“The Plot Against America” is HBO’s adaptation of Philip Roth’s 2004 novel about Charles Lindbergh winning the presidency in 1940 and turning the United States toward fascism. The six-episode series, created by Ed Burns and David Simon, follows the Finkel family in Weequahic, Newark, as anti-Semitism grows and Jews become second-class citizens under the new regime.
The show is a slow-burn drama that builds dread through small, domestic scenes rather than grand speeches. It is less about the mechanics of fascist policy and more about what it feels like to live in a country that stops protecting you. That focus is both its strength and its limitation.
Trailer, via HBO.
Winona Ryder Carries the Weight
Winona Ryder plays Evelyn Finkel, the mother of the family, and she gives the best performance in the series. She watches her husband, Herman, played by Morgan Spector, lose his business while her son Philip, played by Azhy Robertson, loses his childhood. Her grief is constant and quiet, and Ryder finds every beat of it.
John Turturro plays Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf, the conservative rabbi who endorses Lindbergh. His character is the moral fulcrum of the story — a man who believes Lindbergh can save Jews by keeping America out of the war, even as he enables the very persecution he fears. Turturro plays him with a mix of zeal and terror that makes him unforgettable.
Zoe Kazan plays Bess Finkel, Evelyn’s sister-in-law. The doubling of the role is a clever touch, though it sometimes blurs the lines between generations.
Anthony Boyle plays Alvin Levin, Philip’s cousin, and Caleb Malis plays Sandy Levin, Philip’s younger brother. Both actors find the right balance of childish innocence and early cruelty that comes with living under threat.
The Alternate History Works Because It Feels Real
The show does not waste time explaining how Lindbergh won. It simply shows the consequences. The family’s radio listens to Lindbergh’s speeches, and the news reports drift in through windows. The show trusts viewers to fill in the gaps between scenes, and that trust pays off.
The series is strongest when it stays close to the family. The scenes of Philip and his friends being hazed at school, or of his father losing his business, land harder than any exposition about treaties or alliances. The show knows that the personal is the political, and it sticks to that.
The Middle Episodes Drag
The middle of the series slows down. One episode stretches out a single event across too much screen time, and the pacing suffers for it.
The next episode picks back up, but it is still slower than the opening trio. The final episode delivers the emotional climax the series has been building toward, but it arrives after a stretch where the tension had cooled.
What the Series Gets Right
- The performances, especially Ryder’s.
- The sense of ordinary life being slowly stripped away.
- The way anti-Semitism is shown as a process, not a sudden arrival.
- The refusal to let the family become heroes or martyrs.
What it gets wrong is the middle stretch. The show loses momentum when it focuses on bureaucratic detail rather than human cost. That is a shame, because the first three episodes set a high bar.
Why It Matters
“The Plot Against America” is not an action thriller. It is a tragedy about a family that loses everything because the country decided they were not worth protecting. The show asks viewers to sit with discomfort, to watch bad things happen to good people without resolution. That is rare in television, and it is why the series lingers.
The series is a reminder that fascism is not a cartoon villain. It is a system that convinces ordinary people to look the other way. The show does not preach this lesson. It shows it.
The Verdict
“The Plot Against America” is a flawed but powerful piece of television. Its strengths — Ryder’s performance, the grounded sense of dread, the refusal to simplify history — outweigh its weaknesses. The middle episodes slow it down, but the first and last hours are some of the best drama HBO has produced.
The show is worth watching for anyone interested in how families survive when the world changes around them. It is not an easy watch, but it is a necessary one.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
