Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates wants to be a wild, funny road trip comedy about two brothers who hire strangers for their sister’s wedding. It mostly gets there, but it spends too much time explaining why the plan went wrong before letting the chaos unfold.
The film follows Mike and Dave Stangle, played by Adam Devine and Zac Efron, who put an ad on Craigslist for dates to their sister Jeanie’s wedding in Hawaii. The sisters pick Tatiana and Alice, played by Aubrey Plaza and Anna Kendrick, thinking they are two normal women. Once on the island, the girls reveal they are both wild, free-spirited and ready to party.
Trailer, via 20th Century Studios.
The Premise Works Better Than the Execution
The setup is simple and effective. Two irresponsible brothers need respectability for a family event. They find it in two women who pretend to be normal but are secretly desperate for a vacation. The tension between what the brothers want and what the girls deliver is the engine of the movie.
Devine and Efron play the brothers as fraternal opposites: one wild, one awkward. Plaza and Kendrick play the dates as women who are tired of being told what they should want. The dynamic between the four leads carries the first half of the film.
The Middle Stretch Drags
The film slows down in the middle to explain how the brothers met the girls. We see Tatiana and Alice get fired from their waitressing jobs, watch them clean themselves up after seeing the brothers on The Wendy Williams Show, and follow the sequence where Tatiana fakes getting hit by a car to get Mike’s attention. These scenes are necessary, but they slow the momentum that the premise built.
The film also spends too much time on secondary characters like Eric, Jeanie’s fiancé, and Kalani, the BBQ chef. Their scenes add color but don’t move the central story forward.
The Final Stretch Gets Wild
The back half picks up when the girls convince Jeanie and Eric to take an ATV tour. Alice and Tatiana perform tricks on their ATVs, and Mike tries to keep up. That attempt ends badly: he crashes into Jeanie, knocking her out and bruising the right side of her face.
Alice then bribes a masseur to give Jeanie a massage with a tantric-style “happy ending.” The scene is meant to be outrageous, but it feels more like a stunt than a joke.
“They needed hot dates. They got hot messes.”
What Works
- The chemistry between Devine and Efron, especially in scenes where they play off each other’s energy.
- Plaza and Kendrick’s performances as women who are far more interesting than anyone expected.
- The ATV crash, which delivers the film’s biggest laugh.
- The wedding itself, where the brothers finally have to face their family with their choices.
What doesn’t work:
- The middle section, where the film explains too much and loses its pace.
- The supporting characters, who crowd the frame without adding much to the story.
- The final act’s attempt at shock value, which feels forced rather than earned.
Verdict
Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates is a film that knows its premise better than its execution. The jokes land when the story stays focused on the four leads. When it wanders into filler, it drags. The film’s best moments come from letting the characters breathe, not from explaining why things went wrong.
The movie is a comedy about irresponsibility that spends too much time explaining its own irresponsibility. It’s funnier in concept than in practice.
5.1 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
