Miley Stewart is a girl who has everything. Pop star, world fame, millions of fans, and a private jet that can fly her anywhere. What she doesn’t have is a normal life. That’s the premise of “Hannah Montana: The Movie,” and it’s a premise that sounds simple but runs into trouble as soon as the film tries to follow through on it.
The movie opens with Miley performing as Hannah Montana at a concert, racing through the back door just in time to hit the stage. It’s a quick shot of what she’s lost: the ability to move through life without being noticed. Then the film cuts to a music video shoot for “The Best of Both Worlds,” where Miley-as-Hannah is confronted by Oswald Granger, a tabloid reporter who won’t let the secret go. The conflict is set up cleanly: Miley wants both lives, but the world keeps pushing her toward one.
Trailer, via DiscoverMiley.
The Tabloid Reporter’s Chase
Oswald is the engine of the first act. He records Miley alluding to Hannah’s “secret” during a shopping trip gone wrong, then follows her to Lilly’s Sweet Sixteen party at the pier. Miley has to show up as Hannah to keep him from finding out the truth, and the moment she steps onto the dance floor, the whole room turns to watch her. It’s a sharp contrast: in Hollywood, she’s a spectacle. In Crowley Corners, she’s a stranger.
The problem is that the film doesn’t know what to do with this setup once it has it. The chase loses steam fast, and Oswald’s determination becomes less a threat than a running gag about a man who can’t accept a simple “no.” By the time Robby Stewart decides enough is enough and books a private jet to send Miley to Crowley Corners, the stakes have collapsed. It’s a vacation, not a crisis.
Robby’s Plan
Robby Stewart is the one character who understands what’s happening to Miley. He sees her losing touch with her family and her friends, and he reacts by flying her to Tennessee for two weeks with her grandmother Ruby. The plan is to get her some perspective on what matters most in life. The execution is a series of scenes where Miley puts on blue jeans, feeds chickens, and watches old home movies with her grandmother.
These scenes are the film’s clearest moments. Margo Martindale plays Ruby with warmth, and the scenes between Miley and her grandmother feel genuine. But the film can’t sustain the pace. The middle stretch drags, with Miley spending too much time thinking aloud about what she’s given up and not enough time doing something about it.
Lilly’s Sweet Sixteen
Lilly Truscott is Miley’s best friend, and the film leans on her to carry the emotional weight of the story. Lilly’s Sweet Sixteen party is the moment where Miley’s double life becomes impossible to hide. She shows up as Hannah, and the whole room turns to watch her perform “Let’s Get Crazy.” Lilly watches, dejected, while Miley is the center of attention. The scene is meant to be a turning point, but it lands as a shrug rather than a blow.
Later, Lilly is stopped and questioned by Oswald, and she tells him that Hannah is from Crowley Corners, Tennessee. It’s a betrayal, but the film handles it lightly. Lilly’s anger is real, but the film doesn’t let it settle. It moves on to the next beat, leaving the damage unexplored.
Ruby’s Birthday Party
Ruby’s birthday is the reason Miley is in Crowley Corners in the first place. But the film spends more time on Miley’s remorse than on the celebration itself. She looks at a picture of her late mother and wishes she were still alive. It’s a sad moment, but it’s also a thin one. The film has set up a grandmother who wants Miley to spend time with her family, and then it mostly lets Miley wander around feeling sorry for herself.
There are moments of connection. Miley reconnects with small-town life, her grandmother, and her childhood friend Travi. But the film doesn’t trust those connections to carry the story. It keeps returning to the same idea: Miley is torn between two lives, and she has to choose. The problem is that the film never fully commits to either choice.
The Songs
The film leans heavily on songs from the Hannah Montana TV series, including “The Best of Both Worlds” and “Let’s Get Crazy.” These are familiar tracks, and they work in context. The problem is that the film doesn’t use the music to build tension or emotion. It uses the music to mark a beat, then moves on. The songs are background, not foreground.
The film also features a confrontation with Tyra Banks over a pair of shoes. It’s a silly moment, and it’s meant to show Miley’s celebrity lifestyle getting in the way of her personal life. But the moment is so small that it barely registers. It’s a detail, not a scene.
The Final Choice
The film’s final stretch is where it should resolve the central conflict. Instead, it settles for a compromise that feels like a cop-out. Miley isn’t forced to choose between Miley Stewart and Hannah Montana. She’s allowed to be both, but only if she learns to balance them. The film ends with Miley looking happier, but the conflict that drove the story hasn’t actually been resolved.
The tagline sums up the problem: “She has the best of both worlds… Now, she has to choose just one.” The film never delivers on that promise. It just lets Miley have both, and the choice is made for her.
A Film That Misses Its Mark
“Hannah Montana: The Movie” is a film that starts with a strong idea and fails to follow through on it. The premise is simple: a girl who has everything loses sight of what matters. The execution is messy. The chase loses steam, the middle drags, and the resolution is a shrug.
The film is at its best when it focuses on Miley and Ruby, and at its worst when it’s trying to be a comedy about a tabloid reporter. The cast does what it can with what they’re given, but the script doesn’t give them much to work with. Miley Cyrus is fine in the lead role, and Billy Ray Cyrus is solid as her father, but the film doesn’t ask either of them to do anything difficult.
The supporting cast is full of familiar faces from the TV series: Emily Osment, Jason Earles, Mitchel Musso, and Moisés Arias. They’re all competent, but the film doesn’t give them much to do either. The new additions — Lucas Till, Vanessa Williams, Margo Martindale, and Melora Hardin — are the strongest elements, but even they don’t get the screen time they deserve.
The film was released on April 10, 2009, in the United States. It was the second theatrical film based on a Disney Channel Original Series after “The Lizzie McGuire Movie” (2003), and it followed the concert film “Hannah Montana & Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds Concert.” It was also the only theatrical film produced by It’s a Laugh Productions and Millar/Gough Ink. Filming began in April 2008 in Columbia, Tennessee, and Los Angeles, California, and was completed in July 2008.
Despite mixed reviews, the film was a commercial success, grossing $169.2 million worldwide against a $30 million production budget. That success is hard to argue with, but it doesn’t make the film better. A film can be successful and still be bad.
The Numbers
- Runtime: 102 minutes
- Production budget: $30 million
- Worldwide gross: $169.2 million
- Release date: April 10, 2009 (United States)
The film’s schedule ran from April 2008 to July 2008, with filming split between Columbia, Tennessee, and Los Angeles, California.
| Stage | Location |
|---|---|
| Filming began | April 2008 |
| Filming completed | July 2008 |
| Release date | April 10, 2009 |
“Hannah Montana: The Movie” is a film that knows what it’s about but can’t quite say it. It has a strong premise, a decent cast, and a few good scenes. But the middle sags, the stakes collapse, and the resolution is a shrug. It’s a film that feels like it was made to sell toys and DVDs, not to tell a story.
The film earns a 4.7 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
