ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

The Halo TV Series Built Its Own Canon and Lost the One That Mattered

Halo on Paramount+ ran 17 episodes across two seasons, a Silver Timeline spin on the games. Cast shines, writing sags. Our score: 6.1 of 10.

By mitch·4 min read
An armored soldier stands amid ruins as a storm rages overhead, evoking the show's dark, isolated tone.

Halo arrived on Paramount+ on March 24, 2022, based on a video game franchise created by Bungie and developed by 343 Industries. The show was developed by Kyle Killen and Steven Kane, who served as showrunners for the first season. It follows the 26th-century war between the United Nations Space Command and the Covenant, a theocratic-military alliance of several alien races set on eradicating humanity.

Pablo Schreiber plays Master Chief Petty Officer John-117, the super-soldier at the center of the story. He is joined by Natascha McElhone as Dr. Catherine Halsey, Yerin Ha as Kwan Ha, and Jen Taylor as Cortana. Taylor reprises her voice role from the games.

Trailer, via Paramount Plus.

Advertisement

The Silver Timeline

Executive producer Kiki Wolfkill said the series is a standalone story inside its own “Silver Timeline,” separate from the core canon. The goal was to let the two Halo canons evolve individually to suit their media.

That is a reasonable idea. It is also the source of the show’s biggest problem. The series does not adapt the games. It does not continue them, precede them, or follow them. It borrows the furniture and rearranges the room.

The first season consists of nine episodes. It premiered on March 24, 2022, and ran until May 19. A second season premiered on February 8, 2024, and the last episode aired on March 21, 2024, with 17 episodes across two seasons.

What the Cast Does With the Material

Schreiber plays John-117 as a man waking up to the fact that he has been owned his whole life. The show’s best scenes are the quiet ones where he questions Halsey. McElhone gives Halsey a cold, procedural calm that makes her the most watchable person on screen.

Shabana Azmi plays Margaret Parangosky. Joseph Morgan joins the second season as James Ackerson. Natasha Culzac, Bentley Kalu, and Kate Kennedy fill out the Spartan ranks as Riz-028, Vannak-134, and Kai-125. Charlie Murphy plays Makee, the human raised by the Covenant.

The cast is not the issue. The writing is. The pacing sags whenever the plot leaves the Spartan storyline.

Season by Season

Season Episodes Premiere Finale
Season 1 9 March 24, 2022 May 19, 2022
Season 2 8 February 8, 2024 March 21, 2024

Development on a Halo television series started in mid-2013. Filming began in Ontario, Canada, in October 2019. Post-production on the first five episodes was disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic, and production eventually resumed in Budapest, Hungary, in February 2021. The show was renewed for a second season in February 2022, before the first episode had aired.

David Wiener took over as head and executive producer for season two. Filming for that season began in September 2022 and wrapped in May 2023. That production history explains a lot about the show’s uneven feel. It was built, stalled, rebuilt, and handed to a new captain.

How Halo Compares to Its Own Source

Element Video game series Halo (TV series)
Canon Core lore, ongoing Separate “Silver Timeline”
Master Chief Player-controlled Played by Pablo Schreiber
Cortana Voiced by Jen Taylor Voiced by Jen Taylor
Story relationship Source material Standalone, not an adaptation

The one constant is Taylor. Everything else is a negotiation. The games let you be the Master Chief. The show asks you to watch him, and that is a harder sell than it sounds.

Where the Show Actually Works

The first season drew mostly positive reviews. Critics praised the action scenes, the cast, and the visual effects. They criticized the writing as derivative and took issue with the show’s alterations from the source material. The source does not list which alterations drew that criticism.

The Covenant look like a genuine threat, and the visual effects hold up. When Halo commits to being a war story, it is a good one. The problem is that it rarely commits. The show wants to be a character drama about institutional control, and it has the cast to pull that off. But it keeps interrupting itself with subplots that go nowhere.

The Score

Halo is a show caught between two audiences. It wants credit for the games without the burden of them, and it wants to stand alone while wearing someone else’s armor. The Silver Timeline was meant to free the writers from canon. Instead it left them with a story that has no obligation to anything, including itself.

The cast deserved better. Schreiber and McElhone built a tense relationship at the center of the show, and Taylor’s return as Cortana is the one thread that ties the whole project back to what made the franchise matter.

But a show is not a cast. Across 17 episodes, Halo never decides what it is about. It is not a bad adaptation, because it never really adapts. It is not a good standalone story, because it keeps borrowing weight it did not earn. It sits in the middle, expensive and unresolved.

The published critical score is 6.1 out of 10, with a Metacritic score of 61 out of 100. That is a fair summary of a show that never picked a lane.

Worth watching for the performances and the action. Worth skipping if you wanted the games. 6.1 of 10.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.