination, six Television Critics Association Awards, and nine Critics’ Choice Television Awards. The American Film Institute consecutively listed it as one of the ten best television programs in 2021, 2022, and 2023.

Those numbers are impressive, but they do not capture what the show actually does. Reservation Dogs is not a prestige drama. It is a comedy-drama that treats its characters with warmth and honesty. It is a show about grief, friendship, and the difficulty of growing up. It is also a show about the specific experience of being Indigenous in America, and it handles that subject with a light touch and a heavy heart.

Grief and Humor

The show balances its serious themes with genuine laughs. The jokes come from the absurdity of the situation: teenagers planning a cross-country trip with limited resources, a dead friend they can’t stop thinking about, and a community that expects them to stay. The humor is not a shield; it is a way of coping. The characters laugh to keep from crying, and the show lets us see both sides of that laughter.

The show also shows the cost of that coping mechanism. In Season 3, the Rez Dogs explore the history of the elders in the community and how the events and choices of their youth led to their present-day lives. Parallels are drawn between the Rez Dogs and the younger selves of the aunts, uncles, and grandparents. This is where the show reaches its emotional peak, connecting the teenagers’ struggles to the generational trauma that shaped their families.

What Makes It Work

The show’s strength comes from its refusal to simplify its characters. Elora is not just the quiet one. Bear is not just the jokester. Cheese is not just the outsider. Willie Jack is not just the angry one. Each character has layers, and the show takes the time to reveal them. The performances are uniformly excellent, with Woon-A-Tai in particular delivering a breakout turn that earned him Emmy recognition.

The show also benefits from its creators’ vision. Harjo and Waititi bring different perspectives to the project, and the result is a show that feels both personal and universal. It is a Native American story told by Native Americans, and that matters. The show’s success is proof that audiences want stories they have not seen before, and that those stories can find a wide audience.

Aspect Reservation Dogs
Creator Sterlin Harjo and Taika Waititi
Network Hulu/FX on Hulu
Premiere Date August 9, 2021
Seasons 3, 28 episodes
Critical Standing Two Peabody Awards, two Independent Spirit Awards
Emmy Nominations Five, including Outstanding Comedy Series and Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series

The Verdict

Reservation Dogs is a landmark series. It broke ground for Indigenous representation in television, and it did so with a show that is funny, sad, and deeply human. The show is not perfect; no show is. But it succeeds where many shows fail by staying true to its characters and its world. It does not romanticize poverty or tragedy. It simply shows people doing the best they can with what they have.

The show’s final season drew the clearest lines between the generations, showing how the choices of the past shape the present. It is a bold move for a show that could have ended on a lighter note. Instead, it chose to look at the roots of its characters’ pain, and that decision made the ending feel earned.

The show is available to stream on Hulu, and it is worth watching for anyone who wants to see a fresh voice in television. It is a show that respects its audience, its characters, and its own story. It is a show that earns its place among the best of its year, and it deserves to be remembered as one of the most important series of its decade.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

TV reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.