Manchester City have been found guilty of the majority of financial rule breaches in their case, according to an independent panel’s verdict. The club faces a likely points deduction, though an appeal could still change the outcome.
The panel reached a decision on the 115 charges against City, which took two years and 10 days to resolve. That is 1,329 days after the club was first charged. Club executives received the verdict during the week, having signed a non-disclosure agreement to open the file.
City did not confirm whether they were found guilty in a statement. Instead, the club said the “process remains ongoing” and an appeal is expected.
What City was accused of
The allegations cover seven separate charges on PSR breaches in the Premier League alone, plus five related to Uefa competitions. Those charges include inflated sponsorship revenue channelled through companies’ accounts, payments to players and managers, and failure to comply with investigations.
The independent panel found City guilty of the majority of those breaches. The exact count of guilty findings has not been made public.
The precedent set by other clubs
Everton were docked six points for PSR breaches. Their deduction was reduced to 10 on appeal, then further reduced to two points on appeal. Nottingham Forest were deducted four points.
Chelsea took a different path. They admitted guilt and negotiated a sanctioning agreement with the league.
What happens next
A points deduction now appears inevitable, though it depends on the appeal. Enzo Maresca’s side play Liverpool on 11 October, potentially going six points clear at the top of the table.
Clubs are seeking legal advice over potential compensation claims against City.
The timeline so far
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1,329 days ago | City charged |
| Two years and 10 days since | Hearing began |
| During the week | Verdict delivered to executives |
| Ongoing | Appeal process expected |
The stakes for the table
A large points deduction is possible. The appeal process will determine whether the punishment stands.
Liverpool will have to win their fixture against City to stay competitive. The game on 11 October will be watched closely.
The road ahead
The appeal process will determine whether the deductions stand. Until then, City remain in the dark about their exact punishment.
The Premier League has not commented publicly on the verdict. The league’s silence adds to the uncertainty surrounding the case.
City’s statement that the process “remains ongoing” suggests they are still working through the details of the decision. The club’s denial of guilt in the statement raises questions about whether they accept the verdict at all.
What this means for the league
Chelsea’s route — admitting guilt and negotiating a sanction — was a clean resolution for the league.
City’s case is different. The club denied the verdict publicly, which puts the league in a difficult position. A negotiated settlement with City would require the league to engage directly with the club.
Whether the Premier League responds to the verdict at all remains to be seen.
The case has been hanging over the league for a long time. The appeal process will provide some clarity, but until then, clubs, fans and the league itself are left waiting.
Source material: “Why Premier League faces uncertainty and chaos after Man City ruling,” the BBC.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.